No, If you prefer Botrk instead of IE first you are just a noob Yasuo player, have a guarantee crit on every AA(and on his Q) is always better for 1 vs 1 potential at that point of the game, especially when BoTRK still isn't at his best cause enemies don't have a lot of health yet
The fact that a lot of champion don't make a lot of itemization choices, especially for crit is bad (there is a lack of crit items + Runaan is too weak to compete with PD/Statik because of lack of MS, + There is the need to an item with higher raw AD that can challenge IE as first item rush for a lot of AD based champs), but this just doesn't make Yasuo passive less bad anyway
The 100% guaranteed crits is the reason why he needed to be nerfed so hard to the ground that now he has a so low win rate and is useless most of the time. if you remove it (and substitue it with a better damage steroid connected to crit) you can finally buff the rest of his kit and taking him closer to what was the original concept(more of a bruiser that use the shield flow and windwall to not getting wpied out while he kill enemy rather than assassin that must go in for a kill on any kind of knock-up with no counterplay for the enemyor is completely destroyed)
Trynda has a gameplay that leave windows for counterplay since if he stay back he can't proc Fury, and the ulti is what it is, an ulti, so it has to be powerful