Why do so many people want to see Shyvana become Udyr?

Anyone else notice a large amount of the playerbase wants to see Shyvana become a right-click Champion akin to Udyr?

As a huge Shyvana fan, it kinda leaves me scratching my head. I, personally, would love to see Q gutted if it means we could get some power back into Flame Breath and Burnout. Making her an AoE powerhouse would be so much cooler than another Yi/Udyr/Vi...