"Offense outscales defense." Not in Garen's case. Late-game Garen's durability outscales offense.
Every time I face a Garen late-game, he is the toughest Champion in the game to bring down. High speed, reduces all incoming damage by a large percentage with his W, 20% bonus on any resists he builds, and passive health regeneration that makes Mundo's look like crap. Unless you have a Vayne, he's freaking obnoxious.
Oh, and did I mention he can still deal very competent damage with only a Youmu's Ghostblade and a Sunfire Cape as offense? He can build everything else as tank and have a higher EHP than anyone else, and STILL not be an ignorable team fight threat. And if you bring him down to 1% health? He'll be back up to full in about 30 seconds, without recalling.
I think Garen's last buff, where his passive got hugely buffed for his late-game, makes him too hard to kill. Coupled with a Warmog's Armor and Spirit Visage, he can easily regenerate over 100 HP PER SECOND just by hovering out of combat. And because of all his durability pieces, he can't be bursted without true damage, which only Vayne can provide well against such high health. And lastly, once you've nearly killed him, he just backs off, lets his teammates charge in now that you're on cooldown, and comes back within less than a minute at full power and finishes you off.
Pretty freaking lame...
"Just counterpick him!"
Umm, Team Builder does not permit counterpicks.
"Just kite him!"
Easier said than done compared to a Nasus when he's got a high speed boost and Youmu's Ghostblade to make him fast as all hell.
"Ignore him!"
Can't when I'm Katarina. Youmu's Ghostblade and Sunfire Cape also give him enough damage to require you to deal with him (so say nothing of his ultimate).
Bottom line is, tank Garen makes real tanks like Alistar, Leona, and Rammus look bad.
.
.
), of course he'll wreck you if you try to fight, but if you have blinks, well USE EM.
YOUR KNOCKUP AND KNOCKBACK ARE CHILD'S TOYS COMPARED TO HIS Q!!!