The thing that I don't understand is the reasoning behind the Juggernaut update. Those 4 champions were powerful in their own right when played with the right team compositions as well as in the hands of experienced players. Hell, I played a crap-ton of Skarner and Garen, and I was never disappointed with their current states in the game.
Then comes the Juggernaut update, and boy did it hurt. Not only did they buff those 4 into states where they weren't only stronger, but they were dominant picks. Additionally, they gave them items that amplified their new strengths, taking champions that are powerful and pushing them way over the edge. This exact same thing happened with the introduction of BotRK with the hyper-carries (
).
I personally think that Riot took things twice as far as they needed to. They should have either 1. Added the new items into the game, or 2. Rework the "Juggernauts". I personally think that adding the new items would be enough to work, because so many Fighters and Bruisers benefit from them now. I think Garen, Darius, Mordekaiser, and Skarner would have been perfectly fine with the new items and no reworks. The AP item update was great for Mordekaiser, so why not just leave him be?