BUHAHAHAHAHA! I saw this and shook my head. Not even surprised at the balance team at this point.
Garen. Q damage decreased at later ranks.
Garen's spun his way into top lane dominance as of late, and Q's early game damage leaves opponents with few opportunities to trade well. Q - Decisive Strike BASE DAMAGE 30/65/100/135/170 ⇒ 30/60/90/120/150
So you admit you the problem is his early game damage but nerf the Q damage at later ranks when laning phase is over?
[slayer-pantheon-thumbs]
in my worst match ups and it does wonders if you just regen and farm until your W gets to solid stats and you outscale your lane opponent.