New urgot
Actually, Riot said that Urgot
is a juggernaut, but i don't see Urgot do a 1v3 or 1v2 as Darius or Illaoi. None can't contest about Darius or Illaoi have a high damage at short distance, also they have possibility to contest 1v2 in certain cases, but have low movement speed and they have to take risk by receiving a probable damage to deal their damage. It is the samething for the new Urgot, low range, low movement speed, but the actual Urgot has not enough damage to compense his low movement. Urgot has difficulties to beat just one champion with his new kit because he clearly does not do enough damage. The Old Urgot could kill more easier a champion and taking less damage due to his damage reduction than the actual one. Also, the new Urgot is simple to counter : Just stay in the knee used to take less damage. Additionnaly, the new ult of Urgot is actually less useful than the old one as a tank, the old one could make you enter in a fight with damage reduction and fear ennemies, the new one does less than 100 dmg level 1 and it is only useful to kill 1 enemy with LESS than 25 % of his health if you don't miss it...
Other thing, his new Q needs CHARGE or more damage, the old Q of Urgot had a cd of 2 SECONDS, 85 % AD ratio, comparatively to the new Q that a cd of 12-8 seconds and it has a AD ratio of 70 % and it is harder to hit someone with it.
Overall, same if the new Urgot has many more sources of damage than the old one, the old Urgot could spam his Q, reduce the damage of enemy(his primary source of power) and slow enemy with his shield. Also, the abilities of old Urgot had more synergy between each other than actually, the new Urgot should have damage reduction when doing his E to have a kit where his abilities have a certain synergy.
As example, when a enemy was hit by E(corrosive charge), the enemy armor was grealty reduced with Black Cleaver(also slow if W activated) and that could cauze the enemy to go away from Urgot or the enemy would be hit by 2-3 Q, if the enemy was engaging, he would have done less damage due to damage reduction. Now, the new Urgot can't harass as before, he needs to be enoughly near the enemy to attack him and Urgot will without doubt take damage if he wants to really hurt his enemy to the risk of being killed.
Only few things on the new Urgot that is better than the old one, the new urgot can now clear faster wave with his AoE, deal maximum health damage and A CHANCE to execute an enemy low health.
at start.