Justify Picking Garen. I Never Can Now.
From Season 2 to Season 5 Garen was among my most played champions. However after his most recent rework I feel that I can never justify picking him. Overall I would say he is better after the changes, but I just feel like he's seriously lost his niche. I would pick him either to crush lane match ups of champions with weak early games like
and carry with the lead. Or to screw over
, in fact he was incredible against assassins, because he could just silence them the minute they try to jump in on his carries and he would assassinate them before the silence wore off.
Now his early game just isn't as strong anymore, sure he can still push people around and sustain himself with his passive, but he needs far more levels to scale now, were as prior he was extremely strong starting at level 1. He needs around level 5 to really start bringing the pain which gives the weak early champions he used to bend over far more time to scale up. Unless he's gotten far ahead which isn't as easy anymore, they'll be able to 1v1 him by level 11.
Yes he scales far better into late game but.....as I always said he's not a late game champion period, his kit is very straightforward, lacks consistent damage and teamfight presence. And to people who said before his late game sucked, it's because they just built him too tanky. Garen could get away with building only 1 defensive item for armor and resistance and his W would take care of the rest, then build damage, making his damage relevant throughout the game.
Another thing is I feel that I can no longer get away with blind picking the guy. It was always risky on Garen, but I got so many wins by dumping the "Teemo counters" and such. That's because against ranged match ups he could simply Spin to clear the wave, pop W to absorb harass and heal back up with his passive, so he couldn't be denied. Then I could flash Q combo them, but now that his silence is only 1.5 seconds and not 2.5 it's easier for people to get away. Also his Spin no longer wrecks minions as quickly as it used to making him take more damage then he used to before.
Just my thoughts. His winrate is good (probably from low mmr) but I just feel like there is normally a better pick.