Yasuo and Kalista have in common
That people complain about them regardless of their power level, because their kits are toxic.
Yasuo:
- I just ate your entire ult, probably even by accident!
- I'm manaless so even if the opponent outplays me in lane, I just have to wait until he goes oom!
- I have a shield, despite being manaless!
- I get double crit chance because rolling a crit is #outplayed!
- I can dash at any displacement including knockbacks, pulls and your own team's Trundle pillar!
- I have infinite dashes!
He's sitting at 46% winrate and people still think he's overpowered because they hate him so much.
Kalista:
- I'm immune to any melee champion in the game except Udyr!
- I can soulbind without permission unless the target burns flash!
- I can stun my own support in battle!
- I deal % max health damage! (Always a crowd pleaser)
- I have infinitely stacking damage!
She's sitting at 45% winrate and people finally stopped picking her but they still hate her. If she ever becomes viable, the board will drown in tears. She may end up being another Poppy, intentionally left unviable because the alternative would be worse.
Gnar and Fizz may have the same issue, but they actually are OP at the moment. I expect people to whine about them even after they get nerfed though.