oh look another hyper carry/assassin meta thanks riot
because everyone was so glad to play in that meta right?
because everyone was so glad to play in that meta right?
They don't care about game health, all they're out to do is promote their flashy over-the-top bullshit playmakers so Reddit has something to beat off to. After a few tiny nerfs, the Cinderhulk meta was the most healthy and accepted meta we've had in years. Does anyone really not remember how happy people were when most (yes most) of the roster was viable and saw play since the "I'm going to kill you in half a second and there's nothing you can do about it" champs weren't occupying every lane?
Who was upset? The flashy bullshit spammers, the balance team, and the spectators. Only one of these three unhappy groups should have any affect on the next decision, and that's the first. What should have happened? Maybe learn how to play instead of trying to look like someone in the LCS and mindlessly mash buttons to look flashy while you try to kill someone? You can't oneshot a tank; that's kinda what they're for...try building some armor pen and stop trying to 1v1 them for god's sake.
But it's their game, why shouldn't Riot have a say in this?
Because last I checked, they want to preserve League as a player-focused game, and that's just laughable when you read what this "unbiased" balance team wants to do with something healthy to make it more appealing to watch. Just look at the notes for the patch coming out! They don't even try to fucking hide that they want flashy plays at Worlds - they do all but flat out admit to it! Why should they get a say in what the game should be when they aren't trustworthy enough to tell the truth for a single patch??
Spectators are an important part of League though.
Why? Why are they given focus at all? More importantly, why is Riot opening discussion with them for what they want to see? Is it any wonder why Riot favors third party sites and shit like Ask.fm? It allows for non-players to submit their opinions when they shouldn't be given a single ounce of care. It would be like someone who only watches basketball and has never played in their life suggesting to the NBA how they play the game. I'm sorry, but your opinion shouldn't matter, and shouldn't mean anything.
They like to talk to these people because the playerbase mocks and criticizes them for decisions that don't make sense or want to avoid contact when we point out what they've lied about or showing them in detail what and where they have been wrong about and refuse to do anything about it.
Look at all the white knights coming to defend the lie they want to live in.
They don't care about game health, all they're out to do is promote their flashy over-the-top bullshit playmakers so Reddit has something to beat off to. After a few tiny nerfs, the Cinderhulk meta was the most healthy and accepted meta we've had in years. Does anyone really not remember how happy people were when most (yes most) of the roster was viable and saw play since the "I'm going to kill you in half a second and there's nothing you can do about it" champs weren't occupying every lane?
Who was upset? The flashy bullshit spammers, the balance team, and the spectators. Only one of these three unhappy groups should have any affect on the next decision, and that's the first. What should have happened? Maybe learn how to play instead of trying to look like someone in the LCS and mindlessly mash buttons to look flashy while you try to kill someone? You can't oneshot a tank; that's kinda what they're for...try building some armor pen and stop trying to 1v1 them for god's sake.
But it's their game, why shouldn't Riot have a say in this?
Because last I checked, they want to preserve League as a player-focused game, and that's just laughable when you read what this "unbiased" balance team wants to do with something healthy to make it more appealing to watch. Just look at the notes for the patch coming out! They don't even try to fucking hide that they want flashy plays at Worlds - they do all but flat out admit to it! Why should they get a say in what the game should be when they aren't trustworthy enough to tell the truth for a single patch??
Spectators are an important part of League though.
Why? Why are they given focus at all? More importantly, why is Riot opening discussion with them for what they want to see? Is it any wonder why Riot favors third party sites and shit like Ask.fm? It allows for non-players to submit their opinions when they shouldn't be given a single ounce of care. It would be like someone who only watches basketball and has never played in their life suggesting to the NBA how they play the game. I'm sorry, but your opinion shouldn't matter, and shouldn't mean anything.
They like to talk to these people because the playerbase mocks and criticizes them for decisions that don't make sense or want to avoid contact when we point out what they've lied about or showing them in detail what and where they have been wrong about and refuse to do anything about it.
Look at all the white knights coming to defend the lie they want to live in.
Okay. I don't really see how Cinderhulk meta was the most healthy and accepted meta in years. I guess it's because I wasn't on the boards really at that time, but personally I hate the fact that NO ONE EVER DIES in that meta. Plus, I fail to see how all assassins are bullshit spammers. Last I checked, tanks were the easiest champions to play in the game because they don't die.
That's just my opinion though.
Also, I fail to see how your post is unbiased. Everyone is biased. It can't be helped. Your post clearly is ranting against assassins and how Cinderhulk meta is over (and I pray to Ryze that it never returns).
This is the game RIOT made. If you don't like it, stop playing. They can change the meta as they wish.
And, yes, armor was nerfed. Yes, a few assassins received small buffs (okay Lee's buff wasn't too small), but that doesn't mean assassin meta is back.
If spectators are an important part of LoL, then how is Riot supposed to attract spectators? By having a tanky af Sejuani and Zac punch and cc each other for 20 minutes until they run away to avoid dying. Tanky junglers were kinda OP in Cinderhulk meta. They were basically assassins with health and defense.
But, since almost everyone was tanky, no one ever died except those who wanted to play assassins or non-tanks. I don't like playing as tanks. Not one bit.
tl;dr: Your entire post was biased, as is mine. Tanks never die and Riot wants LCS to be somewhat interesting. No one wants to watch tanks just cc each other for the entire game and never die.
Okay. I don't really see how Cinderhulk meta was the most healthy and accepted meta in years. I guess it's because I wasn't on the boards really at that time, but personally I hate the fact that NO ONE EVER DIES in that meta. Plus, I fail to see how all assassins are bullshit spammers. Last I checked, tanks were the easiest champions to play in the game because they don't die.
That's just my opinion though.
Also, I fail to see how your post is unbiased. Everyone is biased. It can't be helped. Your post clearly is ranting against assassins and how Cinderhulk meta is over (and I pray to Ryze that it never returns).
This is the game RIOT made. If you don't like it, stop playing. They can change the meta as they wish.
And, yes, armor was nerfed. Yes, a few assassins received small buffs (okay Lee's buff wasn't too small), but that doesn't mean assassin meta is back.
If spectators are an important part of LoL, then how is Riot supposed to attract spectators? By having a tanky af Sejuani and Zac punch and cc each other for 20 minutes until they run away to avoid dying. Tanky junglers were kinda OP in Cinderhulk meta. They were basically assassins with health and defense.
But, since almost everyone was tanky, no one ever died except those who wanted to play assassins or non-tanks. I don't like playing as tanks. Not one bit.
tl;dr: Your entire post was biased, as is mine. Tanks never die and Riot wants LCS to be somewhat interesting. No one wants to watch tanks just cc each other for the entire game and never die.
So why do you think an entire class of champion should be bad just because you find them boring to watch in the LCS?
So why do you think an entire class of champion should be bad just because you find them boring to watch in the LCS?
not to mention how was cindermeta balanced in anyway? pick tanks or lose wow balance
I thought it was "get Devourer sated or lose".
I thought it was "get Devourer sated or lose".
considering poppy amumu and elise are in the top 6 win rate of junglers i dont think so, thought it's synergy with kayle and a few others is pretty disgusting
...You do realize that Poppy does build devoured when she jungles, right?
http://champion.gg/champion/Poppy/Jungle
Only two of the top seven junglers don't build devourer, only Amumu and Elise don't, and Elise was over buffed.
It's only fitting that Poppy builds devourer, because whoever picks Poppy is going straight for the souls of the players when she ganks.
She ganks for keeps.
What? The tank meta was the most diverse meta we have had in a long time.
Also pick adcs or lose wow balance. This isn't an argument of class balance. Teams with tanks win more games, just like teams with ADCs win more games. It's just good strategy to have a strong front line.
What? The tank meta was the most diverse meta we have had in a long time.
Also pick adcs or lose wow balance. This isn't an argument of class balance. Teams with tanks win more games, just like teams with ADCs win more games. It's just good strategy to have a strong front line.
tanks are just stupid op if you stack aoe cc, had a game yesterday lost every lane i sucked jg my worst roll but we had amumu malphite won every fight even tho we were wayyy behind in gold
Tanks weren't dealing the damage though, if amumu and malphite both ult your team then you've got another 10 seconds before they can kill you.
I found it in your match history... to name a few reasons why you won that game.
Their janna was way behind, your talon was way ahead, they weren't warding for shit, the enemy nunu had a 0 MR "tank" build, your teams average elo was low plat high gold while theirs was mid gold, Fiora farmed to get ahead but didn't do anything with that lead, You had a better teamfight comp, their comp had little synergy,
Tanks weren't dealing the damage though, if amumu and malphite both ult your team then you've got another 10 seconds before they can kill you.
I found it in your match history... to name a few reasons why you won that game.
Their janna was way behind, your talon was way ahead, they weren't warding for shit, the enemy nunu had a 0 MR "tank" build, your teams average elo was low plat high gold while theirs was mid gold, Fiora farmed to get ahead but didn't do anything with that lead, You had a better teamfight comp, their comp had little synergy,
A couple of things, why would nunu build mr before stacking armor since our 2 main threats were ad(and our ap was behind as hell), you are a fool if you think the difference between mid-high gold and low plat is anything for most players. They actually had decent disengage synergy with 3 good disengages but they usually died before they got it off which is why I hate janna. Talon was losing lane and started 1-3 he only got ahead as the game went on if i am not mistaken. We had the better teamfight because of our tanks, no other class can afford to play so mediocre and be so effective on the game like i did, don't think i had 1 successful gank all game but it didn't matter ult in fights win.
none of the reasons i listed directly caused the loss for their team, but i'm fairly certain they all contributed, and the "tanks OP" argument you are making here is just poorly thought out because you didn't analyze why you won.
Nunu shouldn't rush MR, but after ~40 min to have 0 is still failing and allowed you and malphite to deal damage even when behind. If he doesn't counter build you he may as well not be ahead at all. He counterbuilt the talon but i'm betting talon wasn't bothering with the nunu at all focusing instead on the trist or fiora. This means his build was questionable.
The differences in skill are present, even if not drastic i can bet on that contributing.
They had janna for disengage and the trist ult, which helps, but the nunu and fiora probably weren't contributing to that effort. Janna blows engaging enemies out of nunu or ori ult. Fiora wants to all in teamfight, while her team doesn't want to. There are two anti-synergies in their team comp. 2 engage and 2 disengage doesn't lend itself to victory very well.
Your team comp on the other hand was entirely oriented around the mid game. As picks start to happen talon and blitzcrank excel, meaning that combined with the enemies poor warding you will start to come back from your losing lanes through pick potential. When skirmishes happen and later teamfights you have great initiation, and if one of your initiates gets denied through their disengage, you have more engage. You have more engage tools than they have disengage (bandage toss, righteous glory, malphite ult, talon flank, blitz grab) when combined with ezreals+malphites poke means you will always have good initiations to take.
We had the better teamfight because of our tanks, no other class can afford to play so mediocre and be so effective on the game like i did, don't think i had 1 successful gank all game but it didn't matter ult in fights win.
Right, which means the enemy didn't punish your poor early game enough to win, and your superior mid and late game carried you through. Your win condition on amumu isn't to gank well, it's to win teamfights, so it sounds like you played to your win conditions better than they did theirs.
You can lose lane but win game, winning lane is not a prerequisite to winning game.
Okay. I don't really see how Cinderhulk meta was the most healthy and accepted meta in years. I guess it's because I wasn't on the boards really at that time, but personally I hate the fact that NO ONE EVER DIES in that meta. Plus, I fail to see how all assassins are bullshit spammers. Last I checked, tanks were the easiest champions to play in the game because they don't die.
That's just my opinion though.
Also, I fail to see how your post is unbiased. Everyone is biased. It can't be helped. Your post clearly is ranting against assassins and how Cinderhulk meta is over (and I pray to Ryze that it never returns).
This is the game RIOT made. If you don't like it, stop playing. They can change the meta as they wish.
And, yes, armor was nerfed. Yes, a few assassins received small buffs (okay Lee's buff wasn't too small), but that doesn't mean assassin meta is back.
If spectators are an important part of LoL, then how is Riot supposed to attract spectators? By having a tanky af Sejuani and Zac punch and cc each other for 20 minutes until they run away to avoid dying. Tanky junglers were kinda OP in Cinderhulk meta. They were basically assassins with health and defense.
But, since almost everyone was tanky, no one ever died except those who wanted to play assassins or non-tanks. I don't like playing as tanks. Not one bit.
tl;dr: Your entire post was biased, as is mine. Tanks never die and Riot wants LCS to be somewhat interesting. No one wants to watch tanks just cc each other for the entire game and never die.
I only read your tl;dr, and here's my response to it. Cinderhulk was the thinking man's meta. It was all about strategy and rotations instead of "I'm going to kill you in half a second and there's fuck-all you can do about it." Ya know, the way a League should be (by popular opinion). But if you just want it to be go in, mash all your buttons, "OMG I'M SO GOOD AT GAMEZ", more power to you I guess.
I only read your tl;dr, and here's my response to it. Cinderhulk was the thinking man's meta. It was all about strategy and rotations instead of "I'm going to kill you in half a second and there's fuck-all you can do about it." Ya know, the way a League should be (by popular opinion). But if you just want it to be go in, mash all your buttons, "OMG I'M SO GOOD AT GAMEZ", more power to you I guess.
Fair enough, I suppose that IS how my tl'dr makes it sound. ^^;
Seriously though, I don't really see how Cinderhulk was the thinking man's meta. It consisted mostly of tanks that out-damaged assassins. There's a serious problem with a tank doing the job of an assassin better than an actual assassin.
Strategy then seemed to mostly be, "QUICK CC THE OTHER TEAM TO HELL AND NEVER DIE BECAUSE TANK." While assassins WERE kinda OP in assassin meta, they were pretty much useless in Cinderhulk meta.
Fair enough, I suppose that IS how my tl'dr makes it sound. ^^;
Seriously though, I don't really see how Cinderhulk was the thinking man's meta. It consisted mostly of tanks that out-damaged assassins. There's a serious problem with a tank doing the job of an assassin better than an actual assassin.
Strategy then seemed to mostly be, "QUICK CC THE OTHER TEAM TO HELL AND NEVER DIE BECAUSE TANK." While assassins WERE kinda OP in assassin meta, they were pretty much useless in Cinderhulk meta.
I agree that never dying makes for a pretty boring game, but it also makes for pretty much the only meta where ADC's aren't completely irrelevant, because their job is to buy a LW and wreck the tanks. And what tanks are you referring to that do more damage than an assassin? Sejuani maybe, but she got nerfed into the ground pretty quickly. Maokai? Used to do damage but now nobody even buys him a RoA anymore because Righteous is so much better. I can't think of any tanks other than Sejuani that have any good damage scalings when built full tank. And on champions like Vi or Rek'Sai who actually can do damage, if you decide to build damage you're no longer unkillable, so that throws your first argument out the window, doesn't it?
My sentiment exactly.
Not only do they butcher tanks by a large margin for no reasons other than "assassins should be able to kill tanks faster" stance (laughable I know), they buff assassins and bruisers because they make LCS flashy plays$$$$$$.
In a MOBA like this, the supposed game balance should be:
The post-nerf Cinderhulk is not perfect (since tanks dealt a lot more damage than they should), but its associated tank meta is arguably one of the most balanced metas in the history of LOL, because almost all of the above applies in the meta. Riot ruined things over by making armor less useful and making assassins and bruisers have to ability to kill tanks when they shouldn't be able to.
If an Assassin doesn't have an escape or poke, then they have to have massive 100-0 damage in order to be effective and that is generally not fun to play against. Not to mention they would then be garbage at anything that isn't killing an isolated, squishy target.
You misread my comment obviously. I mean assassins should not be rewarded an escape if they fail to engage or assassinate. An escape should be a reward, not a "get-out-of-jail-free" card.
I also disagree with your stance on poking. Many assassins already have massive AOE damage to obliterate squishy carries (that's plural) if they engage properly. They do not need high damage pokes to do the job. If an assassin relies on pokes to do his assassination, why don't Riot just make him a mage? A mage relies on pokes whilst an assassin relies on quick engage, gapclosing and assassinating, not pokes. I even listed one exception to this "no pokes for assassins" rule: if a poke ability does not do massive damage and opens the door to engaging assassination (like Katarina's Q), the "no poke" rule does not apply.
Also, tell this to Talon and Rengar, who have ultimates that allow them to do either one of the following only: escape/going all-in and assassinating one/more target(s), without escaping (or escaping conditionally with enemy minions nearby, using their regular non-ultimate ability/passive). Tell that to Akali, who basically either goes all-in or dies unless there are enemy minions around, too.
Your post words it all so well, i have the negative trait of ridiculising things too much but the sentiment is the same. Respect to you and an upvote. :)
p.s. http://boards.na.leagueoflegends.com/en/c/gameplay-balance/rwkgIspj-so-why-you-can-not-play-a-normal-without-being-in-lcs-finals? similar topic, from a bit of another direction, ofcourse downvoted, what else.
To start I agree with you completely. The majority of players is not who they listen too. They are balancing based ENTIRELY off of the LCS.
BUT
I do have to say the reason the spectators are getting say is because in reality thats their plan to sustain the game. Because if LCS is popular enough pros make money, if pros make money people want to do that for a job so they will start playing the game hoping for that shot. Spectators make the game profitable just like with your NBA analogy... The players are putting on the show so that the spectators buy tickets... and jerseys... and food etc... spectators and pros are the most important thing for them right now and if you aren't in that group then Riot wants you to shut the fuck up and play the game. They don't care if its not healthy, balanced, or fun for people under diamond 1. Period.
It's better early and worse late. I think that's a trade off a lot of people would be willing to make.
It's better early and worse late. I think that's a trade off a lot of people would be willing to make.
100 hp early.... that's not really compensation for the loss of 10% hp from our item. Overall this was a tank jg nerf. edit Cinderhulk was probably the most balanced jg item we had. lol
thats not true, i think warrior is the most balanced...
thats not true, i think warrior is the most balanced...
Pretty sure warrior is underpowered atm. It gives the least utility. Yeah you get cdr but it is massively and armor pen. But it is massively outclassed by devourer. So it rarely sees use anyways.
[{quoted}](name=Malicious Fury,realm=NA,application-id=3ErqAdtq,discussion-id=HrALzjwh,comment-id=000500000002000000000000,timestamp=2015-08-20T07:04:41.048+0000)
Bro, you gotta stop posting pictures of yourself on league. smh
Except the people have calculated that devourer is the best item early and late.
I tried to click your link where you found such calculations, but it turned out to just be a meme picture.
There's a number of them on the forums, you just have to look.
My sentiment exactly...
This thread is just people not realizing that bruisers just got super buffed this patch and it is nowhere close to an Assassin meta. Randuins now screws over Yasuo even more and you idiots still think it's going to be an assassin meta lol
Shhhhhhh let them keep picking Yasuo
People whined about tanks and bruisers returning and all so there ya go
Back to being annoyed as an immobile tank/bruiser main
People whined about tanks and bruisers returning and all so there ya go
Back to being annoyed as an immobile tank/bruiser main
After a few nerf to Cinder, it was pretty Ok, it was actually enjoyable, then Dev came in and boom, League is in a shitty place again, and riot is doing nothing to fix it. Dat 5 ad nerf on Kayle, ffs.
I enjoy the hypocrisy. Heaven forbid a 5v5 team fight last longer than 3 seconds and champions get to live long enough to use more than one skill rotation.
Back to watching Zed two shot everyone by hitting R. That is real skill I guess.
Dumbass, ever heard of qss/zhonya/cc him, zed is the hardest champ to play with the most counters.
he's definitely not the hardest champion but yes, there are a lot of ways around him.
can't say that zed mains will get mad that someone pointed out their skilless champ is skilless
Tanks don't make #lcsbigplays so the twitter and crowd can go nuts. I'd be happy if they just removed ranged ad champs.
maybe the shitty bronze crowds that make up most LCS watchers and think that they'll get plat or diamond some day. I for one love seeing crazy initiations from cinderhulk junglers that CC the entire enemy team or isolate the carries from their frontline.
renekton/malphite/rammus plays <3
tanks are basically ok so we have to kill the ad carry quickly *takes their tank asss and runs into the ad carry cc him to hell kill him and yea that was so fun. assasins make it look good and fun, but idk.... i dont like tanks anyway
ok, have fun in bronze where nobody picked tanks even in the tank era and now you get 1 shotted by assassins and 90% crit ADCs even easier.
first of all im not bronze second of all i watch some of my bronze friend games and look at his match history and they always pick tanks so idk what ur talking about cant argue with someone that likes tanks and tells u to have fun in bronze
I am happy that tanks aren't going to be as strong.
I miss the assassin meta because it seemed like positioning and teamfights were more important.
Not just 'I'm going to build tank and then wet noodle you to death'
Or 'I'm just going to turret dive you because turrets don't matter.'
Tank meta has bored the hell out of me.
I am happy that tanks aren't going to be as strong.
I miss the assassin meta because it seemed like positioning and teamfights were more important. Not just 'I'm going to build tank and then wet noodle you to death' Or 'I'm just going to turret dive you because turrets don't matter.' Tank meta has bored the hell out of me.
So you prefer to spend half the game in a grey screen because you had 0.5 seconds to react to the assassins ?
There is no skill in the wet noodle contest. There is no risk for going in, because you take forever to kill and can literally just WALK out of the fight with more than half your HP left. Teamfights devolve into just which ADC and APC do more damage overall, because whichever team runs out of tanks first loses.
In the assassin meta, positioning and reactions matter. If you get out of position, you deserve to die, not just take half your health in damage and walk away laughing. If you don't react to a flank, you deserve to die. You got outplayed. Being able to be forgiven for playing bad just because you picked the beefiest champion you could shouldn't be the way the game works.
There is no skill in the wet noodle contest. There is no risk for going in, because you take forever to kill and can literally just WALK out of the fight with more than half your HP left. Teamfights devolve into just which ADC and APC do more damage overall, because whichever team runs out of tanks first loses.
In the assassin meta, positioning and reactions matter. If you get out of position, you deserve to die, not just take half your health in damage and walk away laughing. If you don't react to a flank, you deserve to die. You got outplayed. Being able to be forgiven for playing bad just because you picked the beefiest champion you could shouldn't be the way the game works.
Not what I asked...
and you think the assassin meta took any skill? you could kill anyone with half a rotation, that position you talk about, that was important when you COULDN'T kill everyone in a blink of an eye In the tank meta, assassins were what they were supposed to be, sneaky guys who went to the backline to kill the squishies In the assassin meta, everyone is squishy so no need for positioning or strategy, just jump in, kill everyone and dont even bother jumping out because everyone is already dead
And at the very least, in the tank meta people had FUN, both teams, both players in a fight Not just the Zed that R'ed from krugs and killed the enemy before he could do anything about it
You know why counterplay is important? so the game is fun for both, not just the one playing the champ That is why you can destroy enemy gangplank barrels That is why Sions charge is hard to turn and block on terrain That is why certain abilities can escape Jarvan wall
You know what DOESN'T have counterplay? something that kills you before you can react!
(
)
You know why people don't complain about
or
so much? because they are not toxic
They have counterplay, you can stop them with a bit of skill with any champ, they don't kill you before you can react to it
But Zed? either go thank or have Zonyas
THAT is why people liked the tank meta,because everyone had a chance, because everyone could be played, because there was always a way to win despite the champions a team was composed of
You got bored from tank meta? Most people got sick and tired of looking at the grey screen most of the game