Whoever did the changes to Rightous Glory

Should really rethink if removing the Valor's Reward is a logical decision because now thematically it does not fit with the build path.

If you really don't want Righteous Glory to have that passive just make a new catalyst item specialized for tanks that doesn't have the active. Maybe something like Catalyst plus Glacial Shroud. The only problem with having something like this is that it would be godly on Taric but if you are worried about buffing Taric then that's your problem.