[New Item]Arcanium Quire

CoolKnightST··3 votes·722 views

An new AP support item designed to make their pick potentional stronger. I would like to get some feedback here regarding the ballance for such an item.

  • Recipe: item 3801 + item 3108 + 750 + (=2200)
  • Stats: +250 Health, +100% Base Health Regen, +40 Ability power, +10% Cooldown Reduction
  • UNIQUE Passive: Slows are 20% stronger (can't cap over 99%).

Thoughts?

17 Comments

Sun Mythic1 votes

Probably will be bought in mid sometimes too

CoolKnightST1 votes

I honnestly think that would be ok. I can't think about an direct example where it would be broken on. It doesn't give a lot of ability power for scaling supports to utilize it while lane bullies often doesn't have the slows to buff in the first place. Those are better off with item 3116. Same goes for champions that spam abilities.

Not sure if we can allow item 3116 to stack with it tho.

FurretHasAGlock1 votes

make it build into rylais?

CoolKnightST1 votes

Rylais does something compleetly different and wouldn't make sence add all.

FurretHasAGlock1 votes

{quoted}

Rylais does something compleetly different and wouldn't make sence add all.

Yes, however, possibly make the passive the same as rylai's, the increased slow, honestly, would cause problems. thresh's box would make champs unable to move, as its 99% slow, as with zileans E, at max level. It would basically be another semi-hard CC to those kind of kits, and considering thresh, the slow is WAY too much CC on him if it snares.

CoolKnightST1 votes

I had plans to add an cap to 99% to it. This means the item is useless on Thresh his ult.

With that change it basicly useless for zilean too unless they want a 99% an rank earlyer.

The main champions I want this item to benefit on is Lulu Karma Sona. I actualy feel bad for Zilean that he can't benefit from the item.

A lot other supports like Janna Nami Soraka will benefit from this too.

AyRe CoNteMpT1 votes

so a 30% slow now slows for 36% ?

CoolKnightST1 votes

Jup

Nekusen1 votes

it's a support item, we need mage items

Erockandroll1 votes

That items is going to get balanced around the highest abuse case. And be made crap afterwards.

And if a few champs are having problems with their slows, it's better to buff their kit, not their item. Partually because an item that can affect slows that cheaply, will be abused by other laners. (not just support.) And even if it wasn't supports still wouldn't take it, because it's way to greedy. Over a more supportive item like Banner of command, or Cruciple.

CoolKnightST1 votes

I think the ballance itself won't be that problematic as you might think. I give an example with the champion Lulu:

As a solo laner Lulu is ballanced arround waveclear, peel, enchanter & lategame sustain damage. On this moment their is little to no differents between the functionality of her support kit as wel as her solo lane kit. The more AP means more utility she can provide.

Her support role is ballanced arround peel & enchanting. In theory her pick potentional suppose to be better with item 3092 but their is litterly the only differents we have right now. On this patch even that differents has been taken away.

Rather than letting supports get cc scaling with their AP they have to spend gold for it. Something like this is a lot easyer to ballance. Offcourse midlane Lulu can still get this item but let's think about a theoretical build ones item 3092 is no longer an option:

  • item 3165 (2550 gold)
  • item 3158 (800 gold)
  • Add this moment sololane lulu need to decide is she need:
    • Waveclear with item 3089 (3800 gold) or item 3285 (3200 gold)
    • More pick potentional with this new item (2200 gold)
  • Lategame items like item 3157 item 3135 are probaly a must go add some point.
  • Than their is room for one more item like item 3100 item 3504 item 3102 item 3143 item 3089 item 3285, this new item

I don't think it's a good idea to go this item early on a solo lane lulu because of the fact she loses so many AP she won't be able to waveclear properly. As a 6th item it could be intressting but even than you could agrue that when going an AP item it's better to take something that can trigger the 10% more momentspeed on Whimsy (what's even possible with lich bane when having Deathcap in that build).

item 3116 has show that a support can legit buy these type of items. The fact that this item cost 1000 gold less than that would sure make it worth. It gives health what's also pretty intressting.

Nekusen1 votes

the thing is that support already have ways of getting CDR, the ones that need it the most right now are mages

Kaeblen1 votes

so, I'm going to suggest a different item; a completely different item; an outrageous one:

  • +35 AD
  • +45 AP
  • 10% CDR
  • Unique Passive: +20% missile speed for all non-aa missles.
  • recipe: item 1026 +item 3133 + 750 (=2700)

this item gives hybrid scaling, and therefore can't give very high values (Akali Jax and a few others prevent that). Even so, the increase missle speed would be an entirely unique and noticeable change to gameplay. Ashe gets a faster ult. Ezreal probably gets nerfed because of it Soraka can hit her Q easier and the list goes on.

FurretHasAGlock1 votes

{quoted}

so, I'm going to suggest a different item; a completely different item; an outrageous one:

  • +35 AD
  • +45 AP
  • 10% CDR
  • Unique Passive: +20% missile speed for all non-aa missles.
  • recipe: item 1026 +item 3133 + 750 (=2700)

this item gives hybrid scaling, and therefore can't give very high values (Akali Jax and a few others prevent that). Even so, the increase missle speed would be an entirely unique and noticeable change to gameplay. Ashe gets a faster ult. Ezreal probably gets nerfed because of it Soraka can hit her Q easier and the list goes on.

Yea, no. XD

CoolKnightST1 votes

Riot already stated they will never implement scaling missle speed in the game. It had something todo with been unhealthy for a reaction based FPS game.

Secondly, we already have plenty of hybrid items in the game. Hybrid items where always a pain in the ass to ballance out. Just look how item 3124 played out. It's probaly in the most ballanced state riot ever managed to rework it but it's still has really tricky power curves that riot has to keep an eye on. Same goes for item 3146 actualy.

Kaeblen1 votes

yeah, I didn't think my idea would be one that would actually get implemented.

I know the issue with hybrid items, but do you know why they are opposed to scaling missle speed? I know Ahri's Charm scales with missle speed, so... just a reaction time problem?

CoolKnightST1 votes

It's not only reaction time. It also has todo with Frame per Second (FPS) & ping. Let's say you play vs someone that has 100 FPS & 30 ping vs someone with 50 FPS & 50 ping. The first guy would be add a serious advantage. Even if the second guy is better add the game. It most likely the second guy will lose that fight. It's never a good thing skill get determined who has the most money to spend on a good pc.

Let compair it with sports. Let's say guy A has better shoes than guy B but guy B is better add the game. It would really shitty that guy A wins that simply because he has better shoes. In an online game the example of better shoes has more impact on the game (FPS, ping). So the developers need to be carefull how many factors they make dynamic that impact how good your FPS & ping is.

More from Gameplay

More by CoolKnightST