[{quoted}](name=Full Moon Ace,realm=NA,application-id=3ErqAdtq,discussion-id=9Pv7v6hv,comment-id=00040000,timestamp=2017-03-17T17:29:04.109+0000)
I honestly think AP Scaling Utility is probably the dumbest thing in the game. Especially on champs designed or reworked into supports and not intended for midlaners.
If they just gave Sona better base values, and increased her skill floor, and made her able to push instead of getting shoved, or even give her cc. She would be a better champ. Her kit is extremely binary as she only has one skill shot in her entire kit and the rest of her abilities are auto-targetted, as a result, it's hard to give her a satisfying kit without having her smush everyone in Bronze. Her highest winrate build is literally rush Lich Bane, a Luden's cap it off with a deathcap and void, and then maybe another AP Item or Ardent. Unbohlievable.
In her current state, Sona is more consistent, but more risky, and less effective Karma. Rework her Q so it's slightly less consistent, give it more value, and give her her auras back. If Riot is an advocate against invisible power, then they wouldn't have tacked on every little thing in the world on Lee Sin's kit.
The team was smaller when they did the rework on Sona ages ago and I highly doubt they'd do the same thing if they were handling her again. Not going to argue Lee Sin because it's irrelevant to this post.
I don't think her auras need to return as they just would add onto the damage creep and doesn't deter the Lich Bane building (if anything that actually will make it more prevalent because it increased AD/AP back then). Her kit is binary imo because you're not forced to play around with anything other than Staccato, and its influence on choice is so non-impactful that you'll mostly be going for Q Staccato 90% of the time. Pre-rework there was no semblance of choice either, so it was just as binary (the heal was pretty strong back then and even if you could argue the case of less damage taken on W, it wasn't necessary to do like for shielding champions). Even in this thread it was stated "people ignore that I have a slow." It requires too much setup to get her soft CC for not enough returns. To me, that basically says her E needs a rework along with a powershift from Q to Staccato so you're not losing out for making impactful choices.
I'd like to see more posts like yours that mention directly about Lich Bane and what exactly should be done over where Sona should stand instead of "generalist with poke and heal and ult engage" which was already there pre-rework. She was literally just stronger at what she did.