You say all this but I don't see a single champ in the game with a healing cleanse and bonus gold value just for cs'ing.
There is you know... cleanse...
Or the 2 items that cleanse
Or the other champions that have a built in cleanse like Alistar
The heal is just a heal, one of oldest mechanics in the entire game
Now you put them together in a clever way and tadaa you have GP oranges, an ability only he has access to, created with already existing mechanics.
TF also gets bonus gold for cs-ing
Pyke gets bonus gold for killing people with ult
Getting bonus gold was a mechanic on an item called "Avarice blade"
The coin/targons support item also gives you gold just for cs-ing in a sense
Again, the mechanics were already in the game but they were put together into his Q and potential to get more value through barrels
-> Good design
I mean, you're blatantly wrong but how many times can a man say "Unable to be targeted DOES NOT MEAN unable to be damaged"?
There is not a single other champion in the entire game that has true stealth
Nor has there ever been a champion with that mechanic
It's something league has never seen and for good reason because if it was a thing then what the hell is true sight here for
It just screws up the game the same way easily accessable GW screws with heal-powerbudgets
We don't need it, it's literally only on one champion in the entire games history, just remove it and put normal stealth on it so it fits with the rest of the mechanics in the game that have been balanced the past decade
Lazy design it's what it is
There sure as hell was a way to just make it a stealth and compensate it elsewhere but the designer wanted to have an easy job
You can't target anyone in stealth. Hell, ever since the stealth changes You couldn't target Akali via pinks, anyway. The ONLY thing that changed was using targeted abilities under turret. That's LITERALLY the only thing, and THIS is the hill we lay down and die on? This, when we have Pyke that literally gives full kill gold value to people that got assists? Or how Bard can just Zhonyas entire teams, allies and enemies alike, from semi-global ranges, against their will? Or TK who can just up and grab someone, then run away with them while you can't hit them because they're inside him? We say "This is too much" on the obscured effect? Really?
Hell, even Ivern can turn 1 jg buff into 2, as well as just make a fucking bush anywhere on the map, but you guys get your panties in a bunch about "the RulES" over an assassin that isn't even a threat until Diamond elo.
Yes that is what stealth is here for so why does she need true stealth?
So she is "UnIqUe" or what?
Also TF ult / Lee reveal etc. grant true sight. They counter stealth but haha jokes on you Akali has true stealth now!
Stop beating around the bush, she doesn't need it and you know very well that she doesn't
Pyke giving full kill gold is an adaptation (a big one) to the already mentioned gold generation mechanics we used to have in the game.
It's a pretty new thing but still leans on existing mechanics.
The game has never seen true stealth in Akalis case, it's literally 100% out of the blue new and thus, there is no counter to it.
Bard R is literally just the zhonyeas mechanic, or Lissandra R without damage on AOE. It was already here, it just got changed.
Also Bard is a pretty well designed champion even though he introduced the wall mechanic.
THAT one was a completely new one since league had never any mechanic concerning traveling through walls (excluding dashes). It was a risky shot but it came out well and spawned new champions/design with that mechanic (Kayn / Talon)
Yeah that one is an example of a completely new mechanic introduced into the game and coming out well at the end.
The TK thing is already a problem I don't know what you are talking about, that one is just trash design. Same with Kalista R, the mechanic doesn't work.
Ivern is a special case in that his mechanic cannot be used in different designs, it's literally just him that can use it.
Also I don't care how viable Akali is in any elo, if a mechanic/design is trash then it's trash
Look at Kalista, she is nowhere viable but still a problem.
He literally turns a kill with an assist into 2 separate solo kills. That's a 50% kill value increase, just by virtue of being Pyke. How's that not "BReaKIng The FUNdAmenTalS" of gold distribution?
Pretty simple, TF and GP can generate as much gold with their gold generation mechanic, also support items generate that much gold easily but that's kind of another thing.
Just think of it as a support item built in a spell
It's already there, it's being used everywhere, it's included pretty clever into a kit
I mean, if anything, more marksmen should have ammo mechanics but I'm not on that rn.
This is exactly what you should be commenting about because it's literally your point
The ammo mechanic is also a completely new mechanic to league
It was a risky move to add it but it came out well and now champions are starting to gain that mechanics in their designs. Graves/Jhin/Xayah all have ammo mechanics.
It's a good mechanic, I don't have problems with new mechanics being added if they actually support the game in a good and meaningful way.
True stealth doesn't accomplish either
Well duh.
Her autos are also a new mechanic
Since the beggining of league if you wanted to auto attack constantly you had to sit still
Now Kalista comes in and says "nah fuck that" and it gets her down to a 43% WR.
This is a BAD mechanic and trash design, main reason why riot has given up on that concept and they just have to rework her now
Yeah, you're biased. You play champs that aren't as innovative in design, look at those champs, and get upset about it without truly weighing just how influential they actually are in your matches or why.
Like I said before: Who died and wrote down "New mechanics must solely be derived from old mechanics" as the final decree of LoL design? LoL always brings in new things, but you guys are just hyper sensitive to damage-oriented ones.
Biased where?
I gave you 2 examples on good new mechanics being added into the game and 3 examples of bad new mechanics and 3 examples of unique mechanics being created from existing ones.
There isn't a single thing I haven't given you an example about
You mean Morello?
If anything I wish he came back and the current "balance" team would just fuck off and rename themselfes to change team because that's all they are doing.
Season 8 has been a complete disaster because Riot just thinks "innovative and new" equals fun and enjoyable.
No it fucking doesn't