Ah okay, cool. I thought those were with the cycle with Elemental Lux lol. Totally my fault.
But yeah, even with the changes I don't think Ali can beat Naut when it comes to being a CC king.
Reasons why:
Ali has to generate stacks to get a stun on his AAs, whereas Naut doesn't. While Ali's last longer than Naut's, Ali can't stun multiple enemies in a team fight unlike Naut.
So if we look at their abilities, Naut has 4 methods of hard CC (AA stun, Q stun/pull, E slow, R stun/knockup), whereas Alistar only really has 2 and 1/2 (Q knockup, W stun/knockback) unless he can get enough Trample stacks to stun 1 opponent to make it a full 3 CCs.
So really, Ali is better than he was with more utility, but he doesn't compare to the sheer about of reliable CC Naut has when it comes to teamfights or locking opponents down. Not to mention it's harder to dodge Naut's CC than it is Ali's since Naut's are either AOE, lock-on, or AAs. Only Naut's Q is easily dodged, but even then Naut can use his Q for more than just CCing enemies.
I hope that makes sense. Sorry about confusing you earlier D: Was totally my fault.