RIOT logic: Garen punching the enemy when he crits makes no sense cause he has a sword

Xemeron··102 votes·6,544 views

Lets make Sion kick the enemy when he crits, even thought the has a big as fuck axe.

Seriously, as a Garen player that really annoys me, why was Garens epic fist to the face punch removed with such a lame excuse and then another champion basicly gets an identical unlogical crit animation?

62 Comments

Salt and Veigar45 votes

But if Sion didn't kick enemies he couldn't achieve his dream of being a dancer D:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=voXhLliLbkc

SpongeDude1 votes

{quoted}

But if Sion didn't kick enemies he couldn't achieve his dream of being a dancer D:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=voXhLliLbkc

Damn I almost fell off from my chair

ALthaGreat1 votes

ok you just proved for me that the best thing about league is the forums xD

The Fat Punisher30 votes

sions foot is also made of metal.

he already hits people with his axe what more could you want.

although i admit the Garen punch was awesome.

JevelFaithful10 votes

Garen has a metal gauntlet bigger than my head. +1 for saying it was awesome.

Hasztalan218 votes

Fun fact: Gp uses a pistol to shoot in melee when he has a sabre.

Mundo does a headsmash when he crits.

YOYOYOOY umadsmallzon.

Ice Weasel X25 votes

{quoted}

Fun fact: Gp uses a pistol to shoot in melee when he has a sabre.

Funny side effect: People unfamiliar with Critplank think someone's hacking to spam Q when they see him shooting his pistol faster than once per second.

Jimmyyy3 votes

[{quoted}](name=Ice Weasel X,realm=NA,application-id=3ErqAdtq,discussion-id=0hGlIeFz,comment-id=00010000,timestamp=2015-03-15T11:39:41.310+0000)

Funny side effect: People unfamiliar with Critplank think someone's hacking to spam Q when they see him shooting his pistol faster than once per second.

I swear this was me when I first started playing pvp... I saw a critplank (didn't know what it was, of course), and thought "why is he able to shoot so many times when if I play him I have to wait like 5 years to shoot again?"

DrCyanide1 votes

No joke, Friday one of my friends came up to me asking how the reset mechanic on Gangplank's Q worked. He was a bit confused when I told him there wasn't one, then he got all upset and went on about how "You should know when a champion uses an ability", to which I replied "It's not my fault you don't know the audio difference between the two".

SmokinSickStyle6 votes

Gragas crit animation.

Search it up.

Scrimshäw16 votes

1- legs have up to over 5x the strength as arms 2- sion's huge metal block foot>garen's wimpy hand

Silents42910 votes

I love how Maokai headbutts people. I like how Garen stabs people. I hate how Nautilus punches? Why does he punch at all.

Yuki Akuma1 votes

{quoted}

I love how Maokai headbutts people. I like how Garen stabs people. I hate how Nautilus punches? Why does he punch at all.

Maybe he deems some problems unworthly of taking a massive anchor to their face.

Dezell8 votes

[{quoted}](name=Yuki Akuma,realm=NA,application-id=3ErqAdtq,discussion-id=0hGlIeFz,comment-id=00090000,timestamp=2015-03-15T20:17:20.004+0000)

Maybe he deems some problems unworthly of taking a massive anchor to their face.

I cannot think of a single problem unworthy of taking an anchor to the face.

Dog barking? Anchor to the face. Baby crying? Anchor to the face. Car won't start? Anchor to the face. Speeding ticket? Anchor to the face.

RasCaelestis9 votes

It's not triggered by crit strikes, but Nautilus still sometimes punches things as his AA. I'm not sure why they took it away from Garen, but I can understand why players want it back. I'd be seriously bummed out If they took Naut's...

JevelFaithful6 votes

Their reasoning is what the OP said unfortunately. I guess the artist team got a wee bit too serious about the new gruffy-serious-garen.

Zazusha8 votes

isn't garen's crit animation a thrust? (like he does to Tryn in the 'Twist of Fate' Cinematic)

i find that badass as is.

Sion's crit is funny, but badass too. (300 horse kick down a well :P)

Xeynid5 votes

Yes. But that was after they "reworked" him and updated his visuals. Originally, his crit animation was a punch to the face.

Zazusha2 votes

I think sion can get a pass on his crit animation.

In what normal, viable, non-troll, build do you have enough crit to see him spaming Kicks instead of usin his axe? (also his AA's already include Punching as well, and a shoulder tackle when attacking turrets).

Darius's Crit should become a punch to the face, Like he does in the New Dawn cinematic vs Rengar at the End.

junglerboy162 votes

Build Trinity force and watch your opponents cry. I just played a match as Sion jungle yesterday and because of the new jungle item I had nearly 3k health at lvl 12 with only item 3717 so I got myself a item 3078. It is probably the best damage item for Sion because the Sheen procs on his high base damage HURT and that helps your R>E>Q>W burst combo, and occasionally you get to see that beautiful crit animation, which would almost be enough on its own.

BLU Medic7 votes

Garen's crit punch is why I bought Garen.

CataclysmCrash5 votes

What Riot says happened: "It's illogical so we didn't do it"

What really happened: "We forgot to add it since no one here gives half a rats ass about Garen and we're too lazy to change anything."

GloriousKaiser4 votes

Q flip.

UPfreely4 votes

can we change teemos crit animation to his death animation?

Quepha4 votes

the ult's kill animation actually bugs me a lot more. it's clearly way too much shit on my screen and riot justifies that by saying "well it's only for the garen player, no one else sees it"

if it's too much for other players to see then it's certainly too much for me.

Aarekk3 votes

If you don't want your ultimate to kill people so hard your screen explodes, why are you playing Garen?

junglerboy163 votes

I agree, Garen going man mode and punching in the enemy's face was awesome, just like Sion breaking their kneecaps is awesome.

Nubeel2 votes

You're a Garen Player.

Garen players are all noobs.

Nobody cares about noob's opinions.

Rinky Dinky39 votes

OH SHIT BOYS

WE GOT US A CHALLENJOUR SMURF

GloriousKaiser4 votes

GG

Rew7111 votes

Honestly, though, about Garen's critical, I thought it was him stabbing the enemy with his sword. I guess this must had been recent because I've never seen him punch... I have played Garen with critical items and its actually fun.

Captain Aishi4 votes

his punch was back when it was real garen, not the VU'd abomination we're now stuck with

Matezoide5 votes

[{quoted}](name=Captain Aishi,realm=NA,application-id=3ErqAdtq,discussion-id=0hGlIeFz,comment-id=0003000200010000,timestamp=2015-03-15T20:36:44.296+0000)

his punch was back when it was real garen, not the VU'd abomination we're now stuck with

RIP his old splash art.

He went from the incredibly heroic, badass dude to the random screaming douche bag. Especially the icon.

OyddAWqJ5r5 votes

Garen players are all noobs. Just look at that Master Tier noob scrub WingsofDeathx. Only Master Tier noobs play Garen. lol

UdoIkOSc4u2 votes

nasus when crits he hit with the end of his stick.....

Vicvictorw2 votes

Amumu breakdances when he lands a crit.

KING OF MASKS2 votes

RIP in peace, Garen face punch (2010-2013).

OyddAWqJ5r2 votes

I personally like his new stab animation, it's pretty satisfying.

TheHobbits2 votes

Nautilus F*ck it, this anchor is to heavy. Slap! "You have slain an enemy."

NinjaFifer2 votes

Mundo HEADBUTT!

Matezoide2 votes

IIRC, old Garen had 3 auto attack animations, one of the being his punch. At worst, i fully remember him punching without any crit items.

Meanwhil Sion has a punch on his regular basic attack lol

The Garen VU was a complete failure that should have been reverted a long time ago. The only good thing that came out of that bullshit were the updated icons and his epic "JUSTICE!" scream.

Ra1d2 votes

I'd love to see a new garen rework where they give him some new animations but also keep some of his current ones. I haven't been playing him long enough to see him punch but a VU is long overdue for him even though he got one two years ago. I really hate his trashcan skin(Steel Legion) so much. His Commando skin looks nothing like the artwork and that beret is stupid looking. Rugged Garen and Dreadknight look pretty cool as does his classic, but the rest just need changes. Also I'd enjoy seeing him punch people. He has a free hand so why not. And a downward slash rather than a angled slash would also look cool for crits.

FancyKiwi1 votes

At two minutes in this video is what his crit animation should be.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_2mV0XVbHSc

Ancient Tower1 votes

Hmm, I thought that Garen 's punch animation was one of his basic attacks pre-rework and his pre-rework crit was an overhead downward slash like the current decisive strike but without the vertical take-off. Then they dragged and dropped MasterYi 's aa animation and touched it up with his crit being a copy of the cinematic's stabbing of Tryndamere. I love the new crit animation, but having only two basic auto attack animations is really boring. He swings left, then right, then left, then..ri..ght..z.z.zzzz....

The loss of the front flip-spin master slam on Q's also a bug of mine ._. Now he just kind of floats...it's really weird. Also low attack speed (aka base) is really painful to watch on top of only two animations. Critting is an absolute joy for some reason though, despite only having a single animation, it seems to be a lot smoother overall.

BlackSunNocturne1 votes

Sion is also a 12 foot tall monster of a man.

To be honest, I'd be more afraid of Sion's kick than Garen's sword stab/facepunch.

Ryan the Skitzo1 votes

Amumu's crit is by far the best.

He break dances

FooDang1 votes

You ever get critted in the nose? that shit hurts...

More from Gameplay

More by Xemeron