Sion and Karthus shouldn't win prize fight in their passive

ValyrianBlade·Jan 4, 2019·3 votes·1,413 views

In order for their passive to activate, they need to DIE FIRST.

Prize fight clearly says "take the enemies' lives before they take yours".

In both cases, you take their life first. They simply reanimate after death and take yours back.

It's wrong that they win prize fight in their passives. You won the fight. They simply got some revenge.

Adding this point: If you get first blood for activating their passive, you should win the prize fight. It's inconsistent with how they've been treated since they were made.

11 Comments

DynikusJan 4, 20195 votes

not really, as that's part of their kit. It also works with kog passive. If they can still fight, you haven't won yet. If you could get GA, it would be the same deal.

MonstermushmushJan 4, 20191 votes

{quoted}

not really, as that's part of their kit. It also works with kog passive. If they can still fight, you haven't won yet. If you could get GA, it would be the same deal.

Sorta what I was thinking.

Deep Terror NamiJan 4, 20191 votes

JóhannJan 4, 20191 votes

same. atleast i didnt have to write it this time xD

ValyrianBladeJan 4, 20191 votes

{quoted}

same. atleast i didnt have to write it this time xD

Copying my other response to show it up on your feed: Just because it's part of their kit doesn't mean they aren't already dead.

Same should apply to Kog.

Even if they kill you in their passive, they're already dead. AT BEST, it's a draw for them.

For example - if you're in a 1 on 1 and you activate their passive and they kill you back, who gets first blood? You do. It should be pretty clear then, that you've won.

ValyrianBladeJan 4, 20191 votes

{quoted}

not really, as that's part of their kit. It also works with kog passive. If they can still fight, you haven't won yet. If you could get GA, it would be the same deal.

Just because it's part of their kit doesn't mean they aren't already dead.

Same should apply to Kog.

Even if they kill you in their passive, they're already dead. AT BEST, it's a draw for them.

For example - if you're in a 1 on 1 and you activate their passive and they kill you back, who gets first blood? You do. It should be pretty clear then, that you've won.

DynikusJan 4, 20191 votes

Prize fight isn't determined by who kills the other player first though, it's determined by who wins the fight. If the other person can still fight, it's not over yet.

ValyrianBladeJan 5, 20191 votes

{quoted}

Prize fight isn't determined by who kills the other player first though, it's determined by who wins the fight. If the other person can still fight, it's not over yet.

You've won the fight, they're seeking revenge.

I just don't agree with the logic at all. Especially kog'maw as people are posting here - he needs to explode to deal the damage from his passive. That one is simultaneous at best. However Sion and karthus have already lost in my opinion as well. These passives are no chance of survival. You can't "win" at that point...