Is it really ever a good idea to go for offensive masteries on Garen?
The reason I ask is because I've been comparing my own builds against the ones listed on probuilds.net, and I was really surprised at how many of them take 21/9/0 masteries even in games where they end up building nothing but tank items. Now I don't know the full context of their choices, as I can only see their final K/D/A, total gold, and the order of item purchase. But it's still got me wondering, what would justify in prioritizing your damage over sustainability on Garen?
For me, Garen is my safe pick because even if he does end up going against a hard counter like somebody with damage-over-time abilities, it's usually not too difficult to just escape death with proper positioning and a well-timed Q. This is especially true when I go 9/21/0 masteries because I'll take Perseverance and Second Wind to make his passive healing even stronger than it is normally. (Combined with a Warmog's or Spirit Visage, I can fully heal from 1/10 HP in a matter of seconds)
I've tried going for more damaging builds with Garen before, but it never gets me very far. I seem to do far better going full tank aside from an early Black Cleaver, and I think it synergizes well with assisting my ADC late game. (that E Black Cleaver proc) But if anyone here has some input on how to effectively play Garen as a fighter rather than a tank, then I'm willing to give it another shot.
...
DEMACIAAAAAAA!!!
. You're the off-tank, do some damage too.