Should I buy Katarina or Orianna?

Honestly, pretty good for soloqueue. She has a lot of damage and utility, so she can easily set up plays for her team. It's kinda of like Amumu or Thresh; if your team sees you land your ultimate or your Q, they usually know that they can follow up for an easy kill. Zhonya's Hourglass makes it very difficult for your enemies to prevent or interrupt your ultimate and buys you time for your team to follow up, and she has great base damage and scaling so it can really hurt with some Magic Penetration and AP. She's good for ganking as well, since her can easily push the wave and roam to another lane with her Q and/or ultimate to lock down the target for her allies.

However, I believe that her strongest point is probably her consistency. She can farm very quickly and safely after she gets a few levels and some AP, sitting back far from the minion wave and using her Black Shield to walk away from most attempted ganks. Her damage is still very high, so you can often pick up an easy kill at level 6, especially if you burned your opponents Flash beforehand. Just get a couple Doran's Rings early game for mana sustain and you are pretty much set if you manage your mana appropriately.

If you want to see someone experienced playing her, I'd probably recommend InvaderXive since she is one of his main champions.

Also, please reply to my post next time so I get a notification for your response. I only checked this thread against out of curiousity and didn't know you responded to me beforehand.

{quoted}

I'd vote for Ori, if you're looking to carry yourself "Out of silver and beyond". Kat is decent in low ELO(Bronze/Silver specifically, from what I'm told.) But in the higher leagues people are much more careful to not feed her, and save their Point+Click CC to shut her down the moment she jumps.

Ori, on the other hand, has a ton of outplay potential even at a higher level of play.

To be fair, I don't play much of either one(Though I do dabble in both.) If you're gonna spend the time getting good with one of them, it might as well be the one that can carry you the highest.

The problem is that i tend to switch focus WAAAY too much when trying to main someone. I like kat, her kit seems nice and she can snowball like crazy, but she is always permabanned in my que. The problem is that i will not be able to hang on to the same champion for very extended periods of time, which is why i am considering Tryndamere solotop, pretty ez and a 'free pass' IMO.

The reason i am asking for a good carry mid laner is because i am certain i will not be getting top very often lol. I know mid is contested too, but better expand your pool, right?

{quoted}

is pretty fun, though.

I agree, fiddle is pretty fun, i just cant play him very well :/

Orianna is probably a better pick for sustained damage and team-utility (her ultimate is great for followup on initiators or leading into AoE burst, shield + resistances, slow and MS buff, vision from ball). She can bully some champions early using her shield and passive while scaling into a strong mid-late game champion. Her ultimate is easier to use at a range, letting your team initiate, or following up an allies initiation. She requires more micromanagement, but can provide a good source of mobility, sustained damage, and protection during teamfights.

Morgana is probably a better pick for burst damage, AoE lockdown, and her E is great in protect-the-carry compositions or against teams with a lot of CC. Her sustained damage is pretty low, but her ultimate can chunk enemy teams and lock them down while her Q and W kill a target. Her ultimate can be a bit more difficult to position correctly, however it can easily lock down a grouped or confined team (such as in jungle corridors or dragon/baron pit). I believe that she is much better at arranging picks if she can land her Q, since she can easily follow up with her ultimate for lockdown.

It automatically adds the quote? I've been replying to each of your posts and it hasn't tried to add the quote on me yet on either Firefox or Chrome. Which browser are you using?

It's not really that annoying. I just couldn't think of a reason for you to keep quoting my entire post.

Eh, against mobile champions you can usually just play back on Morgana. If they want to engage on you they have to pass your minion wave and most assassin's gapclosers have a predictable ending location which you can use to bind them. If you are really worried about them dodging your Q, you can usually wait until they use their mobility tool to harass or trade with you, chase them down, ult them, and bind them while they are stunned.

If you want a good AoE CC mage against assassins, I'd recommend Lissandra. Her poke early game is very strong against melee champions and her ultimate can serve to shut down assassins either by ulting herself (to place herself in stasis and negate the damage) or ulting the assassin (stunning them). Her ultimate is targetted too, so they can't actually dodge it, and you have your W for followed CC.