Zanryu's Review center [CCC Judge Editon]

Zanryu·9/17/2014, 10:19:04 AM·4 votes·1,151 views

Hio guys,

Many of you probably know that there is currently an ongoing contest. If you don't, you probably should check it out. Especially since it is a monthly contest. In the current one I'm a judge (you probably noticed it from the title) and but the first looks the most harsh. In one week the results will be announced and for now I'm finished with my distribution of points (so almost no hope for crucial changes), but from now on I can take requests to write extended reviews for your champions so you probably gain a better insight into my (and maybe of the other judges, too) decisions. Unlike the judging I will not write any points towards the reviews. I can prepare the reviews for now, but I will post them after the final results are in so I won't influence any other judges.

Surely, I also take non-CCC concepts without any delay as usual.

The ruleset is still the same as before:

  • I don't require trades of reviews. If you want a review, just post it.
  • Try to enlist as much values as possible without using to much background information on abilites.
  • Be careful with classifications like tank or support. Each champion can be a tank or a support.
  • Do not forget to write if your skills doing magic or physical damage. It can influence your whole champion.
  • Don't forget to write if it is Total Attack Damage or Bonus Attack Damage.

Stuff from me:

Concepts: [Champion] Cyrus, the Mindsmith [April MCCC '13] Heather, the Evergreen [June MCCC '13] Lamont, the Verdict of Chains [Champion] Zanryu, the Descent of Fire [August CCC '14] Chuizi, the Kindling Hammer [October CCC '14] Quentin, the Source of Sorrow [[Champion]] Tillion, the Argent Wing](http://boards.na.leagueoflegends.com/en/c/skin-champion-concepts/AZPtcVO6-mccc-tillion-the-argent-wing)

Death Recap 2.0 Suggestion

Previous Review Centers: Zanryu's Review Center [Boards Edition] #. I Zanryu's Review Center [Boards Edition] #. II Zanryu's Review Center [Boards Edition] #. III


My First Review Center My Second Review Center


Reviews: The Azazel by MrBuffington Cole, the Bandle City Beetleback by The Lost Marbles Magnon, the Master of the Lighthouse by PenguinSebs Ymir, the Defender by LittleBlast Zero, the Primal Pursuant by Leroyswish Mila, The Stray Light by Bourmegar Kokoro, The Ionian Skeleton by DezOverlord Thule, the Tribal Twinge by Leroyswish Shrike, the Stormchaser by Flintfall Zeph, the Sky Caller by dialMARK4acti0n Xanir, the Child of Twilight by Destínum


Zanryu

15 Comments

Sir ArmaMalum9/17/2014, 1:41:57 PM3 votes

Zanryu, you are aware that I mentioned several times that judges were not to reveal themselves until the end of the contest correct?

Flintfall9/17/2014, 9:18:28 PM1 votes

Really cool that you're doing this (my other sentiments expressed by Sir ArmaMalum), I was exhausted from judging and the fact you're going the extra mile makes me happy to be a part of these contests.

I'll take you up on the review for Shrike, I'd normally wait for the contest reveal to ask for opinions but since you're offering I can take up less space in the comments :P

Points I am already aware of:

  • Lore is a bit inconsistent (in terms of writing style, I didn't unify it as much as I could).

  • Ultimate is a bit confusing (very confusing to some).

  • The kit has a very hit and miss aspect to it, you need to land abilities.

Thanks in advance!

dialMARK4acti0n9/24/2014, 7:56:18 PM1 votes

It was really awesome of you to volunteer as a judge in the contest!

Zeph was my 1st concept so I didn't even think I'd get to Top 5 but here I am in 3RD FREAKIN' PLACE!!!!

I'd like to hear what you liked and disliked about him and how I can improve with my next one!

So, in short, could you review Zeph here?

Would appreciate it!!

Destínum9/26/2014, 10:09:31 AM1 votes

You and the other judges did a great job with the contest! After my concept Xanir came in 6th place (so close to top 5!), I'd like to know what parts I did well and which ones would have needed improvements.

Would really appreciate if you could give some opinions, and thanks in advance!