No matter how you slice it, you still have X amount of people who either want the game to be over or the game to continue. A pre-made is still made up of individuals who each get their own vote. Them having the same opinion is no different than two strangers having the same opinion on a vote, it's just more likely to happen when it's two friends.
Using your proposed rule, consider the hypothetical situation;
A pre-made of four believe the game is over, the game has gone horribly. Because all of them count as a single vote, the 5th player has the ability to hold the game hostage for all four of the other players. That's pretty unfair.