When someone is being really toxic but, I'm trying to keep a positive attitude.

+1 for mlp and the truth

But then you somehow get drawn into insulting each other anyway

https://derpicdn.net/img/view/2015/9/19/983206__safe_rarity_monochrome_animated_screencap_edit_open+mouth_wide+eyes_discovery+family_pointing.gif

Distracting them with something non-sequitur is rather amusing, if it disrupts their anger issues it can get them to refocus too.

a mlp post that is not downvote bombed?

that is refreshing for once

Mute button is my favourite cup.

same

I just insult them with fruits. Like calling them a pineapple sucker. That makes them just say "wtf" and let it go over 50% of the time.

Would upvote but... pony..