What do you prefer old kayle or New kayle?

The look of old Kayle for sure. Honestly I prefer old Kayle's gameplay too, both to play against and to play as.

Can I pick neither? Old Kayle didn't exist because she had very few niches to fill, and the new one was a headache when she was released until she was nerfed back into mediocrity just like the old Kayle. I feel like the purpose of the rework was to make people play her and give her a more unique kit, but she just circled back into oblivion again.

I liked her old E, that's all that I miss. Though she basically gets the old one at 11 now, so I still feel they could have done something more for her new E. Everything else is just an upgrade.