Skip to content

Riot. If you are going to make abilities that have lines defining their edges.....

rvn2svn··232 votes·7,167 views

Make the ability line up with the animation.

Illaoi's tentale smash is wider than the animation

Tahm Kench's Tongue Lash is wider than the animation

When Lux casts Lucent Singularity you KNOW where the edge of the ability is because it has a defined edge. If someone walked next to that area but still was affected by the slow when they weren't in the animation that would be a problem. Why are Tahm and Illaoi allowed to have this in their already "wow this is really not fun to play against" kits?

142 Comments

Aeolian Melodies72 votes

Jinx's "warning" for Zap also does not match the actual skill's hitbox.

Stepping out of Morg's circle (when she has ulted you) does not always break it.

etc.

Auryiel10 votes

Morg's ult probably checks your position every 0.25 second

As for Jinx, I think the indicator when she starts to cast is more representative of the ability's actual size. Why it gets smaller as she channels, I don't know

Troll for Trump37 votes

I swear Lux's R's line is BS. Also Cho's E hitbox..

EDIT: I mean his AOE Silence, not his toggled E.Although his E's hitbox is also kinda wonky.

DeathToHeretics6 votes

Mostly Cho's W is wonky. Half the time his W should hit, it doesn't...and half the time it shouldn't, it does. His E is supposed to get wider proportionally to how many stacks he has, I don't remember that one messing up as much as his silence does.

Durzaka6 votes

{quoted}

Mostly Cho's W is wonky. Half the time his W should hit, it doesn't...and half the time it shouldn't, it does. His E is supposed to get wider proportionally to how many stacks he has, I don't remember that one messing up as much as his silence does.

How it works is if you were in the cone when he activates it, you get hit, regardless. The animation is just to look pretty.

It makes him incredibly hard to lane against because of that.

OyddAWqJ5r1 votes

Never really gave it too much thought but yeah the animation should probly change to match how instantaneous the cone really is.

Captain Aishi1 votes

the animation is there because it's a bug that makes it guaranteed to hit if your enemy is in range when you cast it (same bug that affected darius pull for a while) they fixed the bug on darius but not on cho's silence for some reason

the long cast animation of cho's W is there because it's an ability that you're supposed to be able to dodge (originally)

Auz the Ripper4 votes

It's not really a bug, it's a result of old programming. Riot's fully aware of it, but it's intrinsic to the skill's function so they need to completely rewrite the programming of the skill to get rid of it. It'll be fixed when Cho'gath is reworked or has his kit updated, like Apprehend and Siphon of Destruction were

OyddAWqJ5r1 votes

As Auz said, the skill always hit in such a fashion. It was never bugged, it just never had an animation to match the effect since season 1 (that's as far as I know but it was probly in beta too).

Captain Aishi1 votes

that isn't true at all, I used to pick katarina as a counter to chogath in lane because it was so easy to just shunpo on him to dodge his silence, but nowadays (since the patch that fixed cone abilities firing backwards after flashing) you shunpo on him and then get silenced anyway (any champion that could dash through him during his animation used to be able to dodge the skill entirely)

it's 100% a bug but riot just didn't care fixing it for some reason

OyddAWqJ5r1 votes

Yeah no, if you are in the cone on cast you get hit. If you weren't you don't. There is no lingering hitbox so dashing behind him won't silence you rather you were silenced in the same moment you Shunpo'd. I've yet to silence something behind me.

That said, we weren't talking about the hitbox but rather the fact it doesn't travel. It has always been instant.

Captain Aishi1 votes

that's what i,m saying, it has not always been instant, the instance i'm talking about is when you use a blink as a reaction to his cast animation, it used to dodge the skill before the patch where they fixed cone abilities firing backwards after dashing through all of seasons 1 to what, 4 and a half, i have always been able to react to a cho's W animation to dash out of the cast area and dodge the spell entirely, and that suddenly became impossible with the patch i keep referring to

(it was the same patch that brought the darius pull bug back into the game as well because I had never been able to pull someone who flashed out of it before that particular patch, and then it suddenly became a common occurence)

OyddAWqJ5r1 votes

I'm telling you--it's always been instant. The animation is just for show. There never was a travel time.

Captain Aishi1 votes

and i,m telling you, the ability used to hit when the animation played, not when the spell was cast, since i've dodged it plenty of times in the past

it'd be pretty hard for me to say i'm wrong when i've had plenty of first hand experiences of what i'm saying you know :S

OyddAWqJ5r1 votes

I promise it never traveled. Thus why it was never blockable via Wind Wall.

Captain Aishi1 votes

that has nothing to do with what i'm talking about, I never said it was a projectile, I just said the spell hit the units that were in it's hitbox when the animation played instead of the units that were in it's hitbox during the initial cast

(imagine his rupture knocking units that were inside the red circle at the start of the cast instead of the units that are in it once the spikes pop up, that's how the W behaves now compared to before this bug)

OyddAWqJ5r1 votes

I said it didn't travel in 3 previous replies and you just now say that that's not what you were talking about... Why didn't you say so earlier? Jeez.

Waste of time. Not a bug though. It damages the moment the "roar" part starts, no matter where you were in the cone. It does NOT damage you if you were there the moment he cast it and blinked out as the skill has a delay before it casts (albeit a small one). It is working as intended. The animation simply needs an update.

Just play Cho'Gath for Christ's sake. You won't get any "unfair" or "bugged" W hits at all.

Kawaii Chad1 votes

[deleted]

DeathToHeretics1 votes

If we're looking at it from a logical progression, 99% of League wouldn't exist. But, I do see what you're saying. Just as a heavy Cho player, the animation doesn't fit.

My Waifu Vanilla2 votes

Are you a heavy Cho'Gath player because you always end the game with 6 stacks?

58738074DEL121 votes

[deleted]

Spank me hard2 votes

Nidalee's javelins are broken in a way that they go through people and don't hit when they're supposed to. Also many champions have so bad hitboxes. For example vs Yi, Javelins always go through him when they're supposed to hit...

iainB854 votes

I agree... I've had people dead center in Lux's ult and zero damage. Vice versa I've had people I thought I clearly missed get nailed.

Aeolian Melodies2 votes

{quoted}

I swear Lux's R's line is BS. Also Cho's E hitbox..

Lux's red line isn't meant to represent the AoE of the ability. When you see the anymation fire off it is wider than that and it matches the actual hitbox.

Troll for Trump1 votes

When the laser/final spark fires, in a rainbow ray(this is AFTER the line) it hits me even though it didn't Rito plx.

Oberic2 votes

Finales Funkeln! Never forget!

Bongo Johnson1 votes

Cho's E has been a pseudo eternal problem. its distance doesn't match the animation, nor the width. [zombie-brand-clap]

Blissed1 votes

Jinx shouldn't even have an indicator, look at Cait or Ezreal... Stop complaining.

KaisadiIIa1 votes

That has to be the most stupid comment I've ever read. You can't justify an indicator being misleading/wrong just because other champions don't have an indicator.

Blissed1 votes

The hitbox on their skills are bigger than they look, the indicator is meaningless -_-

Durzaka23 votes

{quoted}

Make the ability line up with the animation.

Illaoi's tentale smash is wider than the animation

http://imgur.com/a/79guG

http://imgur.com/a/3W8Yi

Im curious how many fucking times im going to have to post this before people stop saying it doesnt match the animation. It fucking does.

There are very real problems with abilities not matching animations, but Illaoi's tentacles are NOT one of them.

Ackelope8 votes

The issue is not that the hitbox doesn't match the indicator on the ability for Illaoi, but that it supposedly doesn't match the little box that shows up for enemies when she casts it. I'm not sure if it's at all true, haven't really ever been in melee range with an Illaoi since I primarily play ranged champions, and I feel getting into melee range of her is generally a poor idea.

Durzaka3 votes

The icon you see on the ground in the pictures standing in fountain are the same for both Illaoi and her enemies. THAT is the indicator. it is what you react to to avoid getting hit by it.

Ackelope2 votes

I'm guessing people think it's iffy because they assume skillshot hits are calculated with the center of their model, but it's edge-to-edge, which can make some skillshots seem like they shouldn't have hit when they did.

Carpe Victoria2 votes

I don't know if it's been patched but shortly after the main client release her tentacle smash was hitting quite a bit further off the far end of it than the enemy outline box showed. I haven't laned against her enough to notice it being wider but it was longer at some point.

Durzaka1 votes

Those albums were made over 2 weeks ago. less than a week after she was released.

Carpe Victoria1 votes

Those pictures don't show it hitting anyone though, just the visuals. Test it with a friend and have them stand just off the edge of the end of it.

Durzaka1 votes

There are several pictures showing edge hits, and edge misses, with the another picture for each showing where the indicator said it was going to hit.

Carpe Victoria2 votes

I'm personally talking about the front tip though not the side.

koager1 votes

I've also seen that. I'm clearly far enough in front of the indicator box, out of reach of her tentacle, but when it comes smashing down I've taken damage.

sealust10 votes

I haven't had experience with Illaoi's tentacles being wider, but longer instead. Hit box still seems to be off for it :/

bobbery510 votes

I can't tell you how many times I've died to Lux's ult when I can see grass between myself and the animation.

doiminat0r36007 votes

Karthus doesnt even have a radius for his Q on quick cast.

Rubber Jesus2 votes

This is referring to what the enemy sees, not what you see. So it doesn't show a radius line for any of his Q's. You can just see the animation coming up below you. This is like Cass's Q, there is not a line when you play against her.

Think about playing against a Lux. When she throws out E, you can see a line around it's edge showing where it will hit. Morgana's pool is the same: it has a defined line when you are playing against her.

SeductiveGrandpa4 votes

Oh. Hell. No. Galio THIS FUCKER (Which I love playing) HAS A LYING ULT. DONT IGNORE THIS. WE'VE ALL HAD THAT MOMENT WHERE YOU WERE LIKE "Hmm, since I didnt get stuck in the ult I should try to help attack outside of it" AND THEN YOU WALKED NEAR THE OUTLINE, GOT TAUNTED ANYWAY, AND DIED.

Sire Hippington5 votes

and then you tount an adc duering his escape/just befor flash and he simply Hits you from outside the damage aoe*[slayer-jinx-unamused]*

DrProfVibeCheck3 votes

Then theres Cho'Gath with the opposite problem.

His Q hitbox is shorter than it indicates.

Ackelope2 votes

I think the solution here would not be to increase the hitbox, but decrease the indicator's size. I don't really want giant Cho Qs...

iluvalar3 votes

@OP. Keep in mind there is at least 100ms delay between the players. At the end of the day, there is that weird synching system that try to compromise by spreading the delay between both side.

You're out of the tentacles range now, but how about 100ms ago ? If you were in back there, expect any result. Maybe on her screen, illaoi walked an extra 100ms in the right direction before she cast the spell and you got hit. Maybe you were walking in the right direction to dodge before the cast and she was seeing you 100ms behind, she cast her skill right on you but on your screen your were nearly out already. You got lazy and stop dodging right on the edge ?

I know it's easy to forget about the ping delay, specially here in lol, riot made a pretty decent job at the task. But remember there is a blurry line around the skill shots and if 2 actions from different players happen simultaneously inside the ping range expect weird results. Specially if they cause people to displace, then it can become funny.

More from Gameplay

More by rvn2svn