Gameplay+, the newest way to discuss the game on the Boards

ModWuks·8/17/2018, 10:10:34 PM·48 votes·406,122 views

[8/21/18 - 2:13PM PDT] Gameplay+ is live! Check out the announcement here

Over the past few months, the NA Boards volunteers have made allusions to a project that we've addressed simply as a Gameplay sub-board focusing on more in-depth and meaningful posts and discussions for all things related to League of Legends gameplay. We've been carefully tweaking the rules and guidelines and have been developing the technical features for this area; and I'm happy to announce that we're at a point where we feel we can move forward with this project in the very near future.

Before we launch, we'd love to gather your thoughts on everything from the name (Gameplay+) to the guidelines.


Gameplay+, the newest way to discuss the game on the Boards

Some of you have probably noticed some success that we’ve had on heavily moderated threads in the past year or so. These threads have provided an interesting window to how the community responds to more discussion-focused threads with increased moderator presence. That response has been extremely positive, and we’d like to take the next step to continue this success by making an entirely new sub-board for these curated discussions. So let’s talk about Gameplay+.

The goal of this new board is to give the community a place to dig deep into topics like gameplay, balance, and design, and that requires posts and comments that show a genuine attempt at meaningful, respectful, and informed discussion. As part of this process topics posted on Gateplay+ will be subject to a Moderator approval process before they are visible to the community. This will help ensure that every conversation on Gameplay+ starts out with a genuine attempt at sparking a good, strong discussion. Comments will not need to go through this approval process, but will be subject to moderation with these same guidelines in mind.

  1. Posts must have a clear and specific title that provides an introduction to the topic of the thread. Titles that are insufficiently clear may be altered by moderation prior to post approval if the post is otherwise satisfactory.
  2. Posts must provide a thoughtful analysis or other meaningful starting point for discussion. Data should be cited where possible, and hyperbole is not appropriate. Do not let your passion about some aspect of the game cloud your ability to present your views, and do not let your views get in the way of having a respectful discussion.
  3. Posts must offer a direction for conversation that is not shared with other recent or active posts. If you wish to partake in a discussion already ongoing, do so in the thread for that discussion.
  4. Posts must genuinely invite discussion, even if others take another viewpoint or support another side of an argument.

We want threads and comments on Gamplay+ to be consistently high-quality and full of good discussion and polite interactions. To help facilitate this goal, we will be especially strict in moderation of comments that do not adhere to the Universal Rules, so please be respectful to others on this sub-board, even if you may disagree with their analysis or their viewpoint!

Our dream is to have a sub-board where every thread and every comment is composed of thoughtful discussion and informed responses, and we think this strategy will get us closer to that goal than other strategies that have been used in the past. We hope that you are as excited about this as we are!

Thanks for embarking on this experiment with us,

--The Volunteer team

123 Comments

D357R0Y3R8/17/2018, 10:13:55 PM23 votes

those are actually good rules, waiting to see how they're applied now

Posts must provide a thoughtful analysis

this is incredibly shallow

how do you decide if an analysis is throughtful or not?

ModAcademy Kayn8/17/2018, 11:14:53 PM9 votes

Better name for Gameplay+

The Actual Gameplay and Balance Boards Board.

420 grams8/17/2018, 10:20:17 PM9 votes

Did you know Gameplay+ was made when the boards tried to discuss the game twice at the same time?

warpenguin5558/17/2018, 10:11:54 PM6 votes

Sweet. I've been wanting this for a while now

HungryAngry2SPP8/18/2018, 12:05:44 AM6 votes

So, no more rage post about Tryndamere Zoe Yasuo Zed etc huh? Seems nice. I approve this idea

Meat Feast8/17/2018, 10:26:04 PM5 votes

tldr

Rock MD8/17/2018, 10:25:25 PM5 votes

If you meant a place to discuss meaningful balance changes, philosophies, and trying to determine what makes champions good/bad, that'd be neat.

If it's just another place to post about what champion is or isn't OP, it'll end up just like Gameplay, with people crying about whatever is meta but, "oh look at these statistics, this is rational thought and analysis."

The same rift will occur between low and high elo players, with high elo players talking about abstract concepts and ideas low elos don't understand so they think high elos are just blowing smoke, and the large number of low elos will band together and think they know significantly more about the game than they actually do because they're in agreement.

HateDaddy8/18/2018, 12:18:06 AM5 votes

Great idea. Love it. Only gripe is that you probably shouldn’t change titles unless clear blunders are made (massive spelling errors, typos, etc.). I realize you’re introducing a subjective process to a subjective issue but editing titles might negatively effect a tone an author may be trying to establish - needless to say, if the title is offensive or outright unrelated entirely, the thread probably needs to be killed. My response to this would be linking the poster to their deleted thread and simply inform them that the thread content was great and you’d love to see it but the title needs some serious overhaul for the following reasons, etc.

Dope Solo8/22/2018, 2:49:57 PM5 votes

So you can talk about champion balance, but only the way WE want you to talk about it.

ModEvangele8/17/2018, 10:48:06 PM4 votes

Nami While I did not have the largest hand in this project it is something I am super proud of the moderation team for! Listening to feedback from others on the Gameplay boards seeding this idea. volunteers jumping at the chance to help, and coming up with a plan to implement this has been a pleasure to watch.

I'm very excited to see what types of amazing conversations can be cultivated on a subboard like this.

Bravo!

Who Fed Ru8/18/2018, 12:15:37 PM3 votes

This was needed for a while

The Bad Touch11/3/2018, 10:56:29 AM3 votes

Gameplay+ = making sure the easily triggered Rioters only read posts that have been approved by a committee of ass-kissers.

Teridax688/17/2018, 11:17:40 PM3 votes

So is Gameplay+ going to be an entirely separate sub-board, then? What will happen to current Gameplay when that happens? Are you sure you have enough moderator power to handle the influx of thread requests, let alone moderate the comments on there?

ZephyrDrake8/18/2018, 12:02:02 AM3 votes

Time to move to reddit I guess, since the boards will now be a ghost town

KFCeytron8/18/2018, 4:16:51 AM3 votes

I can tell that significant effort went into making this sound like an extra-wonderful version of Gameplay, but it still ended up as an admission of Gameplay's failure and the desire to have a gameplay-focused board that's actually not terrible. Why not just turn Gameplay into this heavily-moderated thing, and the rest of the posts ("omg I died too fast" eight times a day) can just... not exist, since they aren't valuable?

DamianXBleach1/11/2019, 11:38:24 PM2 votes

I don’t know how to start a post, so I’m commenting here. I was told by @RiotSupport that my feedback on Lee Sin was “not bad” and I should post it here. - “ Can we make Lee Sins W be able to self cast while rooted? He can use everything else but that and it’s not like he moves when he self casts it he should be able to shield. “

Tychusfindlay9188/18/2018, 2:44:08 AM2 votes

"Hyperbole is not appropriate"

I'm sure everyone's excited for this trashy windows-vista version of gameplay boards.

BULLSEYE898/18/2018, 6:30:28 AM2 votes

well, this is an exciting project. it goes to show that meaningful discussions b/w gamers can still happen. thanks a lot. hyped for its launch. btw, when are u planning on releasing this?

Leonerdo8/18/2018, 6:10:34 PM2 votes

I just hope that the criteria for "thoughtful" has nothing to do with "length". I don't think long, meandering ramblings are any better than short, accusatory rants. And taking the time to write 3000 words should not be valued more than taking the time to edit that down to 1000 words.

InTheory8/18/2018, 9:06:29 PM2 votes

I'm not sure that you're helping yourselves by allowing the bottomless pit that is champion balance.

Snugglesnacks9/29/2018, 4:35:06 AM2 votes

A shield from the well deserved spanking the balance team gets.

Sekiro210/22/2018, 3:33:07 AM2 votes
  1. Alistar