Why is Bruiser mage top never just good.

Rewt··3 votes·3,312 views

Its either Dog shit. or Straight busted. There is no in between.

Morde was strong enough to do it without having to be a main and know his kit inside and out. Was oppressive as fuck. got nerfed.

Fizz. we all know this one.

Now Viktor.

My question is why is this archtype never balanced. It is always to one side or the other.

21 Comments

The Bad Touch2 votes

{quoted}

Its either Dog shit. or Straight busted. There is no in between.

Morde was strong enough to do it without having to be a main and know his kit inside and out. Was oppressive as fuck. got nerfed.

Fizz. we all know this one.

Now Viktor.

My question is why is this archtype never balanced. It is always to one side or the other.

Simple. Either the bases are high and it's easy to get a lead. Or the scalings are high and you never get a lead to use said scalings.

Entire game is over at 10 minutes these days.

Look at bot lane and compare Kai'sa to Vayne. Both or "meh" early but Kai'sa is still much stronger in early lane before first back thus can get her foot in the door. Vayne rarely does. Sure at 40 minutes Vayne is hella good... but Kai'sa ended the game with Stormrazor/Rageblade at 22 minutes.

Fizz/Ekko were great when they had base damage... now you almost never see them because they don't make it out of lane.

Sujiren1 votes

[{quoted}](name=The Bad Touch,realm=NA,application-id=3ErqAdtq,discussion-id=mfWOf8jF,comment-id=0000,timestamp=2018-10-31T08:19:02.447+0000)

Simple. Either the bases are high and it's easy to get a lead. Or the scalings are high and you never get a lead to use said scalings.

Entire game is over at 10 minutes these days.

Look at bot lane and compare Kai'sa to Vayne. Both or "meh" early but Kai'sa is still much stronger in early lane before first back thus can get her foot in the door. Vayne rarely does. Sure at 40 minutes Vayne is hella good... but Kai'sa ended the game with Stormrazor/Rageblade at 22 minutes.

Fizz/Ekko were great when they had base damage... now you almost never see them because they don't make it out of lane.

You don't need a 40 minute Vayne. Bork + Rageblade Vayne already destroys everyone , and if she farms well, picks up a kill or two , she will have those items by 20 minutes.

Poske1 votes

{quoted}

You don't need a 40 minute Vayne. Bork + Rageblade Vayne already destroys everyone , and if she farms well, picks up a kill or two , she will have those items by 20 minutes.

Still literaly the worst ADC in a game except maybe Jhin

Ðeath XIII2 votes

RUMBLE SMASH

OtterlyLost1 votes

Morde is a juggernaut not a mage.

Fizz is an AP assassin, not a mage.

The only mage that's ever done this is Viktor and it's purely because he cant be played mid anymore. Like many other champions, he cant stand up to the early game champs like zed, talon, aatrox and the like in order to scale.

Moody P3 votes

mord is a mage

Alzon1 votes

Mordekaiser item 3020 item 3916 item 3146 item 3151 item 3157 item 3026 burst mage

Vs

Mordekaiser item 3047 item 3116 item 3151 item 3065 item 3165 item 3135 juggernaut

Vs

Mordekaiser item 3009 item 3146 item 3065 item 3115 item 3512 item 3135 the Alzon brainlet special

OtterlyLost1 votes

[{quoted}](name=Moody P,realm=NA,application-id=3ErqAdtq,discussion-id=mfWOf8jF,comment-id=00010000,timestamp=2018-10-31T14:41:57.738+0000)

mord is a mage

Yes, that's why he was part of MYMU instead of the Juggernaut update at the end of season 5. Because he's a mage.

No. He is a juggernaut.

Moody P2 votes

yeah kinda how like how skarner is a jugg-- oh wait he's not? wow

full ap builds, not tanky at all, plays for burst - mage

OtterlyLost1 votes

[{quoted}](name=Moody P,realm=NA,application-id=3ErqAdtq,discussion-id=mfWOf8jF,comment-id=0001000000010000,timestamp=2018-10-31T16:42:09.266+0000)

yeah kinda how like how skarner is a jugg-- oh wait he's not? wow

full ap builds, not tanky at all, plays for burst - mage

Low Mobility, high damage, counter play is to kite, has abilities in his kit that make him artificially tanky. He is a Juggernaut. As is Skarner.

Warlord Rhinark1 votes

Cries in AP Udyr

Salron1 votes

Because it usually involves using items or such that weren't intended for them in ways that weren't foreseen

Tr4shB4NSYST3M1 votes

Dont forget tank Ekko top which was mega cancer as well.

LeftyRaydy1 votes

Leave TEkko out of this

Tr4shB4NSYST3M1 votes

Why? was very similar to what Viktor top is now, strong kiting of melee champs, easy to proc shield, item 3057 for turret taking, and high enough base damages that it didn't matter if he didn't build a ton of AP.

Seems like Viktor is just a different chapter of the same book.

LeftyRaydy2 votes

I am just playing with you :) cause Ekko is my main, but I never liked his Tank top I prefer him AP mid and I want him to stay that way.

Tr4shB4NSYST3M2 votes

I like ekko a lot too, im pretty bad at him myself b/c i just havent put in the time, but even tho he has a lot in his kit if an ekko kills me (on fairly even gold) i do feel outplayed b/c all his stuff has very reasonable counterplay.

(except for a few times after patches where His Q was invisible, lol that was rough)

LeftyRaydy1 votes

Let me know if you want some Ekko tips and tricks

SirPurrr1 votes

His bases were too high BUT, tank Ekko is still viable vs some top matchups. It is a refutation of this post imo. While he's certainly not top tier, he lies on the edge of viability top lane. Full tank is not ideal so you still typically want at least one AP item. AP Ekko top is also a thing as we saw from C9 at Worlds. I think it's really cool that he has this build and lane versatility.

PopcornBunni1 votes

Meanwhile the actual fighter and tank mages meant for top are getting completely shat on by these off picks

Galio Maokai Rumble

Strawberrycocoa1 votes

Probably because Mages tend to have stronger utility than regular Bruisers/Juggernauts, so building them tanky means they can both ndure your assaults AND shut you down from fighting back.

Just a guess on my part.

More from Gameplay

More by Rewt