just played new kayle for the first time
overall i feel they ruined kayle.. her early game is next to non-existant.. melee champs abuse you now since they can be easily in range, and the late game while overly strong, you have to get there and if you dont play the lane like you are 1 shot all game you can fall very far behind
q being a skill shot is i guess "meta friendly" since riot hates point and click cc but it feels clunky and i didnt get used to using it in-between autos, used to be a free way to chase but now its dodge-able and if someone flashes it they are gone from your auto attack range (pre 11)
E takes some time to get used to, its not at all anything resembling old kayle but i can see where lich bane was almost made for it, and ult.. man the fact you cant attack for 2 seconds completely outweighs the damage on it not to mention in the short time i used her i saw it bug twice, where i tanked two 4th bullets from a jhin after it had "ended".
and i say "ended" because i was able to attack him back but the shield effect was still on me, so as im not 100% sure how it works it felt like it was a bug