Gragas: Let's talk about love for the big fella
It has almost been a year since the Rabble Rouser was reworked from an explosive "Irish Car-bomb throwing" AP burst mid to the beer-brazened beefy brusier of... top lane? Jungle? Or maybe mid lane? Ok, support? (Get used to beer related puns by the way, because I plan on using them ale lot... you see what I did there?)
A lot of text ahead.
Let's Get This Party Started!
I would like to take a look at the current state of Gragas, and really talk about what I think he needs to be "playable" again. I used to love playing Gragas in the mid lane, and it saddens me to see such a loved and formerly-feared champion becoming a common staple in nemesis draft.
I'd also like to preface by saying that I am certainly not a pro player, so please take what I say with a grain of salt if you so decide. I'm just someone who liked Gragas, and really thinks he needs some attention. I think by making a post like this I can encourage some new ideas, and maybe make a positive impact on the current state of Gragas.
Happy Hour Incoming! It came as no surprise to me (and probably many other Gragas players), when I read Gragas was going to be reworked. After all, he was a complete tyrant in the mid lane. Having everything you could want out of a mid lane kit: high damage, wave-clear, sustain, tankiness, a gap closer, an escape, a displacement, buffs, debuffs, and an amazingly cheesy level 3 all-in potential. Old Gragas simply did not have the weaknesses that were required to be considered a balanced champion. Some very old school Gragas players might argue this point, but deep down we all knew we were playing "the lee sin" of mid lane. So my point, I think one would need to be hopped up on a lot of hops to think that Gragas didn't need a rework. The happy hour for freelo Gragas was over.
Time to Roll Out the Barrel! I found the original post outlining his rework on the boards, feel free to check it out here
Essentially, Gragas would no longer be an AP burst champ because it 1) didn't match his theme, and 2) would be to difficult to balance using his current ability set (basically he would be OP or be "Olaf'd"). I think that the second point is a valid one, but the first is a bit of a cop out. I don't think many will argue with me when I see that lore is not Riot's first or second, or even third priority. So when I saw that Riot was using "feel" as a reason to rework a champion, I was a bit disheartened. It felt like they were trying to add a bit of sugar to my medicine. I just wanted the shot straight.
The second point was fair I thought though. In his current state he would be a monstrous challenge to balance. So what changes would be made to completely rework that OP kit? Well, honestly, not a lot. The damage was reduced (don't need a rework to do that), some of his buffs and debuffs were changed (don't need much of a rework to do that either). But he was different, don't get me wrong. However I don't think Riot changed Gragas enough to change the underlying problems with his kit. "He's OP or he's Olaf". He is still a hard champion to balance.
Fight Time! Well what's up with Gragas these days? After being pushed around a bit, he still doesn't really have a home. Is he a top laner? Maybe? He got LCS play for a bit as a top laner, but alas the meta has shifted away from him there. Can he jungle? Not really, as the new jungle is a much more treacherous place. Can he support? Kind of, but he cannot possibly match the sustain of a Nami, or the engage of a Thresh. So maybe he is still a mid laner? But Riot already said they don't want him to be a bursty AP mage, so that really limits his mid lane potential. There are only a few viable mid laners who are not assassins or mages (Vlad, Swain of the top of my head) and they can certainly out sustain Gragas.
This lack of a place has hit Gragas hard. The once mighty Keg-facer has a measly 40.48% win-rate. He gets played in less that 1% of games. (This is based off of statistics from Champion.gg, so Plat+ games). Why has he fallen so out of favor? Because he has been, and still is, a burst mage. Just a very weak one. A year ago his kit might have been enough for a top laner. But now, if you don't have a malt of CC and ranged damage, or ridiculous amounts of tankiness, you just can't belong there. Gragas sadly sits in the middle of those 2 things. Not enough to be on par with the likes of Liss or Gnar, but certainly not enough tankiness to soak damage like Sion. This is because Gragas is still a bursty, now Olaf'd mage.
Last Call! So what does Gragas need? Well he need a departure from his lore. We ignore lore all the time anyway, so why not. Make him a mage again. Give him more damage, less tankiness, and make his E more about disengage than engage. Don't bring back the old Gragas, just bring back the shadow of the old Gragas. Why not just make him a mid laner again? His most common builds are really not much of a departure from those of old Gragas, so why not accept that he is not a tank, and run with it. He is just to much in the middle to fit in top lane, or the new jungle. Until he gets the love he needs as a mid lane, he simply will remain unplayed.
I really hope to hear some ideas, or criticisms. I want to know what people think of Gragas. He is an awesome champion, who could be a lot of fun.
tl;dr Gragas is a mage, he doesn't fit into top lane. Make him a mage again. Just call it how it is.