Anyone remember their first placements?
My first ranked season ever, where I was at my most retarded point- which was amazingly bad, I was placed silver 2. I can tell from playing lots of games in mid silver, that many people are still placed there while in their un-enlightened state.
This, among other things, is bad for ladder health. All I did was throw games for people that had worked hard to get to silver 2. I was literally game cancer, but I didn't know at the time. I thought I had been placed correctly, I thought I was decent. I didn't realize I knew nothing, nothing at all yet.
EVEN WORSE I endured tons of flame for being 'bad'. I was bad, I didn't belong there, I was cancer and it wasn't my fault I was there.
Riot put me there, it ran its calculations and thats where I belonged. It was bad for the invested players, its was bad for the new player. It ruins the ladder and inherently the fun of the game. It creates toxicity in the city (sorry).
Just the idea that riot thinks they can tell a players skill in just 10 games, while that player is with 4 randoms, playing against 5 other randoms... is a complete failure of logic.
There is no way to tell a players skill accurately with that many variables effecting the player. Sure, you may be able to say, oh these stats at this point in the game over ten games... gold 3 player when compared to aggregated player data. Those aggregated stats would be correct of course. However all of those stats within the 10 games were drastically effected by everyone else in the game, so everyone else in the game impacted your performance. 10 games being the key here, if you had that performance over 100 games... ok that may be a little more convincing. NO RIOT NO, NOT 100 PROMO GAMES! Its not what I meant...please.
Just getting countered in lane can drastically impact your performance in a game.
I know I know, some of you will disagree, but wait! I have proof.
Play a ranked game. Seem evenly matched? Everyone on similar pages of skill and game knowledge?
Maybe thats why the game is so toxic? Curious.