From a fiddle main since season one i'll give my 2 cents
Is fiddle OP or UP yes a no.
The problem with fiddle is there is a lot of micromanaging his resources and enemies around him.
To do max damage you have to line up an extra enemy to bounce the crows off of for the drain. YOu have to bait any CC he has or time the drain to get CC but leaving you with the hp to live until you can Drain Crows them. Now doing this Fear will most likely be used offensively. That means knowing who is Mia and who has TP up. With fiddles weak hp and slow run speed if you commit you have to commit. Anything that is half-way ends in death.
When it comes to Items you have to juggle mana, hp/resist, AP and Pen. You need a different build depending on what the make-up and match up is. This leads to one of the issues. There isn't a lot of great runes or items items for him. (besides
) These items are "needed" to deal max damage.
to get more drain ticks in and to escape by using crows to slow.
to get max damage on ult before you are zerged.
interesting thing is I have been buying
less and less. Because besides getting 2 secs of your ult off its a wasted item. The armor doesn't really make any difference with AD. Due to CD on spells living 4 secs instead of 5 doesn't really save me. I go more
for AD and
for AP. People say getting
and
are good but that is only 33 MR pen. If they have more than 82 MR then
would have been better. Often times I find I get
then they turn around and counter all that gold spend with
for 450 gold. That only leaves me with 7 MR pen. Which is not a lot.
Now for the poke it sucks if they get sustain. Because it becomes worthless. But if they don't its op and you can push them out of the lane. Problem comes in because his Crows also push him to the tower. This means he is really really far up and so easy to gank. He run like a fat kid toward sports. Its a stuggle and looks ever awkward.
Fiddle issues are he takes a lot of micro managing for his easy kit. You have to predict the enemies game plan to win. If you build to win the lane you have mana issues. If you build for mana you have damage issues. Everything is a big trade off with him. A lot of the times to you have pull of a couple of attacks and baits to make him work. If you mess one of those up you die or waste everything. Sure his ult is strong but good vision and game play can stop 70% of it. Next none of the "new" runes really scream fiddle. Dark harvest is strong supporting because it help get the tower and gives surprise burst with melee attacks.
My problem is I have to put a lot more skills and perfect game play to = someone just playing another Meta champ 2 or 3 times. Needs one or two different items that screams fiddle. A rune for Dot damage AP. People think fiddle it toxic because they don't know how to play against him. Like why are you standing next to the wall I can ult over while trying taking a turrent. Bro you just saw me and I disappear at 70% hp..... NO I DIDN'T BACK. or standing in my drain rather than one step back and then attack. Getting no sustain in lane when you are laning against him..... CROWS is his only farm spell attack him after his uses it. He will back or use lvl 1 drain. People can get fiddle to have 1/3 there CS but they fill the MUST kill him to win lane. Its kind of funny.
But he is outclassed by other champs. But my skill on fiddle I can compete. That doesn't mean he isn't on the weaker side.
Edit
and
are great items for AP and fiddle NEEDS CD. However, every time I get these I die too quickly to do anything. Fiddle NEEDS HP. this is at gold plat level. Sure I would love to play high AP control fiddle but I can't win games like that above gold. I still have to carry 1 or 2 idiots that fed someone. Maybe its because Burst/poke is too high but you need the HP more imo.