Why is Garen now more of an attack speed champion than Aatrox?
^
^
Having one ability that scales off AS doesn't suddenly make Garen more of an AS champion than Aatrox. The latter DOES benefit from AS, just not as a direct scaling.
Deathbringer Stance's cooldown is reduced by 2 seconds whenever Aatrox hits a champion or large monster with a basic attack...
If you really want to be like old Aatrox and bash people in the face, you're more than welcome to build Guinsoo's on new Aatrox. The phantom hits will further reduce Deathbringer Stance's CD so you can actually proc it pretty quickly later on.
In fact, Aatrox's kit could probably be tweaked slightly to facilitate this...
Hmmmmmmmm.
or
or
depending on enemy team
Bloodrazor, rageblade, titanic, wits end, mallet, tank item. I got from bronze to gold on my smurf after 9.9 playing mostly this build (am plat on main)
Yoo this is dope, gonna try this when I get home [sg-jinx]
Aatrox needed to be changed because old Aatrox needed AS, AD, CDR, Lifesteal, Health, and Resists to be good. The problem is that AS, AD, and Lifesteal are all very expensive stats, and are very rarely found with the defensive stats.
New Aatrox mainly scales on AD, CDR, Health, and Resists. CDR is usually bundled with AD, Health, and Resists so his items choices and core build is much easier to manage and he isn't as heavily punished for going for a greedy item like DD.
I think the main reason they changed Garen is so that he can actually use stuff like Grasp and Tiamat without it feeling like shit once he starts spinning 24/7. The goal isn't to make him good with attack speed, but to make it so that he can actually build a lot of items that are geared around the idea of AS=DPS without it feeling bad.
The difference is that building attack speed on Garen will make you instantly melt anything that touches your spin, while building attack speed an Aatrox will cause you to immediately realize why nobody builds attack speed on Aatrox.
Aatrox is an AD mage now. He scales better with damage and pen.
Edit: Aatrox is a AD Bruiser Mage Assassin Carry
Crittrox OP
Maybe because Aatrox was reworked from his old (but imo great and lovely) state into some scuffed riven 2.0. I mean look at max rank q downtime with 40% cdr on Aatrox, all he does now is press r and use his abilities getting those occasional passive autos off in fights.
Thats literally every rework ever. Riot hates sustain damage champs. Aatrox reworked into a oneshot piece of shit, swain reworked into a oneshot piece of shit, even shen mini reworked from outsustaining and winning by attrition with Q and poke wittling u down into a oneshot piece of shit. Every new champ is a oneshot piece of shit: kai'sa, sylas, neeko, qiyana, akali, irelia.
Only adcs are allowed to deal sustain dmg but even then it's sustained burst dmg since they kill u in three autos.
God do i miss the times when ignite was REQUIRED to have kill pressure in lane but i can already foresee the downvotes and dozens of comments how dmg is now the lowest it has ever been when in reality there were like two champions oneshotting u and everyone hated the shit out of it: rengar and leblanc.
Crit rengo, AP lich bane rengo there were so many r%%%%% tier oneshot builds on rengo. Now being able to one combo people at lvl 3 is a given. HP regen used to mean something. Playing for lategame by rushing a cutlass toplane to outustain a losing matchup and get to your items. Not doable when lategame hits 12 minutes into the game.
Mana pots for sustain in lane.
I’d love to see Swain 1 shot someone in his current state.
Out of your list, Qiyana is the only true one shot PoS. The rest take several seconds to take you down and usually involves hitting a skillshot that you should’ve dodged.
Qiyana is kinda BS because her E makes her combo unavoidable. Like Akali’s old R
he is broken on the PBE. If he goes life like this he is pick or ban
E hitting 24 times in 3s....... With BotRK that is 96% current HP just from the On Hit With Triforce you can Press E hitting with Triforce proc then after 1.5s hit W and Triforce Proc hits again.
Then you have any Tymat Item that procs AOE 24 times....
actually, it's less than that but it is a lot of math
for example, at full health, it does 8% of their max health, but then they have what is left, so the %current gets lower
the number of procs is still ridiculous for any on hit though as that is the equivalent of 8.0 attack speed and more with 
for example,
if all hits are applied, is an extra 180 to 960 bonus damage without the rageblade at 24 hits (wherever that number comes from)
you then add half damage of every on hit on top of that for ridiculous amounts
cause this is how riot balances.
support? MORE DAMAGE assassins? MORE DAMAGE bruisers/tanks? more damage less cooldown more attackspeed. and true damage of course.
Because Riot reworked Aatrox to something more healthy than edgy, worse Tryndamere with the personality of a dirty sock. Whether you accept it or not, Oldtrox had the same problems Trynadmere had, but was just significantly worse. They changed him from auto attack drain tank that had no way to be outplayed when rolling or outplay others in any meaningful way when it came to individual mechanics into a champion who can succeed and screw up based on the player's skill, both the one playing and the one playing against.
If you really miss old Aatrox that much, just play Tryndamere. Or Xin Zhao.
Well Garen was recently shoved into the spotlight by the Youtuber Exil https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sOI2ZQl3ibk
Now anyone who saw this video and is skilled enough is putting in their time on Garen, showing that he isn't the worst champion, and because of that, we are in the meta of infinity edge Garen.
Garen was used in competitive right after this video lol.
Wow, I just played with you in ARAM and you built full attack speed Aatrox, just thought it was funny given the post.
[{quoted}](name=Prospector Pete,realm=NA,application-id=3ErqAdtq,discussion-id=JNnI1G4R,comment-id=0008,timestamp=2019-08-18T02:24:57.320+0000)
Wow, I just played with you in ARAM and you built full attack speed Aatrox, just thought it was funny given the post.
Aatrox is also not a speed attack champion
How does
interact with this? Does it proc off every unit he spins on or only one per tick? Because if it does, then he will be an absolute monster with it in minion waves or teamfights
Pretty sure that Tiamat is "on attack" like rage blade and hurricane, not procced by abilities that apply on hit.
well apparently there's something in garen's code that applies his E as auto attacks
Anklespankin made a video recently and it showed that shen could block garen's E almost completely with his auto attack negation and the ability somehow procc'd auto attack only effects like Tiamat and etc
Tiamat is normal on-hit, even GP can apply it on his Q. His E now applies on-hits on the closest target, it does proc both Tiamat/Ravenous and Titanic, but only once per spin tick.
How does
interact with this? Does it proc off every unit he spins on or only one per tick? Because if it does, then he will be an absolute monster with it in minion waves or teamfights
Yeah every single spin procs the tiamat aoe damage, it's pretty funny. Like all the other on hit effects with his e it's at half damage, though, but it's still good for wave clear. The thing is, his new e on there can already clear waves pretty fast even without Tiamat. And about rageblade as mentioned by RIP Tahm Kench above, his e also stacks rageblade and phantom hits just fyi.
His new spin procs on hits on the closest target at 50% damage
but
has no cooldown on his q. when would you want to use your attack speed?
I was wondering what he was even going to build. About the only atk speed item garens normally get is triforce. He can't stick on anyone well enough to use attack speed well anyway
Frozen mallet is on hit, so his spin will apply it to the nearest target.
[{quoted}](name=Shiroe Okazaki,realm=NA,application-id=3ErqAdtq,discussion-id=JNnI1G4R,comment-id=0000,timestamp=2019-08-17T22:07:32.944+0000)
He can't stick on anyone well enough to use attack speed well anyway
That's why you get this
and as jungle garen you can also use
. Fleet-Footwork also triggers off of the spin giving garen more movespeed, Lethal tempo is overrated.
[{quoted}](name=Shiroe Okazaki,realm=NA,application-id=3ErqAdtq,discussion-id=JNnI1G4R,comment-id=0000,timestamp=2019-08-17T22:07:32.944+0000)
I was wondering what he was even going to build. About the only atk speed item garens normally get is triforce. He can't stick on anyone well enough to use attack speed well anyway
His E also procs onhit effects, aka frozen mallet slow.
pretty sure the attack speed scaling just means garen can build a crit item after his core
Infinity Edge doesn’t give attack speed
[{quoted}](name=Polaris I,realm=NA,application-id=3ErqAdtq,discussion-id=JNnI1G4R,comment-id=00010000,timestamp=2019-08-17T22:14:00.750+0000)
Infinity Edge doesn’t give attack speed
IE is incredibly expensive and not as gold efficient as zeal items until you get more than one crit item
pretty sure the attack speed scaling just means garen can build a crit item after his core
you mean 4 IE?
Triforce PD and then Sunfire/Visage etc. not to mention the attack speed scaling works with his level ups as well.
I think he is still on the damage side. The only true attack speed champion is YI, if you exclude adc and yasuo. Think about it, Garen wears plates, how fast he can go? It has to be damage not speed.
See my comment below
See my comment below
AOE is not true attack speed.
More AS -> more consistent damage -> less punishable downtime -> Better as a Freight Train Jugg.
i'd like to try reworked garen in urf tbh
Yeah it is very depressing how they take away from people (for no reason) to give things to others no one is asking for. Resulting in less fun and more polarization.
I've been saying Garen's E should scale with attack speed since season 4 lol
like why doesnt riven buy attspeed dude : spell reliant
they only changed garens E so that he could get more benefit off buidling trinity
+
+ Conqueror = Insane healing. No seriously, He can heal up to half HP while having 3000+ HP, that's scary.
Because new Garen learned from old Aatrox, and New Aatrox learned from old Garen.