Shyvana Buff is Lazy and Doesn't Sovle Any of Her Problems

Frosted Tips··20 votes·11,933 views

This seems to be a lazy buff. To me it seems like Riot finally heard enough complaints about how people utterly hate Shyvana's awful passive so they just decided, "fine we will buff her." But this is not what players want or what Shyvana needs.

Shyvana's stupid gimmicky passive really is bad. I'm talking about the armor and magic resist gained from killing dragons. That part is just a stupid gimmick added seemingly without reason to her kit. If by some act of a higher being Shyvana can manage to get all the dragons up until just over 30 minutes without delay she can earn a total of 30 armor and 30 magic resist. That's great and all, but if this is the case then there is almost a 95% chance that the team Shyvana is on already has the game sealed up, so it was meaningless and any less is pretty negligible.

Riot needs to scrap this part of her passive and give Shyvana power where she desperately needs it. Shyvana has insanely long cooldowns early game, and could really use a buff on those, or she could use a way to CC her targets. Also she does not need to kill dragons faster. She already kills them quickly and she would receive little to no benefit from this.

So Riot should not just insert this idea that took them 5 minutes to think of and actually look into what huge problems Shyvana has right now and try to fix that.

23 Comments

Raiku Kawisa7 votes

I was so excited when I saw they were looking to buff Shyvana... I'm still waiting to see the actual buff.

Seriously though, Shyvana already takes dragons fast enough, her ability to take objectives have never been in question. The issue is her ability to effect fights. She has no CC, so she needs to do damage, but outside of her ult & her minor W MS, she has no ability to get to critical targets.

She needs a buff that helps her in fights.

ModAcademy Kayn3 votes

I mean, when Shyvana's no longer a stat check, I'd be fine with buffing her ability to fight. As it stands though, there's not a lot you can do against her in a normal skirmish. Buffing her objective control, when they specifically said they only aim for a slight increase in power, seems fair enough.

Raiku Kawisa1 votes

I can certainly agree there. Shyvana is certainly a number's game. She either can kill you, and you die. Or she can't kill you, and she dies. I was still hoping for something more substantial than a passive buff on a passive that I forget even exists half the time.

Shiroe Okazaki1 votes

why not give a part of her a rework. maybe her passive buffs her ulti and gives a new mechanic to it or in dragon form one of her abilities gain a new mechanic. I know she'd probably have to lose something for that so she doesn't have too much in her abilities. ( like most of the new champs )

Flashes6 votes

I agree completely. It's almost like Wukong's passive in a sense. "Here's a flat amount of Armor/Magic resist for this conditional that has realistically no impact on how you play this champion."

Edit: No Shyvana is going to say "Let's do this dragon because I need 4 more Armor and MR." They're going to take dragon because they need dragon. Same for Wukong. No Wukong is going to say "I am going in 1v5 because of the additional 20-30 resistances I get." They're going to go in for a team wide knockup, and stealth out.

Sexy Jack Rabbit3 votes

I think the difference is moreso that Wukong is an Old Champion with an Old Passive. He needs work, there's really no doubt about that. His passive is suited to the diver they kind of made him to be but he didn't age well.

Shyv's current passive is a relatively new passive, so that kind of speaks for how poor it is to buff it now of all times.

Vlada Cut2 votes

Her passive is utter garbage and inferior version of Garen's W passive. 40 armor and magic ressidt, for killing minions and champions. More stats, for less work. That's stupid.

Flashes1 votes

[{quoted}](name=Vlada Cut,realm=EUNE,application-id=3ErqAdtq,discussion-id=BqEyAALA,comment-id=0003,timestamp=2019-01-11T15:29:22.353+0000)

Her passive is utter garbage and inferior version of Garen's W passive. 40 armor and magic ressidt, for killing minions and champions. More stats, for less work. That's stupid.

And a 10% -> 20% damage increase towards dragons which makes her objective game stronk

Profirix1 votes

Correction: Objective game against dragons ONLY

Flashes1 votes

However, luckily they're planning to add an extra 10% damage to dragon dealing damage, so they are looking at ways to increase the impact of Shyvana's passive. That is the part that WILL influence how people play Shyvana. From "We can't take this Dragon" to "We can take this dragon".

Thefrostyviking9 votes

Like.......a shyv can already solo dragon at level ...3-4 after the first clear as long as she doesnt get stopped so a buff to helping her with this kinda seems utterly pointless.

Only thing shyv has to be scared off is enemy jungle or support or midlane crashing on her when she does it, and no mere 10% bonus damage to dragons will help with that.

LittleDemonTrist2 votes

If she can do drake faster, enemy has less time to react.

Thefrostyviking8 votes

Trust me, if the enemy is in any kind of position to react to shyv then its already a lost case for her, she has no sustain/resistance or mobility early so even if the support is the one who jumps her when she tries to sneak dragon early she is dead.

10%? 10 hits becomes 9, i cant say its a big difference.

Like even now Shyv wont even attempt going for Dragon unless she sees enemy jungle move for her toplane/their jungle or even her jungle while either midlane or botlane is stable and the other side warded so she can see if anyone comes towards her.

And when that is happening its not a situation where 1 or 2 hits here and there would matter much.

Heck most of her damage on Dragon comes from hitting it while her E is on it at any rate and that ability has a damage cap on monsters and minions.

Shiroe Okazaki1 votes

having played her just recently. the buff to dragon taking is hardly noticeable. her having the obj control isn't bad or anything, But its gonna do nothing for her.

Alzon1 votes

A couple good buffs to Shyvana without increasing her damage would be adding Tenacity to either her ult or Burnout (or even just Dragon Form Burnout), and increasing her passive’s base amount from 5 to 10 of armor and MR. Just some more tools to help her do more early in the game.

AIQ1 votes

Yeah, I got the opportunity to talk to Meddler the day 9.2 was announced he stated that scaling with elder will be added

Meddler (NA) I'll follow up on scaling off Elder Dragons taken, hadn't realized that wasn't already in, not immediately seeing any reason it shouldn't be regardless of what else we do.

While Shyvana has many problems the elder addition removes one big one in that Shyvana like all other objective scaling champions (rengar/kindred) now has infinite opportunities to get her passive.

However, with the jungle nerfs again, it's extremely unfair to leave Shyvana in this state.

She needs some QOL buffs. Scale with elder Gain fury while dead. Decay on her W

There a many iterations of the passive I've heard and thought of. Harder Scaling/Buffing her team with it/ having the dragons in a set order and getting a special buff. Etc.

Her Passive and lack luster ult need big changes.

Profirix1 votes

5 -> 10 armor/mr per dragon really wouldn't be that big of a deal. You get what? maximum 60 additional resists and thats if you are even capable of holding 6!!!!! dragons. You have to basically already have the game in the bag to get that many.

AIQ3 votes

One of my personal ideas was Augments.

Each one of the 4 Dragons spawn, if Shyvana has not obtained a Dragon it will continue to spawn (up to 3 times), Gaining 2 of the same dragon type does not obtain an augment. If Shyvana takes down Baron Nashor or Elder, the first augment slot that was not obtained is filled.

AUG 1: Ocean, Mana regen is converted to HP regen. Flame breaths passive effect now slows on hit.

AUG 2: Mountain, Burnout now gives +10/15/20 (with ult level) armor and MR while active.

AUG 3: Cloud, Twin bite increase Shyvanas attack speed by 10/15/ 20% and burnouts MVSPD (with ult level)

AUG 4: Infernal, While in Dragon form a burn trail is left, in addition Shyvanas basic attacks have a DOT effect.

AUG 5: Elder ONLY, All on hit effects from Shyvanas W/E are converted to true damage for the duration of the buff. (If Shyvana has missed a Dragon prior to Elder that Augment will be acquired first.)

Profirix1 votes

That is a really cool idea to give her meaningful power.

PrinceOfStorms1 votes

Riot stealth nerfed Shyvana into the bottom of F tier though. Now Q does reduced damage to structures (starting at 50% at rank 1 and scaling up to 100% with Q rank) which actually kills the ability for her to push with the AP build which is meta for her right now (where max order is EWQ).

TheHeadShot1 votes

I feel a lazy, yet easy fix for our favourite half dragon would be this:

For every dragon shyvana or her team take she gains 10% cool down reduction.

Having cool down on her would make the champions biggest weekness a solvable part of her kit & make taking dragons an actual benefit as 10% cdr is considerable.

If you really wanted to Buff her, they could make you R have an additional affect whist already in dragon form. Or to be able to be recast on a take down so she can use it to fly to enemy's multiple times in one fight.

KelmirOsue1 votes

So, here's what I think. Her passive needs a buff more then anything I think we all can agree on that. So here's my ideas

Deal 40% more damage to dragons. This should make it much more noticeable

For every dragon she kills, she gets 15 armor and magic resist. As well as 10 AP per dragon kill. In addition she gains 50 HP. And gets 5% CDR, as well as deal damage over time while in dragon form. Scaling based on how many dragons killed for 3 seconds. This increases based off of 20% ability power or attack power. Whichever is higher 15/30/45/60/75/90/105.... For each Elder dragon killed, increase her armor and magic resist by 20

snake929041 votes

I dont want Shyvana to be buffed. I like her passive because I enjoy taking objectives and farming, then scaling late game. I dont want her to be tier 2 because then I will have to deal with people banning Shyvana. Leave my champion alone Riot. 😢

More from Gameplay

More by Frosted Tips