Swain player here:
I have mixed feeling about his Update - on the one hand it is well done, his Beatrice feels even more unique, he still feels like the BigBossBird I love to play and his visuals are also better. In Late you have ess problems to deal with.
BUT: The update has ALOT of downsides as well.
- I love toggle Ults, removed. Not for style or gameplay - just because they had no idea how to properly nerf him.
- His E - once your main Spell you want to max out, now just a green bubble you throw to deal DMG... there are alot of overloaded abilities in the game, and we really dont need more... but this E feels heavily under-loaded!
- His Power: What the update did - instead of their desire to give a champ clear strenght and weaknes. They made a 180 and REDUCED Swain weaknes resulting in (obviously) him being so much over-powered, they directly nerfed his strenght to stop him.
Swain was this Champ with a pathetic early. Sore Wavecontroll, no mobility, just some tools to prevent engages and some mediocre low rang poke.
but if he was good enough to get even into midgame, you became a monster to deal with only capped by your mana-bar essentially working like Energy with no regen except with kills. xD
The update gave him wavecontroll (alot), he got more range and therefore poke! You now have a decent laning and no problems getting into midgame.... (do you see the problem????????). And than they buffed his Mana-Pool directly AND indirectly by Items....
OFC he is OP now! Instantly he's OP needs nerfs! (Who'd expected this? D:) But instead of fixing the problems - they hit his midgame.. his strenght... GJ!
They didn't destroy him - he still feels good to play (although some matchups went upside down... looking at Yasuo).
But I question the Value of the update... His Q feels less clunky - his R feels more clunky. His laning feels better his mid feels worse.
he went from a low-pick-high-win-rate Mid-Top to low-pick-high-win-rate Mid/Top. Profit?
I guess I'd not revert the update completely - but I'd fix his Ult. (And maybe his E, but that's hard without direct buffs)