Skip to content

Let's talk about minion collision

Savage Câbbage··34 votes·3,253 views

So I'll try to keep in my rage, but minion collision is litteraly the worst thing in the entire game for me, except that it seems completely useless to me it's also really annoying and has killed me quite a lot of times. I know there are items and champion passives that take away unit collision, but I don't care about that. The only thing minion collision does is make you stuck between two minions because the game doesn't know how to comprehend a few little minions standing in your way, when you're trying to run away or chase someone but there's a minion wave in the way, you'll just keep trying to get past it left-right-left-right-left-right just pretty much stopping you in your path for a second or two. When you're pushing a turret and you want to fall back because you are getting ganked, it's not going to happen because YOUR mage minions have formed a solid wall making you have to walk around them giving the jungler a few more seconds to kill you while you're under their turret. There's not really a lot to add to this but I just wanted to get this off my mind.

P.S I'm not English, so I hope everything is understandable.

EDIT: I didn't know they were going to patch the path finding (It's about time...), so that will probably change a lot. This might actually fix the whole issue I have. But we will see...

EDIT 2: I'm only talking about walking into minions, not skillshots hitting minions...

53 Comments

Dreadlocks20 votes

I wouldn't mind keeping unit collision when running through enemy minions, but can we remove being blocked by our own minions for starters xD?

Remlap12234 votes

That's exactly how it works in Smite, and it's actually less necessary in Smite considering they have a full WSAD full movement system, and not the gawdfukingawful pathing League has.

Ajacks13372 votes

Smite is terribad, get out

Beowulfss8 votes

"I know there are items and champion passives that take away unit collision, but I don't care about that."

tl:dr I want to whine and complain about something that is already solved by a few items or champions in the game. Why should I have to utilize these tools that are already at my disposal?

Savage Câbbage15 votes

There are enough champions that don't really need phantom dancer, or champions that aren't Hecarim or Kassadin.

Bouffon dAnglais3 votes

I think Fizz's passive allows him to go through minions, too. only adding to his slipperiness

Savage Câbbage1 votes

I don't think being slippery makes you go right through stuff though.

Rinky Dinky30 votes

Yes lets build PD on nautilus

The Bíg Ticket2 votes

Works with his W...the attack speed gives you so many attacks during the 10 second duration of his shield.

Crett8 votes

[{quoted}](name=Danielas Kitten,realm=EUW,application-id=3ErqAdtq,discussion-id=40TsRNIp,comment-id=000100010000,timestamp=2015-07-07T00:03:24.730+0000)

Works with his W...the attack speed gives you so many attacks during the 10 second duration of his shield.

?????Nautilus????

WHAT?/??

Chaotic Reks1 votes

Sadly, Critilus is a thing...

Ancestor0072 votes

Yes, let's build it on Lux

Ace Access 3 votes

so your saying we should build item 3046 on every champ

Remlap12236 votes

Didn't you hear? The nice guy on the enemy team told me that it was OP on Veigar. Also he told me that D was to dance! I would've never known!

Remlap12234 votes

Aatrox Ahri Akali Alistar Amumu Anivia Annie Azir Bard Blitzcrank Brand Braum Cassiopeia Chogath Corki Darius Diana DrMundo Draven Draven Ekko Elise Evelynn Ezreal Fiddlesticks Fiora Galio Gangplank Garen Gnar Gragas Hecarim Heimerdinger Irelia Janna JarvanIV Jax Jayce Karma Karthus Katarina Kayle Kennen Khazix Leblanc LeeSin Leona Lissandra Lulu Lux Malphite Malzahar Maokai MissFortune Mordekaiser Morgana Nami Nasus Nautilus Nidalee Nocturne Nunu Olaf Orianna Pantheon Poppy Quinn Rammus RekSai Renekton Riven Rumble Ryze Sejuani Shen Shyvana Singed Sion Sivir Skarner Sona Soraka Swain Syndra Talon Taric Teemo Thresh Trundle TwistedFate Udyr Urgot Varus Veigar Velkoz Vi Viktor Vladimir Volibear Warwick MonkeyKing Xerath XinZhao Yasuo Yorick Zac Zed Ziggs Zilean Zyra

This is literally all of the champions that Phantom Dancer is extremely inefficient at best to downright trolling at worst on.

Alistar Evelynn Fizz Hecarim Kassadin

These are the champions that never have to worry about it due to their passives or a single ability that makes friendly unit collision something that they don't have to worry about.

Ashe Caitlyn Draven Graves Twitch

And finally, these are the champions that actually build Phantom Dancer efficiently (core even), but still don't get the unit collision ignore effect until after the point where it'd be the MOST FUCKING HELPFUL HAS PASSED ALREADY.

Last I checked, a **HUUUUUGE **QOL buff to 125 champions versus an extremely unnoticeable indirect nerf to 4 is something I'd consider to be "fostering champion diversity." You know, the big thing Riot loves?

Dextix LT1 votes

Draven Draven is in every list.

There can never be too much of DRAAAAAAVEN

Ace Access 1 votes

Garen DEMACIAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA!!

Bodkins Odds1 votes

Um, you put Janna in the wrong list. Her W passive lets her ignore unit collision.

Remlap12231 votes

Yup, forgot to take Hecarim off of the initial list as well. You try sifting through that shit when all you have is the chronological order when champions were conceptualized, but also goes all the way up to 250 for whatever reason. I don't get why you can't just see the icons.

Morgy Morgy8 votes

Unit collision fucks me up every time I play Draven, catching those axes becomes more of a chore than it should be when I keep getting stuck in the minion waves.

Remlap12231 votes

I seriously doubt Draven is the only one Riot is worried about. If they were so worried about his ability to keep his Q up and passive stacked, wouldn't they have just nerfed his damage and implemented this?

I don't know why, but Riot seems to either not understand how this impacts the game negatively, or they're so worried that they'll turn game balance on its head from this (spoiler alert, it won't, besides maybe a spike in Draven and Zac players.)

Beowulfss3 votes

Then I guess you dont pritorize the added benefit of the said items or champions do you? fizz is also another one

Savage Câbbage17 votes

I looked it up, there are 12 champions that have some sort of ability or passive to remove unit collision, that makes about 10% of the champions, so you're saying I should just play those champions just because they don't have unit collision? And just ignore all the other about 108 champions?

Beowulfss4 votes

Would you please point to the place where I said play only 10% of champs? I said you must not prioritize unit collision, if you don't want to play a champion that has it or build an item that enables it. It is a benefit, not a necessity. Look at invulerable moves. They are an added plus for certain champs, so should we remove it since not every champ has it/ it isnt in their perfect build?

tl:dr If you want to ignore unit collision, then you need to prioritize for it. Just like I prioritize crit for tryn, CDR for fizz, and AD for an ADC.

Savage Câbbage12 votes

Did you even read my post, all it says is that unit collision is useless except that it's really annoying. Having more crit chance makes you stronger, having more damage makes you stronger, having more defence makes you stronger, having more CDR makes your stronger, not having unit collision just takes away the annoyance.

Dulu2 votes

Except, it's not useless.

You use the example of running away from someone. Well, that person chasing you finds those minions very useful, since you are now caught in them, and probably dead.

Removing unit collision would be a huge ninja buff to every single melee character in this game.

Savage Câbbage2 votes

{quoted}

Except, it's not useless.

You use the example of running away from someone. Well, that person chasing you finds those minions very useful, since you are now caught in them, and probably dead.

Removing unit collision would be a huge ninja buff to every single melee character in this game.

But the problem is, it's pretty much based on luck, and most of the time it's really frustrating, using your example, sometimes the path finding will work, but sometimes it won't know what to do and (as I said) you will just be stuck on a minion because the path finding can't decide if you have to go left-right-left-right.

Hyrum Graff1 votes

{quoted}

But the problem is, it's pretty much based on luck, and most of the time it's really frustrating, using your example, sometimes the path finding will work, but sometimes it won't know what to do and (as I said) you will just be stuck on a minion because the path finding can't decide if you have to go left-right-left-right.

Pretty much this. I'd be much more okay with unit collision if it functioned the way it intuitively should.

JayenKei1 votes

{quoted}

Did you even read my post, all it says is that unit collision is useless except that it's really annoying. Having more crit chance makes you stronger, having more damage makes you stronger, having more defence makes you stronger, having more CDR makes your stronger, not having unit collision just takes away the annoyance.

I have to disagree. Having no unit collision actually helps a lot when trading in lane. The fact that I can walk through creeps and make sure that my opponent cannot trade with me is a very nice, albeit small advantage to have. It also helps when you're running away and such and such. In my opinion this isn't something that needs to be addressed. League already is an extremely player friendly game and things like creep block keeps league from going a little too player friendly.

ChaoticPinecone2 votes

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LFw-C__upQg

Unit collision is important so this doesnt happen with every champion.

Ajacks13371 votes

Yes this needs to be upvoted lol.

Ooh kill em

CrazedPorcupine3 votes

after a lot of thought, the only reason minion collision exists, is because of the remnant from DotA and the ability to block creeps to delay their entrance to lane so you can last hit easier and more safely or to pull them into a jungle camp to help manipulate a wave.

Since neither of those things are possible in League, I feel like minion collision (at least with friendly minions) should be removed.

Draykow2 votes

I would like it if allied minions had smaller collision boxes than enemy minions.

Remlap12232 votes

They should have none whatsover. Smite does this and they have a full WSAD movement system. If a game that has a much greater control over your movement allows this, then why can't League, which has one of the worst pathing I've ever experienced.

Draykow1 votes

{quoted}

They should have none whatsover. Smite does this and they have a full WSAD movement system. If a game that has a much greater control over your movement allows this, then why can't League, which has one of the worst pathing I've ever experienced.

Strategic diversity is the answer. And Smite doesn't have pathing if it's WASD movement. I think it's neat that there's no collision with other champs though. In Dota the creep are the same size as the heroes and the heroes can move-block each other, sometimes with nightmare-ish results!

SoMNia2 votes

Unit collision is a good thing. It adds strategic depth to the game. If you want to ignore it, bring Ghost, or build a Phantom Dancer. There's a reason that item is not convenient to build on every champion. Some champions benefit from the ability a lot more than others, and SHOULDN'T have easy access to it. If you really "don't care" about that, then keep tripping on minions. If you put yourself in a position where your minions have piled up behind you, and you can't escape a gank, that is not the minions' fault, but yours. It's annoying when minions block skillshots, too, but there's a reason only some of them ignore minions. Sad how everyone pointing out that this is how the game is SUPPOSED to work is getting a mass of downvotes.

Truth is, the real problem is with pathing. It's terrible in this game. But I heard somewhere that it's supposed to be getting an overhaul/upgrade.

Savage Câbbage2 votes

{quoted}

Unit collision is a good thing. It adds strategic depth to the game. If you want to ignore it, bring Ghost, or build a Phantom Dancer. There's a reason that item is not convenient to build on every champion. Some champions benefit from the ability a lot more than others, and SHOULDN'T have easy access to it. If you really "don't care" about that, then keep tripping on minions. If you put yourself in a position where your minions have piled up behind you, and you can't escape a gank, that is not the minions' fault, but yours. It's annoying when minions block skillshots, too, but there's a reason only some of them ignore minions. Sad how everyone pointing out that this is how the game is SUPPOSED to work is getting a mass of downvotes.

Truth is, the real problem is with pathing. It's terrible in this game. But I heard somewhere that it's supposed to be getting an overhaul/upgrade.

So, I should get ghost or phantom dancer or not push as a melee champion, just so I don't have problems with minion collision? And btw, when I'm talking about minion collision I'm only talking about champions colliding with minions, not skillshots. And yes, there seem to be a lot of people talking about this 'pathing overhaul', so let's hope for the best.

SoMNia1 votes

Well, no. You push from the sides of the minion wave, or CS with any ranged skillshots if they're in the middle. That's part of the challenge of playing a melee champion. I definitely agree that it sucks to get stuck on minions because the game can't decide which path to take to get around them, so your champion just runs back and forth over the same ~20 units, even though the lane's wide open. But this is the reason people click A LOT when playing this game. Pathing sucks right now. Don't rely on it.

LadyRenly2 votes

Creep block is not an issue. Derp pathing is.

Ace Access 1 votes

no kidding, I've had lots of problems because of this shit

Remlap12232 votes

Well, creep block is part of the reason for derp pathing. But like I've said 3 times already, if a game that has full WSAD movement removes collision ignore on friendly minions, then why can't it be implemented on a derpy pathing game like League, especially since Draven and Zac exist?

ChaosThief1 votes

I think there was a point where my champion starting just stuttering in the same spot trying to find a way to get across a single jungle path.

I MEAN, COME ON. YOU WALK THAT WAY, NOT THAT HARD.

Guy Fox Teemo2 votes

Well then in lane i can just stand on top of my minons and ignore every skill shot, easily, instead of having to walk around everywhere so you don't get hit by skill shots.

Savage Câbbage1 votes

{quoted}

Well then in lane i can just stand on top of my minons and ignore every skill shot, easily, instead of having to walk around everywhere so you don't get hit by skill shots.

You can also just walk behind minions with the same effect, and I don't mean it like that, just so you don't get stuck behind minions.

Chaotic Reks2 votes

I was playing against a Malphite top as Shen and i killed him by slapping him to death because HIS OWN MINIONS blocked him into me and he couldn't do anything about it.

Downfall1 votes

Can we please like, swap item 3009 item 3046 Passives?

Celebrimborr1 votes

Kassadin Kassadin Kassadin Kassadin Kassadin Kassadin Kassadin Kassadin Kassadin Kassadin Kassadin Kassadin Kassadin Kassadin Kassadin Kassadin Kassadin Kassadin Kassadin Kassadin Kassadin Kassadin Kassadin Kassadin Kassadin Kassadin Kassadin Kassadin Kassadin Kassadin Kassadin Kassadin Kassadin Kassadin Kassadin Kassadin Kassadin Kassadin Kassadin Kassadin Kassadin Kassadin Kassadin Kassadin Kassadin Kassadin Kassadin Kassadin Kassadin KassadinKassadin Kassadin Kassadin Kassadin Kassadin Kassadin Kassadin Kassadin Kassadin Kassadin Kassadin Kassadin Kassadin Kassadin Kassadin Kassadin Kassadin Kassadin Kassadin Kassadin Kassadin Kassadin Kassadin Kassadin Kassadin Kassadin Kassadin Kassadin Kassadin Kassadin No unit collision

ChaosThief2 votes

Because everyone plays kassadin, right?

More from Gameplay

More by Savage Câbbage