then why isnt annies q point and click?
Because she was made in the same era as Ryze and never received the major overhaul reworks that Ryze had.
Let me turn your own argument against you. Her kit has been polarizing for the longest time, and only recently has been toned down now that more champs can handle her flash R combo. Because both of us can recognize these elements of her kit as bad, why do you want Ryze's design to go back to how she's designed?
See the thing you have to understand now is that it's not just about balance. We can balance any champion by dumpstering their stats one way or another, but if they are that polarizing broken messes like old Poppy, ESPECIALLY old Poppy, isn't it better game design to just remove these horribly toxic older elements of game design with newer updated parts?