Skip to content

13 Comments

Metal Janna2 votes

A list of crappy things about X:

  1. The first thing: I think this is crap because blah blah blah
  2. The second thing: Wait wtf why does it say one again?
  3. The third thing: Seriously why does using a line break cause the list to fucking break?

This is what's wrong with the numbered list feature. You add a line explaining in more detail the thing you listed, and it breaks the list. Just keep counting, forum!

Hotarµ1 votes

Just keep counting, forum!

It's because you're breaking the format by spacing it out.

If you do this:

  1. I dislike Annie.

I don't think she should be able to hold her stun indefinitely.

  1. I like Ivern.

His kit is unique and fun to play with or against.

You're breaking the format by spacing everything out. However, if you don't space it out, you get this:

  1. I dislike Annie. I don't think she should be able to hold her stun indefinitely.
  2. I like Ivern. His kit is unique and fun to play with or against.

A proper listing.

If you want to make an incredibly detailed post with tons of data or spaced lines, use an alternative symbol like em dashes or hyphens.

1 - I dislike Annie.

I don't think she should be able to hold her stun indefinitely. Also, bears are scary IRL so Volibear and Tibbers should be reworked.

2 - I like Ivern.

The format works when you use it correctly, not when you break it apart and rearrange it. The list function is supposed to be for quick and non-spaced paragraphs.

Metal Janna1 votes

You're absolutely correct. I still wish they'd change it so there has to be a blank line in order for the list to be considered ended, because that's not the way humans read lists.

Hotarµ1 votes

You're absolutely correct. I still wish they'd change it so there has to be a blank line in order for the list to be considered ended, because that's not the way humans read lists.

Lists are meant to be short and to the point, not multiple incredibly detailed paragraphs. I can understand it as a QOL thing I guess but it works both functionally and logically.

FireDrizzle1 votes

[{quoted}](name=Metal Janna,realm=NA,application-id=6heBIhQc,discussion-id=axlPyAk5,comment-id=0001,timestamp=2019-06-18T14:29:26.980+0000)

A list of crappy things about X:

  1. The first thing: I think this is crap because blah blah blah
  2. The second thing: Wait wtf why does it say one again?
  3. The third thing: Seriously why does using a line break cause the list to fucking break?

This is what's wrong with the numbered list feature. You add a line explaining in more detail the thing you listed, and it breaks the list. Just keep counting, forum!

Thats a good example of how bad it is, thank you.

Hotarµ2 votes

And did you see the link where I had my 2 changed?

I just checked out that comment and it's because you put a double space inbetween the numbers.

If you do this:

  1. Test

  2. Test

It will show up as a new list because you're breaking the format of a list. Follow the format correctly and you get:

(no spaces)

  1. Test
  2. Test

Alternatively, use a different method like hyphens or em dashes and you can use whatever style you want.

1 - Test literally anything you want even an emote 2 - Test

It's not that hard to get around the formatting of a list.

Do the designers of the forum want too wipe my bum too?

I love that you're asking for something to be changed and you're still insulting the Boards team the entire time.

How about you voice your complaints constructively since you're one of the only people who struggles to use this feature? It works correctly when you follow the correct format.

FireDrizzle1 votes

It will show up as a new list because you're breaking the format of a list. Follow the format correctly and you get:

I dont care, there is no reason for me too have too follow some format.

you're still insulting the Boards team the entire time.

I'm just pointing out the nonsense of its handholding.

How about you voice your complaints constructively since you're one of the only people who struggles to use this feature? It works correctly when you follow the correct format

Actually functionally this forum is very bad and that isnt opinion. I dont struggle too use a feature, I have a forced unneeded feature editing my posts.

Hotarµ2 votes

I dont care, there is no reason for me too have too follow some format. I'm just pointing out the nonsense of its handholding.

[zombie-brand-mindblown]

Actually functionally this forum is very bad and that isnt opinion.

Yes, it is an opinion, because you're in the minority here. Very few people actually complain about the technical side of the forums aside from the most glaring issue of moderators not being able to move posts.

I dont struggle too use a feature, I have a forced unneeded feature editing my posts.

Nothing is forcing you to do anything, the format is clearly laid out for you and you're breaking it, then complaining when it doesn't work.

That's like complaining that a mathematical equation doesn't work after you do it backwards. The format is there, you're not following the rules for it to work. The fault does not lie with the format.

FireDrizzle1 votes

{quoted} Yes, it is an opinion, because you're in the minority here. Very few people actually complain about the technical side of the forums aside from the most glaring issue of moderators not being able to move posts.

An opinion, hm. Theres a lot wrong with the fourm, like searches not working, randomly losing ability too upvote or downvote and posts being in nonsensical order, just off the top of my head. I'm not that passionate about it but, I have too counter this nonsense.

Nothing is forcing you to do anything, the format is clearly laid out for you and you're breaking it, then complaining when it doesn't work.

Yes im forced too follow a format when i've listed things in a readable and logical format.

That's like complaining that a mathematical equation doesn't work after you do it backwards. The format is there, you're not following the rules for it to work. The fault does not lie with the format.

It's more like complaining autocorrect corrected something for no reason. The fault cleary does lie with the format, there is no reason i cant put a space between things in a list, nor a reason you cant elaborate on a list like

A list of crappy things about X:

  1. The first thing: I think this is crap because blah blah blah
  2. The second thing: Wait wtf why does it say one again?
  3. The third thing: Seriously why does using a line break cause the list to fucking break?

This is what's wrong with the numbered list feature. You add a line explaining in more detail the thing you listed, and it breaks the list. Just keep counting, forum!

Elite4Runner1 votes

I understand that the logic is counter-intuitive, .. but I can't think of a reason you would need to do this.

If you're going to number a subset, then restart the number sequence .. you should have a new heading to describe the new set.

Set #1

    1. Item 1
    1. Item 2

Set #2

    1. Item 3
    1. Item 4
FireDrizzle1 votes

{quoted}

I understand that the logic is counter-intuitive, .. but I can't think of a reason you would need to do this.

If you're going to number a subset, then restart the number sequence .. you should have a new heading to describe the new set.

Set #1

    1. Item 1
    1. Item 2

Set #2

    1. Item 3
    1. Item 4

And did you see the link where I had my 2 changed? The forum shouldnt be changing my numbers anyway, like I'm too stupid too put the number i mean. Do the designers of the forum want too wipe my bum too?

I just typed those numbers in the op too show that the forum changes your numbers, I had it mess me up in different ways but I cant remember how off hand and don't want too look through all my posting history.

ModPrandine1 votes

Definitely understand your frustration on that part. I'm no boards developer but I've found that the issue seems to commonly stem from using a period at the end of a number, while no issue comes up when using a parenthesis after it. For example:

It's more time consuming and tedious definitely but it's something I've found to work consistently.

More from Discuss the Boards

More by FireDrizzle