[LORE DISCUSSION] The Black Rose

ModCaptainMårvelous··12 votes·8,843 views

Lore Discussion Omni-Post

PREVIOUS DISCUSSIONS Who built the Mercury Hammer? Are the Watchers Void-Beings? What happened in Shurima? Shurima Part 2 Who killed the man Yasuo was guarding? Who is C?

Happy Friday everyone and welcome back to Lore Discussion! So this week's topic was a pretty close one with over 100 votes and several neck-and-neck topics. By a mere three votes, this week's topic won out. So today, we'll be diving into the trecherous and deceitful world of Noxus to ask about the organization who's name is whispered in even the highest ranking households of the city...

http://i.imgur.com/V1OXYZ8.jpg?1 #The Black Rose


http://i.imgur.com/FzfhqyF.jpg #What is the Black Rose?

The Black Rose is an organization that has it's ties back before many of the cities we know today were even villages on the outskirts of an ancient Runeterra. Not much is known for a solid history, but it's clear we have very few key facts to cling onto:

  • The Black Rose has it's ties to the Noxus hierarchy and as such, Noxus itself.
  • Many of the Black Rose and it's allies are versed in magic.
  • The key goals are unknown, but it's clear that the Black Rose wants to establish itself as the puppetmaster behind the scenes.

In the original lore (Pre-retcon), the Black Rose waited until the League of Legends (Institute of War) was created and had firm, cemented power in it's wake before sending the esteemed LeBlanc to it's doorstep. Apparently they were waiting for a global authority to emerge before showing themselves and making their presence..."known". Still, the goals in the new lore are not clear outside of the ties they have with the Noxus hierarchy.


http://i.imgur.com/25GOZA3.png #The Organization of the Black Rose

Thanks to the "Reborn" teaser, we gathered some key facts about the actual organization of the Black Rose. Mainly, the fact that there are (at least) three key members among them.

  • Thorn- Thorn references the base of the petal, where there are thorns (Shocker). My personal theory is that Thorn represents the physical worker of the Black Rose. He or She is the one who partakes in assassination missions or otherwise murder, assault or other things of a physical nature. He/She is the one who is primarily the cause of stabbings and murderings that go unanswered.

  • Petal- Again, more flower symbolism (In the Black Rose? Shocking again!), the Petal strikes me as the "beauty" of the Black Rose. Perhaps a beautiful female or a handsome man, the Petal is the person who whispers sweet poison in the ears of the Black Roses' manipulatee. Through favors of the romantic or the sexual, the Petal twists the words of the Black Rose into honey and makes their will known through more subtle means.

  • LeBlanc- Finally, the "Face" of the Black Rose, LeBlanc is the leader and overall matron of the entire organization. There are some more things to ask about LeBlanc, but we'll wait until the next section.

So of those roles, are any still around? Well, I have my theories. For one thing, while we don't see the petal/thorn show up in later examples, I'd hazard a guess that the lore might shift. I, for one, could see Cassiopeia have the role of the "Petal", as she is (well, "was") a beautiful consort who wove her words with the venom that she now uses to stab people in the face with. For "Thorn", I'm still a little up in the air about it. Normal signs point to Talon being a possible suspect thanks to his stab-happy dagger flinging ways, but it's possible that Katarina or even her father could have ties. Heck, I could be wrong and NONE of these people are even remotely with the Rose.


http://i.imgur.com/qKJQCOS.jpg?1 #LeBlanc

Now, LeBlanc is an interesting figure for a few reasons. For one, she is present in the Reborn saga throughout the ages. From Sion's death to imprisonment to rebirth, LeBlanc is center stage. Following this, LeBlanc is both mentally sound and more than magically capable. She's able to hold her own in these League matches and can take a punch just as well as any other magus. (Not that great but bear with me).

So the question is: Is LeBlanc a title passed down through the Rose or is LeBlanc somewhat immortal?

Now, the title being passed down is the more likely of the two. LeBlanc is not a person but an ideal of the Black Rose. LeBlanc can be male, female, anything in between. It also plays into the style of play LeBlanc has in League. She is deceptive, tricky, impossible to pin down and always fooling you. This right here leads to the idea that whatever you think of LeBlanc is entirely false. Oh, she's the leader? Naw, she's just a magus. Oh, she's really old? Nope, only sixteen. So on and so on.

However, looking at the idea of Immortality...could it be possible? For one thing, LeBlanc lists Elise as a friend on the champion page, implying that they're somehow buddies. Now, this could just be the likeminded aspect of two manipulative leaders, but what if it's more than that? What if LeBlanc is tainted by the magic of the shadow isles and has been alive through means that are quite unholy? Following this train of thought, it'd also explain the power of Sion's resurrection: Shadow Isles magic. Further digging into this, LeBlanc's appearance is hinted at changing quite a bit. As previous hinted that she changed to resemble Jarvan IV, who is to say LeBlanc isn't really thousands of years old and a hideous hag, magic making her the devious and beautiful woman she appears to be?

Perhaps this is exactly what LeBlanc wants? Wild theories and accusations flying around, the truth hinted at but always behind a fog or veil to keep everyone guessing and wondering just who or what she is? If that's the case, amazingly well done. A hat must be tipped to the mistress of manipulation.


With all this said and done, what do you think? Is the Black Rose still strong and alive in Runeterra? Perhaps it's just LeBlanc left after hundreds of years? Maybe there's some counter group they hope to thwart or defeat? Either way, be sure to discuss, keep it civil and remember to vote for next week's topic!

41 Comments

WestTiger5 votes

Well, Swain used to be a Black Rose member, he still wears the club ring according to LeBlanc's League Judgement back in the d : Shippiest League Judgement ever btw

I wonder if it's still canon or not, but that's probably concerning if Swain gets a VU/remake or whatever and they change up his lore, this is probably the least important bit of his backstory all thing's considered. But assuming this is still canon, since LeBlanc's story seems to be fairly stabilized.

  1. Does Swain know Emilia LeBlanc or whoever/whatever personifies the Matron of the Black Rose? There's LeBlanc prior to becoming Matron, and the LeBlanc that completes the rite to become the Matron. Swain could have known either of these two women, or both. Maybe it doesn't matter but it would help gauge a bit of the age of LeBlanc, at least in relation to the coup in Noxus (that should have been a couple of centuries ago but they refer to it like it happened pretty recently by how they refer to DuCouteau. Confusing).

  2. Everything about Swain's past in the Black Rose. What was his rank, what was his duty, why did he leave, was it by choice or was he forced to, but he kept the ring so is he still loyal to the Black Rose, is he a free agent, did he ever communicate to the other Black Rose members besides LeBlanc etc.

  3. Journal of Justice Vol 1 Issue 24 featured a reader's letter to LeBlanc that was specifically made to look fake so we would try to decode it.

The decoded message talks about Vayne, but there's some interesting things to note in the base letter. Notably, LeBlanc replied to this person as though he/she was part of the Black Rose. So we can assume that this is an informant, possibly one of the Black Rose members, who requires a public forum like this to communicate to LeBlanc for some reason. Notice how they talk about Swain: "Surely you Can not sUspect those Rumors of bIg Old Ugly ravenS Making fIne Garden protectors, tHey likely spliT the Soon as the winds raisE there wings highEr"

So what I take from that is that not all the Black Rose is confident that Swain would actually help them, and that the moment he gets enough power, he will leave them for dead - and it's a little telling from the Reborn lead-up, that this situation could actually be happening. Swain's Grand General, short of ruling Runeterra, this was his biggest goal. LeBlanc mentions that they apparently haven't met for "quite some time", presumably after the last JoJ, and Swain simply says that she/the Black Rose "has his favor" and that's as much as she/they will get.

Although it's a written conversation, you lose a lot of nuances. There are ways to say those same lines and Swain won't sound as cold/distant, so who knows. I mean this is a contrast to back when Swain was still rising in the ranks, and during a gala for his appointment to High Command (JoJ Vol1 Issue 11), he had LeBlanc as his date:

Perhaps just as curious as the circumstances of his promotion was Swain's choice of companionship for the evening, which caused quite a stir at the proceedings. On his arm all night was none other than the infamous (and notoriously reclusive) LeBlancSquare.png Emilia LeBlanc, who had not appeared in public for decades.

So is Swain distancing himself now since he doesn't need LeBlanc's help anymore? Again, hard to tell with just a written conversation with no explanation of how lines are being said.

cshakes1 votes

Riot, please hire this person and write a Noxus/Black Rose event with actual lore and a conclusion based on hir comment.

I'd argue that LeBlanc likes to be reclusive, so meeting with the (probably) quite busy Grand General of Noxus isn't as private as she'd like. Given that her League Judgement was very flirty, I'd be inclined to interpret the "you have my favor" bit as being said warmly.

LeBlanc probably prefers to be a power behind the throne, helping whomever she likes ascend the ranks and then influence them until they lose her favor.

WestTiger1 votes

Not gonna lie, I personally ship Swain/LeBlanc as my OTP, but I'm being cautious in how I interpret those lines at the moment. Although I'm a little optimistic since they are releasing Ravenborn LeBlanc, which is Riot pretty much making sure as many people know of the existence of Swain/LeBlanc's relationship as possible. Very handy, I used to have to convince people to read the lore really deeply to figure that out, but now, it's just in their faces!

Also fun-fact, in Swain's League Judgement, the 'head summoner' lady came down personally to oversee his judgement. In the midst of their conversation, he came off as flirting a bit with her, and it seemed to work, plus they seemed to know each other. I'm...just going to assume that Swain's like Sean Connery, he got sexier with age.

And I can't take credit for anything in my comment, it's all about the old lore crew who decided they would really put in the effort and IRL time to build up Swain's side of the story all this time. I mean, think about it, it's really the most important one because Riot uses Noxus/Swain as the instigator in nearly all the major storylines. Heck, Dominion comes about because of how Swain and LeBlanc manipulated the Kalamanda incident!

At this point, Riot can't really retcon or do anything to their lore, because of just how much is built on-top of how strong and cohesive their lore is compared to just about every other faction's. Demacia's story has stagnated, we only see anything new because of them fighting Noxus. Heck, noone even knows if/when J4 is LeBlanc or himself.

With Swain being the main 'villain', and Noxus being the big bad, there's no rush to conclude really anything. I just hope they don't mess it up, and keep the direction laid down by the previous lore crew.

cshakes1 votes

I have large fears of New Lore just having the team retcon everything into nonexistance. :( You seem to have a good grasp of all the lore that has been produced, and from what I remember of your comments on other threads, you have decent ideas, too.

I think that Demacia has space for nonstagnation. Vayne exists, and so does Demacia's dark side. What are the Lightshields/Crownguards/etc ignoring? How much corruption is going on? How just is the place? Lawful Good, Lawful Neutral, Lawful Evil or Lawful Stupid? There are tons of stories to be had everywhere.

Actually, a thread on the "unanswered questions" of each faction would probably be pretty interesting reading.

Xyphios1 votes

Also Vladimir is in the black rose

SecretLore1 votes

its possible that he was just hired by swain,he doesn't have to be a member

WestTiger1 votes

Vlad's also technically a Zaunite, like Singed and Mundo. It's just that Zaunite's tend to work with Noxians a lot so they're effectively the same faction sometimes.

GenoXx3 votes

Vlad is a Noxian outcast

Valaran Nara3 votes

I would like to assume that Vlad could possibly be Thorn.

Why? Well, you mentioned how Elise is friends with LeBlanc right?

Well, here's the thing. Vladimir is both friends with Swain AND Elise. Because of Vlad's lore (and yes, there's always the retcon) he learned how to manipulate blood to kill people, and he practiced this on a random passersby or two. Who is to say that he doesn't work for the Black Rose and has been around for a VERY long time.

It is blood magic. If we go based on "vampiric" magiks and whatnot, it is often used to help defy the process of aging. While it doesn't technically make one immortal (or maybe it can) it is suppose to help one keep a youthful appearance. Maybe Vladimir is older than what most believe. Elise is immortal. LeBlanc is a title to get passed down to keep the appearance of immortality.

Why can't Vlad use his magic for eternal youth?

But, since he's Swain's friend, there's also the possibility that he only helped in the ressurection purely as a favor.

dialMARK4acti0n1 votes

Adding to this, is the fact that I believe Elise is 'Petal'... or was, before she got Shadow Isl-ified.

Valaran Nara1 votes

Adding to this, is the fact that I believe Elise is 'Petal'... or was, before she got Shadow Isl-ified.

Now, let us reference that Death Blossom skin of hers! :D Lol, but yeah. I think that, even if Vlad is not Thorn, he definitely have enough ties with The Black Rose.

I mean, he's friends with Elise who is friends with LeBlanc. It is also possible that he just happens to owe Swain favors and just so happen to work for him. It'd explain why Darius doesn't like Vlad. He's...shifty.

That and Vladimir is blood magic, and Darius's passive causes bleed. Darius doesn't want Vlad playing the role of a Tampon and stopping the fun.

Levyathyn2 votes

Confirmed, really, since the Reborn cinematic featured Vladimir perpetrating the blood sacrifice to bring Sion back. If that isn't a strong tie to the Black Rose, I don't know what is.

GenoXx2 votes

That wasn't from the Black Roses' ordr. It was by swain's, the grand General...

Levyathyn1 votes

But Swain with LeBlanc's clear and willing participation. It's possible Vladimir has no ties at all to the Black Rose, but I don't think it would make sense in context for him to be so deep in the machinations without at least knowing of their existence and willingly participating in their schemes to a degree.

GenoXx1 votes

It does make him part of it,....he was an outcast that was accepted in the Noxus military based on his strength.... So if Swain ask him/order him to do something he's gonna do it regards to the High command...

Levyathyn1 votes

I never read that as military service. In the vein of the old lore, I just assumed that when Vladimir was inducted by the High Command it was for League purposes only. I suppose it's possible, again, this meant general service. I guess it's just how you look at it.

Levyathyn3 votes

I love the Black Rose lore, and in tying with the disappearance of General DuCuteau, I think they may have had something to do with it. But then, I have other theories about that. For another time. However, it has been mentioned in the old lore that LeBlanc is just a face that Evaine took up, a role and a name and an illusionary look that completes her as the head of the Black Rose. And if I remember her entry into the League, and its lore, at all correctly, I remember a crowd of people watching as this happened. This would mean the mantle is like that of the Dread Pirate Roberts, and is passed down to worthy successors, one after the other, who presumably take on a different face each time, though it wouldn't surprise me to learn the LeBlanc face always remains the same.

Katarina is die hard to her duty, but Talon and Cassiopeia had other concerns. Talon was only invested in the General himself, through respect, and this could mean that earning this respect would make the Black Rose his ally and perhaps give him his new home--unless the Rose was indeed involved with General DuCuteau's disappearance. On the other hand, Cass has been shown to be manipulative, loyal, and a bit ambitious, far more than the rest of her more traditional family. Just look at the Shurima event for proof. I could see her being a powerful ally to the Black Rose, at least as far as it would serve her to be so.

Osocoldd2 votes

Them and the ninjas need more story especially with their popularity streaks.

SecretLore2 votes

About Thorn and petal we need to ask us too if they are immortal or simply code names that got passed down?

If they are really the same person,then I'd say that Elise &Vladimir are the most likely candidates. Swain couldn't be it,because he didn't know about Sion.And other noxians are definetly not immortal.

I think that Talon &Cassiopeia are rather unlikely to have a big connection to the black rose,it has been heavily implied that general ducouteau is an enemy of the black rose,but cass and talon are allies of ducouteau(he is cassios father and talons mentor).

GenoXx2 votes

Why does it have to be anyone known? People should stop that. When a unknown character is shown, everyone automatically thinks its someone known. That's never how it is really.

SecretLore1 votes

Thorn and Petal could very well be completely new characters,I was just thinking who they might be IF they are characters we already know.

Overall I'd say Elise is pretty likely though,she is listed as a friend fo leblanc and is immortal,so she has some connection to the black rose and might have been alive(or already immortal) during the time of J1&Sion.

GenoXx1 votes

I would say Elise is likely too, I remember reading something that listed Elise and Swain with the black rose. Though i'm not sure that's canon. But Since she is friends with lb, she was probably a former Black Rose member who was in head of the group who went to the Shadow Isles. And then its told from her perspective. I wish they shed more light about what happen and how she actually got the powers she has. I am also assuming Vilemaw is a sentient being. Maybe even before he became undead. Otherwise I cant see any other way Elise is able too interact with em.

Solideus2 votes

The Black Rose, if Vladimir and Elise are involved, seem to have a lot to do with the pursuit of immortality.

It would also not surprise me if they have a connection to the Magelords (from Aatrox's bio) whom they have some similarities to thematically. Morgana, whom according to the official site now belongs to the Noxus faction, might be moved to the Black Rose family. If Morgana's new bio is connected to the Darkin as well these relations would go full circle; its easy to imagine what this would mean for the Black Rose's history.

Valaran Nara1 votes

The Black Rose, if Vladimir and Elise are involved, seem to have a lot to do with the pursuit of immortality.

It would also not surprise me if they have a connection to the Magelords (from Aatrox's bio) whom they have some similarities to thematically. Morgana, whom according to the official site now belongs to the Noxus faction, might be moved to the Black Rose family. If Morgana's new bio is connected to the Darkin as well these relations would go full circle; its easy to imagine what this would mean for the Black Rose's history.

Sounds cool, but because of another thread with the Darkin Theory, I can't believe Morgana being connected since Darkin are living weapons. (Darkin Blade) refers to Aatrox, the blade. <w<. That, and well, Varus's bow is also Darkin. :O

Solideus1 votes

Both this and that is plausible, but both theories are still conjecture at this point.

dialMARK4acti0n1 votes

I really like your discussions! Keep it up!

Crosses fingers and hopes Darkin is the next week's topic

Rew7111 votes

The more we see of this Black Rose the more we may see a new champion come out of this. Maybe this time, a Rogue?

Flyntloch1 votes

Heh, If Elise or Vlad are not tied to the Black rose then I would love a hitman for the Rose, the Thorn, if you so will.

GenoXx1 votes

In her judement, It was revealed that LeBlanc is just the title of the matron of the black Rose. Evaine was given the staff by the previous LeBlanc. Who, when she gave the staff away, showed that she was really old in fact. So no, LeBlanc is not immortal, The name is.

ModCaptainMårvelous2 votes

Retcons mate. Totally possible everything in her judgement isn't canon anymore.

GenoXx3 votes

I'm sure the theme still stands. Don't just assume LeBlanc is immortal just because u see another character with the same name century later. Or because she and/or her group have went to the shadow isles. As they said before, a lot of stuff in Runeterra still stands. They did not change everything. Only change was the IoW and summoners. I am sure that the tradition the black rose has is still canon...other wise consider the blck rose itself is something new, following your logic. The tradition in which a new person gains the title LeBlanc once the current one gets too old. You can't possibly say that's gone because of lore retcons that have nothing to do with noxus, like Shurima.....

ModCaptainMårvelous2 votes

Again, I'm not assuming LeBlanc is immortal, I'm saying "This is possible, but this is also possible". This isn't me saying this is what I think is right, I'm saying what could be possible. And both? Totally possible.

GenoXx1 votes

Again...she is and can possibly not be immortal....stop making it like u want.... Even Darkwill thought he was immortal....meh

ModCaptainMårvelous2 votes

Well, foremost, that entire sentence is fucked up.

Secondly, I'm not "making it like I want it". What I am proposing is an alternative and an idea. If anything, your persistent refuting of my idea is more along the lines of shutting out any other possibility as opposed to me suggesting something.

This is a theory, nothing more. You don't have to agree with me, but you can't keep locking it out because you think it doesn't stand.

GenoXx1 votes

The only about theories, I like to present all facts, and deduce them to simplicity. So at the same time, I am theorizing. From the way I read what u have, it did not seem like you were theorizing and came to a solid conclusion. I only stated what was already given about LB and your answer was " Retcon." Even though LB was never retconned...

Moonshade1 votes

LeBlanc is a magical illusion that is projected over the body of whomever holds the title at the time, the illusion has a constant appearance so that the leader of the rose appears as though she lives forever, and the magic that allows this resides within the hairpiece of the base Leblanc skin (read the League Judgement for LeBlanc found on the wiki, the judgement also implies that some of the knowledge from previous LeBlancs is retained in the broach on her head, allowing them to essentially have hundreds of lifetimes to plan for any and every eventuality). As for whom Thorn and Petal are, I believe that the DeCourteau sisters are very likely to be Thorn (Katarina) and Petal was likely Cassiopea prior to her transformation, there is likely a replacement now to hold the position. I also believe that general DeCourteau was once a Thorn (maybe still is) for the Rose as at the end of LeBlanc's league judgement he comes to visit her and though she reacts with hostility, Swain does not implying he may have turned him (one last act as a Petal before resigning) I also get hints from the Judgement that Swain was once a petal prior to his military coup and now he works with the Rose to hold his position.

GenoXx1 votes

Kata and Cassie aren't in the black rose, those are just two random characters.....sigh

cshakes1 votes

According to her League Judgement, LeBlanc is a title. The physical appearance is caused by the brooch in her hair, and the brooch is worn by the Matron of the Black Rose.

Personally, I think that Thorn and Petal are probably from the era of the previous LeBlanc. Then again, we don't know how old our Evaine really is. In her 40s, perhaps? (Having ascended to LeBlanc in her 20s due to her talents, in my headcanon.)

As for the Elise/LeBlanc tie, well, obviously they might have befriended each other in the Institute. Perhaps Elise is a member of the Black Rose, feeding people to Vilemaw to strengthen it so the Black Rose can use it in their plots? Or a member who's bringing sacrifices to Vilemaw as a side project? ("Spider powers in exchange for bringing in sacrifices? Sure!")

WestTiger1 votes

FYI, just a little thing I remembered with my memory of obscure LoL trivia.

Did you know that Annie's parents were ex-Noxian, and leaders of the Grey Order - a group comprised of magic users who possibly had ties to the old Noxian aristocracy? They then left Noxus in a mass exodus as the military coup was happening and I'm guessing they would have been slaughtered. They escaped, and had Annie out there in their warlock and witches commune.

Black Rose, Grey Order, we're just missing the 'White' now...

(although it's highly likely Annie's backstory is just going to remove that bit, it's really not all that important and the Grey Order is never mentioned anywhere else)

PokladnicaZla1 votes

Another great discussion.

About the pole:Wasnt Katas and Cass father killed?

Taul Temps1 votes

GODDAMNIT! Where is the discussion about the lunari? I want it so bad! A freaking genocide by the solari? Were they cooperating before it happenned? Did the solari betray the lunari? I wanna see a discussion!

More from Story, Art, & Sound

More by CaptainMårvelous