Commenting here because I don't have access to the PBE. Hopefully Riot will actually listen to the people saying "pls no".
I have so many problems with the new Star Guardian skins, i'm going to go one by one through all of the champions. My main feelings are that Anime is popular, therefore anime = money, therefore more anime to please the weeb fans.
Ahri doesn't need a VO, her voice would match the skin perfectly fine, it's compeltely unecessary and could be used much better on other champions coughSyndracough. Feels like Riot has just done this because Ahri is the most popular out of the 5. Additionally, Ahri already has a school based skin. Seriously Riot? Why wouldn't you expand her selection instead of giving her 2 skins which are pretty much the same.
On a personal note her voice annoys the hell out of me, and there isn't enough Kiki (her little pet thing).
Syndra, omg why? Just why? There are so many problems with this skin.
- Thematically, Syndra is dark and powerful. SG Syndra doesn't reflect this well. Both in terms of the skin and the VFX. Everything feels so soft, it's such an odd oxymoron of good & evil, it just breaks my brain to look at. The visual effects are so poofy and soft, other skins do a better job of displaying her control and force. This is what Syndra mains love about her, this skin has completely removed that.
As others have said, Dark Star Syndra would be far more fitting. Regardless of that there are many more concepts that work so well with her personality, this is the last one I would have considered.
1.5 Leading on from this, her voice doesn't match the skin at all. If you had to give one VO in this set, Syndra NEEDED it. Everyone has spoken about this being an issue, I doubt I need to go into much detail. It feels like whoever designed the skin, didn't consider her personality or voice at all. The skin was made to fit the SG set, not to fit Syndra.
- Whilst her orbs are adorable and I love the concept, they don't fit in. They feel more arcade based. The orbs are the only redeeming feature about the skin, but unfortunately they don't do enough to make me want to buy it.
- Colour scheme hurts my eyes. It must have been a challenge to get a dark champion to fit in with such a cute theme. One almost wants to believe that Riot would have stopped and thought "Maybe this just won't work".
- Okay, so here I want to talk about something which affects the other champs in the selection (Miss Fortune). There are champions like Taliyah and Tristana who could have had a SG skin for 1350, simply because their voices wouldn't need to be changed. They are so upbeat and happy, it would be easy to make them all colourful and sparkly. Syndra is the worst case, but I feel like Miss Fortune also has this issue.
MF is quite underwhelming. I love her little followers and how they join in with the ultimate. Other than that, she just looks like a lady with pistols. It doesn't feel like Miss Fortune. I don't really know why she has this skin, but I guess it's better than Syndra.
It hurts my eyes. There is so much detail and over-saturation that I can't look at it. Spell effects are nice, but he's so u g l y.
Best one, I love it. Matches her personality, looks beautiful and original. I would say that her pet could be more involved with her movement. But I'm definitely buying this one.
If it wasn't obvious, i'm a big fan of Syndra. Overall, i'm very disappointed with these skins. I think a lot of people are, and I hope Riot reconsiders many things about these skins.