My list with some detailed explanation:
Caitlyn's kit is fine, albeit there's some changes I'd PERSONALLY make (but that's my feel). As she is, her kit works fine and she's got a nice niche. However, she could use some love as her model is a Season 1 disasterpiece and as the first true "Piltover" champion, she's what happens when you fill a shotgun with steampunk aesthetics and fire indiscriminately.
Not much to say about this one. Iconic kit. Good champ and there's been plenty of cinematics and appearances of the steam golem that show you can easily give his design a razor-sheen polish to make him look spiffy.
Another workable kit, Ashe was also one of the first Fridgelord champs. Her design might need some more fine tuning like giving her some clothes that better fit her regal title as an "avatar of avarosa" but I wouldn't want to stray too far in the fear of ruining something a lot of people earnestly love about the character. Plus miniskirt. Maybe axe that.
While Jarvan's design is killer and it aged pretty decently, I also think he's got some problems. Namely the black armor/aesthetics that don't really fit Demacia's theme of white/blue/gold that they have. Not a huge change I'd make to ol' J4 but some color correction and maybe some cool stuff to better fit his character like thicker armor.
Untouchable (btw) because of his rabid fanbase, I do think Jax could use some touchups to look less like a walking eggplant and more like a timeless warrior from a lost nation. Hell, you could just take his current design and add some tattered/raggedness to it and he'd be an S-tier design. All Jax really needs is a five dollar coupon to a clothing store.
Noc's kit has aged pretty well and he sees play (which is good!) but his visuals have aged like Milk and the angry inkblot could use some love. He's also in the unique spot where Noc's appearance leads to him being a very open-ended idea of a character. I'd like for Riot to home in on one thing and really make him emphasize that.
The last rework (
) was shit. Give her a new one guys.