I was very pleased to see Jaredan provide this kind of concrete, useful prompt. We know that Warwick and Singed are slated for more lore-work, and we've been given enough notice to have a real discussion about them that will hopefully inform that new lore. Thanks, Jarebear!
I've already spent too much time on Boards today, but I did want to make one substantive comment about Warwick.
This dude has already had one huge rewrite. Going off of memory:
In the first (?) version of his lore, Soraka sacrificed her divinity to transform a murderous bioweapons engineer into a mid-tier jungler, apparently being so far removed from the mortal realm that it seemed to her a fitting "curse" to make a murderer into a murderous werewolf with super-strength and preternatural senses.
Not going to lie: this was pretty awkward. I sort of wonder how that went down in-universe.
It's high time that merchant of death was brought to justice.
I've been asking you to let me bring him in for months. You got your panties in a twist about jurisdiction or something.
He's gone too far this time. When he started doing tests on Piltovian prisoners of war, he committed a crime against Piltover.
(dramatically lock-and-loads her rifle) I say we arrange an extradition.
(smacks fist into palm) Hell yeah.
There is no need. He has already been punished by a higher law than your own.
I have a feeling you aren't talking about a League tribunal.
Though I can never again look to the stars without shame, and they shall forevermore answer my orisons with cries of accusation, by their power I have called a curse down upon him.
He's dead?
Oh, no, I turned him into a fearsome beast with the strength of ten men and claws that can rend steel.
How does that help? In what possible way does that help? He was already a war criminal; now he's a war criminal who's also a werewolf?
Freaking Ionians, man. They're worse than Demacia. At least when Demacia's done, the bad guys are dead. Seriously, lady, what kinda divine retribution is that? You gave him FREAKING SUPERPOWERS. He is now OFFICIALLY a SUPERVILLAIN!
T_T
Yeah, you BETTER cry. Come on, 'raka. What's next? Hey, I bet Darius could use some FIRE BREATH.
Don't give her any ideas.
Well, I suppose it's time to invest in some silver bullets.
(tumbles into view)
I ANSWER THE CALL.
(sighs) Greeeeeeaaaat.
Then, we got new lore in which Warwick punked Soraka, and then downed a half-finished Singed potion. He now needs her heart to stop from going full-wolf, and allow him to stay at a comfortable "some wolf" level of wolfosity. It's better than the old lore in some ways, worse in others. I like the element of trickery. I question the viability of a lore-path that requires him to kill another major character, but hey, maybe he'll find some other celestial to eat.
But this post isn't about the nuances of his lore, old or new. It's about you, Riot.
Riot, I want you to take your Warwick retcon credit card. Go get it. And a pair of scissors. Now I want you to cut it up. I know it's hard. We believe in you. Remember what we talked about in group last week.
Seriously, though. I'm not saying I adore his new lore, but it's not inherently awful, either. You can write a good story around it. Fantastic stories have been written around derpier story outlines. You're going to give Warwick an additional personality disorder if you retcon him again. You've already had one bite at the apple. You've made your bed, and now you need to sleep in it. See how I picked one metaphor, then switched to another? It's like that. I'm going to be responsible and resist the urge to switch to yet another metaphor. You need to sleep in the bed you made because you're not the only one sleeping in it. The community is in there with you, and if you remake the bed, you'll wake them up. (Uhhhh. This is kind of going in an awkward direction. I shall persevere.) Even if the fitted sheet is on the wrong way, you don't rouse the other person from their dreams to remake the bed at 4 in the morning. What if they're dreaming about an awesome lightsaber duel? No. The bed's made.
So what I'm saying is, whatever you do with Warwick, focus on building upon his latest story, rather than retconning him yet again.