Couldn't Star Guardian Taliyah have worked?

GenoXx·8/10/2017, 9:03:51 PM·93 votes·4,137 views

Just a question in regarding candidates for the Star Guardian line

102 Comments

Jeddy0178/10/2017, 9:34:00 PM45 votes

>Teenage girl >Use magic

I have been saying this since she was released when the only SG skin was Lux's. Taliyah is a perfect fit for this skinline. No one can tell me otherwise.

ChompyWulf8/10/2017, 10:17:10 PM32 votes

I'm a simple man. I see a suggestion for a different Star Guardian than the ones released, I upvote.

Sexy Jack Rabbit8/10/2017, 11:27:12 PM17 votes

I guess "THROW ANOTHER ROCK" doesn't work well if you're throwing stars...

Almighty8/11/2017, 3:15:57 AM16 votes

But what were the particles going to be? What was the wall going to be made out of?

Star Guardians rely on arcane energy magic, not physical telekinetic magic like Taliyah does. So, apart from a cute outfit, i don't see how else Taliyah would be a Star Guardian.

Bloodstone Taliyah. Now THAT is something i want to see.

Almighty.

Chembaron Yamada8/10/2017, 9:50:43 PM12 votes

Yes, of course it would have worked. Just like alot of other champions.

But they preferred to get the hyper popular champions out of the way first.... Well, there is still next year, right? X__X

archerno18/10/2017, 9:05:47 PM8 votes

Nah. She has ugly face. Only cute grills get to be Star Guardians

Skorch8/11/2017, 12:43:25 AM6 votes

Honestly. I feel like Riot has a plan for Taliyah.

She fits into so many archetypes but hasnt got a skin. Star Guardian couldve worked. Everyone thought that Illaoi AND Taliyah would get Pool Party and we didnt even get PP this year.

I dont know its honestly a little weird.

ModAcademy Kayn8/11/2017, 3:07:48 AM6 votes

I think the hard part is making her visuals work to feel Star Magicky. Her Q is hard in itself, her W has a few possibilities. I think it could work, but it'd be hard.