Skip to content

Should Riot create a "ally unit killing" ability in the future?

Hozimina··4 votes·815 views
Ostanes Flamel - The Demacian Scientist

I have always found that the most effective way to beat an opponent is to ensure that they don't get any CS while in the lane, however even if one does manage to out push their opponent out of lane and under the turret their opponent can still get farm and gold to make their gameplay so much more efficient. I have always been a bit of a hater of Nasus and have always though, "why can't I kill my own minions to make sure he can't have them?" This has lead me to wonder if riot should create a champion with the ability to kill their own minions and steal their enemies CS. I know that this may be a long ways away from coming to life but I just can't help but wish and wonder if this should come to life. If anyone else would like to see this please comment and vote. If not, all the same. And if you wish to see a champion concept that already has this as a build look at my concept in the link provided.

Thank you for taking the time to look and comment Sincerely, Hozimina

14 Comments

DrCyanide3 votes

Absolutely not. If you want the ability to kill ally units to deny them from the enemy, go play Dota.

TheLittlestLulu3 votes

They already removed this from old, old Gangplank. They sure as hell aren't bringing it back.

Marshbouy2 votes

No. They removed old GPs ability to do that because it is considered toxic.

The LDC2 votes

That already exists its called syndras w or e what ever the one grabs the winion bc I remember countless times when syndra's would pick siege minions and throw them at low allies and get them killed.Syndra

zrWQMdGHtY1 votes

Havent you played Kalista or Anivia? You basically can kill your allies and laugh at them while doing it XD

CobaltTheMadMage1 votes

I actually had a champ whose Q could kill allied mobs, but it did so by giving them a temporary attack speed and damage buff at the end of which they would explode, dealing damage in a small radius and not giving the enemy gold or XP.

Onimarus1 votes

I always was in favor of denying in MOBAs. However, it was removed in League because baddies couldn't handle the very simple mechanic and, thus, whined so loud Riot just decided to remove it entirely. It'd be pretty difficult to implement now due to how it's balanced, but when they removed GP's ability it was literally due to little babbies pooping their pants that they couldn't miss a CS.

Let that sink in for a minute because it's pretty sad.

CobaltTheMadMage1 votes

But then you'd have those two laners who spent the whole early-game denying each other at the cost of farming so then they're both under-leveled compared to the rest of their respective teams.

Onimarus1 votes

{quoted}

But then you'd have those two laners who spent the whole early-game denying each other at the cost of farming so then they're both under-leveled compared to the rest of their respective teams.

This speculation only reaffirms the point that League players cannot handle such a simple mechanic. It's literally beyond them.

CobaltTheMadMage2 votes

Actually I've only recently begun playing League. I was talking from the perspective of one with an interest in game design.

That said, I suppose the concept is technically valid as DotA clearly made good use of the mechanic, but then on the flipside LoL demonstrates that such a mechanic isn't quite a necessity to gameplay, and may in fact have some drawbacks. No one perspective is more valid than the other, and neither game is superior or inferior for its choice in design nor obligated to be like the other for any reason. If you don't like LoL because it's not DotA, your time is better spent playing DotA and getting what you want than playing LoL and constantly complaining.

That said, with the ability to kill allied creeps not being a core mechanic of the game, granting such an ability to a single champion as an exclusive feature would have some serious balance considerations. As mentioned, that champion would have an unprecedented ability to deny their lane opponent the ability to farm precious gold or XP in addition to traditional lane harassment, which could let a skilled player create a greater level gap between themselves and their enemy laner than most other champions could under optimal conditions.

Furthermore, the champion in question would likely not get any gold or XP for kills made against their own units, which would then break down players of this champion into distinct categories based on how well they make use of friendly-fire:

  • those who can skillfully juggle between farming for themselves and denying their opponent the same get the aforementioned unprecedented level gap if they can also avoid feeding and especially if they themselves get fed.

  • Those who focus too much on denying enemy farm at the cost of their own farm just create the previously-mentioned mutual level stagnation, which could set one or both of them behind the rest of their team in terms of power level and create some unpleasant balance issues late-game.

  • Those who are bad at the friendly-fire thing might end up accidentally helping their laner gain last-hits and consequently level and gold, which would essentially amount to a form of feeding and earn the ire of their teammates.

  • Finally, those who ignore the friendly-fire mechanic altogether just end up not making the most of their champion's unique strengths, the consequences of which vary depending on said champion's other stats and abilities and consequently go beyond the scope of this hypothetical situation. Basically though it amounts to them playing a normal League champ and all that implies.

And as an additional note, if we were to say add the friendly-fire thing globally to all champs, well, as a Vel'Koz main I can say I would probably end up killing just as many of my own minions on accident as I do my enemy's on purpose, which yeah does sorta deny them farm but also denies me valuable cover and turret push ability. So in a sense it would probably end up doing more harm than good depending on what sort of champion you've chosen.

TL;DR:

-LoL is not obligated to be like DotA -LoL has been built so long around the concept of absence of friendly-fire that adding it in now might not go so well -Friendly-firing allied minions for farm deny may add an additional layer of high-risk high-reward strategy that could turn the tables unfairly to one side or the other if limited only to a single champion -Yes, not every League player will be able to make proper use of this mechanic. And that's exactly the problem. -No, League players aren't inherently worse than DotA players nor is League inherently inferior to DotA simply because they're not the same. -If you love DotA and/or hate League that much, go back to playing the game you love and leave us League players alone. -I realize there's a possibility you're going to be 'that guy' and skip all of this, even this last part, and just shoot back some smug elitist string of insults demeaning me for spending so much time and text space defending a game like League or presumptuously ignore my arguments and insult my intelligence with the help of ad hominems. For the sake of common human decency, please, PLEASE do not be that guy.

Onimarus1 votes

TL;DR:

-LoL is not obligated to be like DotA -LoL has been built so long around the concept of absence of friendly-fire that adding it in now might not go so well -Friendly-firing allied minions for farm deny may add an additional layer of high-risk high-reward strategy that could turn the tables unfairly to one side or the other if limited only to a single champion -Yes, not every League player will be able to make proper use of this mechanic. And that's exactly the problem. -No, League players aren't inherently worse than DotA players nor is League inherently inferior to DotA simply because they're not the same. -If you love DotA and/or hate League that much, go back to playing the game you love and leave us League players alone. -I realize there's a possibility you're going to be 'that guy' and skip all of this, even this last part, and just shoot back some smug elitist string of insults demeaning me for spending so much time and text space defending a game like League or presumptuously ignore my arguments and insult my intelligence with the help of ad hominems. For the sake of common human decency, please, PLEASE do not be that guy.

Obvi. I didn't even mention Dota. I said that in a previous post already. They shouldn't be playing with only one champion in League in the first place. Because not everybody can handle it, nobody will get it? That's terrible logic. The "issue" was mainly that only one champion specifically in League was capable of denying, and because of bad rep from that one champion, denying as a whole is just looked at negatively, with support coming from those who played other mobas who had denying (and failing to do so, inevitably deeming the entire mechanic as "useless" or "toxic"). I literally never said either those things. You're just spouting random fanboyish lines to somebody who is critiquing the horrible mishandling of a decent mechanic.

I skipped the entire thing, but that's because it's literally all just fanboyish nonsense spawned from the misconception that I love Dota and hate League. Because of that, I'll just also go the full-monty and live up to your projections.

Not everything is black and white like you seem to believe, and if you enjoy League you should also know it's far from being even remotely perfect. Why you're getting so angry over the truth is beyond me.

tl;dr denying is an okay mechanic and just because player skill in League is terrible doesn't make the mechanic terrible. Also you're a weirdly sensitive fanboy who seemingly reads too much into text on a containment board.

CobaltTheMadMage2 votes

Well, at least you lived up to the presumption part in ignoring the preface that I've only recently gotten into this game and was talking from an interest in game design perspective (bachelor's in software engineering, for that matter). You also made the assumption that I was talking in black and white when I even addressed the pros and cons of the idea.

And I think you already addressed the issue yourself and proved one of my major points: we already tried having only one champion with this ability, and people didn't like the discrepancy it created. It's not a bad idea at all, in fact somewhat hypocritically I do have a champ concept who had a farm-deny mechanic like this, though it was more like Syndra in that he had an ability that did its own thing but could deal more damage if an allied Minion got involved and would likely die in the process.

...Wait a second, we do have a friendly-fire farm-denial champ! Syndra's kinesis power can throw allied minions into enemies and kill them so they can't! All along we've been making ourselves look like ***holes over what is essentially a moot point, though I guess that then begs the question of what made Gangplank's version unacceptable while Syndra's still worked, and what we could learn from either when designing another such champion.

Tamur1 votes

I can see the abuse much like a Friendly Fire Mode only you can't do anything back. But the best way to deny CS is to remove the enemy from lane as best you can.

CobaltTheMadMage1 votes

And/or play champs like Azir or Yorick, whose powers spawn allied mobs that attack enemies and drive them away from your minions.

More from Concepts & Creations

More by Hozimina