Skip to content

First Amendment rights don't protect you from privately owned companies.

Lost R··84 votes·21,511 views

Riot is a privately owned company. It's not part of the government.

So if you thought that would protect you when you decided to parrot whatever racist shit you heard a streamer say in the in-game chat or on these forums, you're dead wrong.

Also let this be a reminder to stay in school and don't flake on your studies.

100 Comments

ModCaliCoastReplay18 votes

A few notes on this, since First Amendment/free speech topics seem to be trending on the Boards lately:

First off, I must remind everyone that the Boards program is not Riot, mods/Heralds/etc. are not Rioters, and this post is not in any way an official legal notice from Riot nor does it apply to in-game issues as we only moderate the Boards.


Text of the First Amendment to the U.S. Constitution

Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances.


The First Amendment is an extremely important principle which protects American citizens from legislation (and, implicitly, prosecution) by the United States Congress over their freedom of speech. It is crucial in preserving Americans' right to open, honest public debate in civic and public forums.

However, even under the First, certain kinds of speech are not protected - generally speaking, this includes violent threats, extreme pornography, and speech designed to violently or maliciously disturb the peace - the classic example of this third category being shouting "fire!" in a crowded theater.

The First also does not remove the right of private entities to determine rules within their own property which create a safe and healthy environment, including rules governing speech. And unless a state or city has superseding laws itself, all powers not expressly given to the government are reserved to the people via the Tenth Amendment.


TL:DR: The Boards program is not Congress.

We absolutely do have the right and power to moderate or censor speech which creates an unsafe environment for our players, and we will continue to do so.

We absolutely attempt to allow as much free speech and self-expression as possible, but ensuring the safety of our players comes first.

ModCaliCoastReplay2 votes

I bring these things up mostly because, while most of what the original post says is well-intentioned, our intent as a program is not to be one where our users need to be "protected" from us - it's supposed to be one where we help to protect the community.

We are human and imperfect, so we don't always succeed perfectly, but overall this is why we moderate what we moderate. And when community members feel we're failing in that duty, they have the right to tell us on Discuss The Boards or our Discord channel.


I also want to note as one final point that League is an international game. Whether or not the U.S. Constitution even applies at all to players playing a game outside of the States or to our Boards programs in other countries is very dubious. We do try to promote freedom of speech and self-expression on the NA Boards, but overall, assuming an American viewpoint on everything regarding this game is not really a good idea as League is played all over the world.

Skeleton Matrix2 votes

so u do this for free? :O

XxXGwanXxX3 votes

"public forums." "within their own property"

So what is facebook in all this ? Is it a private property or a public forum ? What about twitter ? You know, the platform that was LEGALLY determined to be PUBLIC, so much so that the PRESIDENT cannot block people from his account anymore.

It could be argued it's both, What happens now ? Just because the laws are obsolete and behind the times doesn't make censorship right. What do you consider a "public forum" ? How are boards not a "public forum" ? It's free and anyone can join with basically no effort, how is this not a "public forum?

Do you see where I am going with this ?

"all powers not expressly given to the government are reserved to the people via the Tenth Amendment." And you don't see how that could be a problem when it comes to the monopoly on public forums and platforms like facebook and twitter ?

These things are basically modern Agoras, why are they not considered public forums ?

I know the answer is "that's the law" so we come back to my first point. "Just because the laws are obsolete and behind the times doesn't make censorship right. "

GatekeeperTDS7 votes

A restaurant is open to the public, but it's private property.

A Walmart is open to the public, but it's private property.

This forum is open to the public, but it's private property.

ModCaliCoastReplay5 votes

How are boards not a "public forum" ? It's free and anyone can join with basically no effort, how is this not a "public forum?

You've touched on a good point:

This is, despite being a forum intended for the public, properly not a public forum in the legal sense. It's a discussion taking place on private servers, which legally makes it a private forum.

There are not a lot of genuine public forums in the legal sense on the Internet - all servers have to be hosted, after all. Someone usually owns them. When it is the government, it is generally an actually public forum and has a higher level of First Amendment protections. However, even there, there are lines and limits - no threats, no illegal pornography, and no shouting "Fire!" in a crowded theater (so to speak).

And you don't see how that could be a problem when it comes to the monopoly on public forums and platforms like facebook and twitter ?

How much power do you all think we have? We aren't Facebook or Twitter. Therefore, we can't comment on Facebook or Twitter policies.

Once again - we aren't even Rioters. We can only comment on the Boards program. We cannot be a recourse for anger over society's many larger conflicts between free speech and civic order. We can only do the best we can, here.

I know the answer is "that's the law" so we come back to my first point. "Just because the laws are obsolete and behind the times doesn't make censorship right. "

I understand your perspective - but just because racial slurs, violent threats, and other forms of cyberbullying are free speech does not make them right either. And if we make the decision to allow them, we feel strongly that the Boards become a worse place to be, as well as genuinely dangerous.

There is always a legal line somewhere between freedom of speech and disturbing the peace, even in the most speech-protected societies. Most people want their speech to be protected, no matter what it is - and it's a fine thing in any society to allow as much speech to be protected as possible - but people want to be able to go into a room full of strangers and hurl slurs and threats at them, too. And as much as the person existing in that anger wants that anger to be validated and that speech to be protected, it generally just isn't - because it threatens the well-being of other people.

When speech here crosses the line into violence or threats, or prejudicial hatred of other people over race, gender, or other things beyond their control, or anything else that badly violates our Universal Rules, we are going to continue to moderate it.


(Also, please don't mistake my statements here as a moderator for my personal views on the First Amendment outside of this program. You might be surprised at how fervent an advocate I am personally on free speech issues when it's outside of my work here.)

XxXGwanXxX3 votes

"I understand your perspective - but just because racial slurs, violent threats, and other forms of cyberbullying are free speech does not make them right either."

That is fair but who decides what is a real threat or cyberbullying or racism ? What happens when it's just a joke that was taken out of context ? What about the european player that was banned for saying "kys" when it is actually a word meaning "kiss" in his language ? I am not advocating that I should be able to say I am gonna find and kill someone, this is litteraly illegal as it should be. I'm just saying that depending on who has the power, the "unnaceptable" behavior isn't actually that bad.

Would you consider saying "my ngga you sooo gud" to be racism ? Even when said by a black person to one of his friend ? My point is that sometimes people will be offended for others even tho they shouldn't be.

Ice Weasel X4 votes

{quoted}

Would you consider saying "my ngga you sooo gud" to be racism ? Even when said by a black person to one of his friend ? My point is that sometimes people will be offended for others even tho they shouldn't be.

What if the observer is also black and refuses to accept the -ga version of the word because he has personally been called that as an insult? Not all black people consider it a viable distinction. Just because you and your friend are fine with certain colorful language directed at each other doesn't mean others are offended for you. They may be offended because of personal experiences, and telling them they shouldn't be isn't your call.

My cousins and I call each other racially insensitive things in private. We absolutely will not do this in front of random Asians. It would be completely reasonable for them to be pissed at us.

Solution: don't say things to your friends in team/all chat that you know some people find offensive. Keep it to /msg or voice chat.

ModCaliCoastReplay2 votes

These are all good points, people. There are no easy answers.

They relate to a problem as old as humanity, that the Romans called "Quis custodiet ipsos custodes?" - "Who watches these watchmen?"

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quis_custodiet_ipsos_custodes%3F

Ultimately, one reaches a point where there is no further chain of command and the watchmen are policed only by themselves.

That's not a good way to run any railroad - but it's also inextricable from the problem. There is no one perfect entity up the chain that can ever come down and fix everything. It's all run by imperfect authorities in the end, because humans are not perfect.

That is fair but who decides what is a real threat or cyberbullying or racism ?

Right now, we do - at least on the Boards. And where we don't (in-game issues and/or serious escalated cases), Riot does. And we are all human beings, and not perfect. I hate to keep saying that, but it's true.

A big part of our moderator training has to do with scanning context - we really do try to separate joking around from genuine hostile intent. Hostile intent is one of the biggest things that will get any post taken down, no matter what the actual issue is about.

Solution: don't say things to your friends in team/all chat that you know some people find offensive. Keep it to /msg or voice chat.

This is actually really good advice - see my points about context above.

"Know your audience" is one of the first things taught in any public speaking class.


There is no perfect answer to these problems.

But there are imperfect answers, and they start with more engagement between users and moderators and building more community so that the Boards feel less like a free-for-all and more like a place where people come to be kind, have fun, help support each other, and promote a teaching environment about the game.

Discuss the Boards is always a great place to make suggestions on ways you think the current process is broken and how those problems can be fixed.

Ph03n1xb1rd1 votes

"an unsafe environment for our players" - How can an online forum be unsafe? I've never seen anyone slipping on a "kys" and breaking his neck.

"ensuring the safety of our players comes first" - Safety from what? Safety from reading words? :O

I mean, ofc, you can censor, delete, ban and just simply SJW bash everything to hell if you feel so, since you are a mod. But should you really do it?

PS.: Oh fck, i just realized i'm grave digging, sorry. But still interested in the answers tho ;)

Lost R2 votes

You know the Doxxing and Swatting fad, where you find a person's address and then call the cops on them? Several people I know have had that happen to them over the years. One person lost his job and had some vigilantes hunt him down and actually go to his house, another had Scotland Yard come and arrest him (he's been acquitted of the charges after a two year bullshit investigation and at least one attempt by the prosecutor to fabricate evidence), and I personally had someone snap and go all Annie Wilkes on me and attempted to do things that I am not allowed to talk about here.

There's a lot more dangerous things than petty microaggressions, and all that aside, Riot isn't forced to tolerate someone who wants to be a Lord of the Shits. This isn't 8chan or the Shadbase Discord; Hell, even those places have (had, for 8chan) their own sets of rules in the name of safety (physical and especially legal).

And if you think all of that is bullshit, then go open up your own board/forum, get at least 100K people into it, enforce no rules whatsoever, and see how long you last.

Zlera10 votes

I made a post similar to this about a month back. I dont understand why people dont realize this.

Modi6 votes

{quoted}

I made a post similar to this about a month back. I dont understand why people dont realize this.

Most people read "Free Speech" and nothing more.

4th3t0s3 votes

{quoted}

Most people read "Free Speech" and nothing more.

And conflate it with "freedom from consequence"

Zero Skill Tank4 votes

For someone without interest in law, I can imagine it is counterintuitive that a private company can do something to you that a government can't.

Normally it is the other way around, i.e. a private company isn't allowed to steal some money from you for every transaction you make.

GatekeeperTDS7 votes

that a private company can do something to you that a government can't

Riot cannot infringe on your right to free speech as provided by the US Constitution or the laws of your own country, therefore Riot can't do anything to you outside of their services. Riot can prohibit you from using their service or forums if you don't adhere to their rules, which are legal.

a private company isn't allowed to steal some money

This is covered by different laws that regulate commerce. No, private companies aren't allowed to steal from you or defraud you, those are crimes. What private companies ARE allowed to do is set the terms of using their service, just as you are allowed to set rules in your own home as long as those rules are not illegal in the sense that they conform with existing laws.

You, for example, cannot prohibit someone from leaving your home at any point they choose. This would be false imprisonment or kidnapping. You absolutely could prohibit the wearing of green socks on your property, and anyone who wishes to enter has to abide by the rules or piss off. The same goes for Riot's games and forums.

TL;DR - NO SHIRT, NO SHOES, NO SERVICE

AbiwonKenabi3 votes

Private companies have a say over you to an extent. Riot isn't going to police what you say around the internet or what you do outside of League, they can't. If you work for them perhaps, you can say whatever you want still but that doesn't mean its without consequences.

Its like private property. You can say whatever you want and do whatever you want (for the most part) on your own private property, but if you're on someone else's, they can ask you to leave for whatever reason they want. League is basically Riot's "private property".

I hope people strive to understand the nuance. Its not violating First Amendment rights to restrict speech in some instances. The classic example: you have a freedom of speech, meaning you can speak your mind and say whatever you want without the government punishing you...but you can't yell "Fire!" in a crowded theatre. This doesn't mean we live in a totalitarian state, it just means there are of course going to be some rules as there are with anything else.

Oleandervine3 votes

Private companies can do TONS OF THINGS that the government can't do, that's an extremely common thing. For instance, if you walk through the park, and someone comes up to you and shows you a printout of their private parts, you could call the police and have them arrested. But if you go into a shop called Sensual Delights and call the police because the shopkeeper is showing you items that have pictures of private parts on them, they'd laugh you out of the store. This kind of duality exists everywhere, from fetish clubs, clubs that only allow certain people to join, restaurants that give you discounts based on things like your age, etc. etc - things which wouldn't be permissible under federal laws in government sponsored establishments, but are allowed for privately owned establishments.

Arcade Lulu8 votes

I'll never understand why people don't understand this

YTmustangcody2 votes

Because private company's in the U.S. have to follow the laws of the Constitution but they can deny rights in game.

Riot is a privately owned company. It's not part of the government.

Really doesn't mean anything, it only matters if you accept their tos to play the game which you forfeit your rights.

Arcade Lulu2 votes

{quoted}

Because private company's in the U.S. have to follow the laws of the Constitution but they can deny rights in game.

Riot is a privately owned company. It's not part of the government.

Really doesn't mean anything, it only matters if you accept their tos to play the game which you forfeit your rights.

Huh Did you even read my comment? I said that i don't understand WHY OTHER people don't understand it I understand it perfectly fine, even thought i've never lived in na

Lost R3 votes

Because the educational standards in the US are the worst in the developed world, we have a dropout rate of over 30%, we have a culture that says you pass so long as you score at least a D-, and then teachers are encouraged to go out of their way to avoid giving students F's, the school curriculum is designed around teaching students how to maximize their SAT scores and pass tests at the cost of critical thinking, effectively teaching them 2+2=4 but neglecting to teach them how to count, and the SAT scores determine how much funding schools get, forcing them to fight each other over the meager scraps.

And on top of that, League players dump-stated everything in order to get better at Yasuo and mob mentality is so inset here that even the minions could best them in a battle of wits.

AlienPrimate1 votes

Test scores have absolutely nothing to do with school funding in my state. The only thing determining a school's funding is the taxes payed by the people living in the school's district. This means a poor district will have less funding than a wealthy district. This also means that everyone pays for public schooling equally whether they use it or not. Someone paying for their children to go to a private school is also paying for the public school in the area.

General Esdeath 5 votes

Whatever, I'm calling my lawyer and the government on this fucking sjw company, fucking dictator mods and rioters not letting me practice my free speech smh

/s because it's the boards

JedenVojak4 votes

What kind of game do you want to play?

One where one misstep or one joke creates one report that gets you banned?

Or one where people can joke and mess around and say whatever they want, and just have fun?

Jhins Girlfriend10 votes

{quoted}

What kind of game do you want to play?

One where one misstep or one joke creates one report that gets you banned?

Or one where people can joke and mess around and say whatever they want, and just have fun?

My friends and I were joking around and having fun for hours on League last night, none of us got banned..

TehNACHO9 votes

No you don't understand.

He wants to have "playful banter" with strangers.

With no consequences.

Because he says so.

GatekeeperTDS3 votes

He wants to have "playful banter" with strangers.

The thing is, the people who get banned and come here crying about their ban weren't having playful trashtalk with the enemy team. They were flaming and berating their OWN teammates. Then they make the false analogy of comparing it to real sports where there's trash talk - Hello, you still don't shit talk your own damn team. lol

JedenVojak2 votes

Why are you presupposing that the only reason that someone would want people to be able to speak freely was due to some nefarious motive?

I've never been banned from playing lol for offensive speech, but I have had annoying teammates before and I muted them.

Why is this not an acceptable solution?

rujitra3 votes

Because muting does not solve the problem, it merely hides it.

It's the same reason that time-delay safes existing does not make it okay to attempt to rob people. It's the same reason that assault is assault regardless if it's against a frail person or against a buff person who could fight back. The same reason that bulletproof vests don't make shooting at people okay. The same reason that it's not permissible to harass people when they "could just walk away".

Western society, be it the US, EU, or any other developed society, subscribes to this idea of "the innocent is never at fault". Simply put, this means that someone who is doing nothing wrong has an inherent right to do what they want free from people wronging them. In other words, "no victim blaming". Sure, you can mute. But you shouldn't have to.

JedenVojak1 votes

Muting absolutely solves the problem. If every game a person plays, they get muted by their team, they will eventually either get bored and stop being a jerk, or they'll give up and quit.

Being a jerk is not robbing, it's not assault, it's not shooting at people. It's a completely harmless activity - there is no comparison to actual crimes.

Sure, you can choose to not lock your car and leave 10k on the passenger seat, cry foul and say that your car never should have robbed and that you shouldn't have to lock your car, but you're just deliberately being a moron at that point. The world is cruel and unfair, take responsibility for yourself.

Subdue1 votes

{quoted}

Muting absolutely solves the problem. If every game a person plays, they get muted by their team, they will eventually either get bored and stop being a jerk, or they'll give up and quit.

Being a jerk is not robbing, it's not assault, it's not shooting at people. It's a completely harmless activity - there is no comparison to actual crimes.

Sure, you can choose to not lock your car and leave 10k on the passenger seat, cry foul and say that your car never should have robbed and that you shouldn't have to lock your car, but you're just deliberately being a moron at that point. The world is cruel and unfair, take responsibility for yourself.

Silly analogies are silly.

Being a jerk is not robbing, assault, or shooting people, just as being banned from a video game is not prison or deathrow.

If you're caught robbing an unlocked car, do you get off the hook by arguing the car was unlocked?

See how that works?

rujitra1 votes

... you literally proved my point.

The car is being unlocked (the player didn’t mute). You robbed it. You still get arrested.

Subdue1 votes

{quoted}

... you literally proved my point.

The car is being unlocked (the player didn’t mute). You robbed it. You still get arrested.

Woah there cowboy, you're going to need to read that post again.

Subdue3 votes

{quoted}

What kind of game do you want to play?

One where one misstep or one joke creates one report that gets you banned?

Or one where people can joke and mess around and say whatever they want, and just have fun?

https://www.logicallyfallacious.com/tools/lp/Bo/LogicalFallacies/94/False-Dilemma

Enjoy.

JedenVojak1 votes

{quoted}

https://www.logicallyfallacious.com/tools/lp/Bo/LogicalFallacies/94/False-Dilemma

Enjoy.

Is there some minimum threshold of offensive words that has to be reached before one gets banned? Because if not, then it's not a false dilemma.

Subdue4 votes

{quoted}

Is there some minimum threshold of offensive words that has to be reached before one gets banned? Because if not, then it's not a false dilemma.

Each player has a hidden toxicity score. When a player is validly reported, the score goes up. When a player completes a game without being validly reported, the score goes down. Punishments are assessed when a player reaches certain toxicity scores. How each action is weighted, how much someone may lose from a neutral game or earn from a toxic game is unknown, but the net result is that a player who is rarely (not never) toxic will never be punished, but a person who is frequently toxic, or is severely toxic, will be penalized.

95% of the player base has never received a penalty. Do you think that's because those millions and millions of players have never called someone a noob or told someone to stop sucking? There is leniency, arguably too much leniency, built into the system, which exists because sometimes people get frustrated or let their tempers get best of them. If it only happens rarely, it's understandable.

MT Headed3 votes

You do have some rights. League can Ban you all they want within reason. What they can not do is delete your account. If they want to delete your account they must contact you and reimburse you for any money spent. After that they can technically delete your account. However, their is restrictions on this also. You need to appeal to the "Gaming Board" .. every country is in charge of what is allowed. If riot pisses off say the states and gets a class action lawsuit. they will be force to close their game in the US.. just as an example.

To be honest I am waiting for someone to class action the honor system. I recently got banned cause someone was trolling top pinging for engage then backing off... then taking their own jg(me) monsters then trolling more. I was Honest and meant what i said to them and was banned for it.

Since the ban. I have lost 41 of 44 games and am now gold to bronze. Again they will flag an account to play with people on a downward trend. I just roll with it and no longer care about this account. Many people have been swearing at me for not carrying them. My response is you care about the game. you dont like to lose. Your going to get banned.

You talk. You care. You get banned. I have reported at least 50-60 players in those games who honestly want to win. They just are not at the same stage i am.

If league wants to repair their game they need to remove all banning. Get rid of honor PERIOD. They do not understand the word honor at all.

This include your Periscope. who replied to me last time. Instead of banning people why doesnt league formally apolagize for errors in their ranking system and correct it. My real life job and who I am is one of the most Honest Honorable Respectful people you will ever Ever meet. Being frustrated with people ruining the game should not be a bannable offense.

Instead of just shutting everyone up why dont you talk to frustrated players and get your game fixed. "The guy sitting at home laughing as he trolls and says nothing in chat" is your problem. The players whom you seem to place in silver2+ who lack the skills of an iron player is YOUR problem.

I recently have started trying new players in ranked. 0 skill with the player. why am i doing this? cause i am entitled too. I am losing games. I should feel ashamed for doing this but i not longer RESPECT league as a game because of what they have done to me. Gotta wonder if 90% of the people trolling are just people who are sick and tired of league banning and playing god.

Remove the WORD HONOR from your game. Call it Politeness... call it even respect for others ,. that way people do not care.

Anytime you want to chat Periscope instead of just deleting and smothering the problems let me know.

Subdue2 votes

[{quoted}](name=MT Headed,realm=NA,application-id=ZGEFLEUQ,discussion-id=dI1MAjiM,comment-id=0006,timestamp=2019-09-30T20:54:45.577+0000)

You do have some rights. League can Ban you all they want within reason. What they can not do is delete your account. If they want to delete your account they must contact you and reimburse you for any money spent. After that they can technically delete your account. However, their is restrictions on this also. You need to appeal to the "Gaming Board" .. every country is in charge of what is allowed. If riot pisses off say the states and gets a class action lawsuit. they will be force to close their game in the US.. just as an example.

To be honest I am waiting for someone to class action the honor system. I recently got banned cause someone was trolling top pinging for engage then backing off... then taking their own jg(me) monsters then trolling more. I was Honest and meant what i said to them and was banned for it.

Since the ban. I have lost 41 of 44 games and am now gold to bronze. Again they will flag an account to play with people on a downward trend. I just roll with it and no longer care about this account. Many people have been swearing at me for not carrying them. My response is you care about the game. you dont like to lose. Your going to get banned.

You talk. You care. You get banned. I have reported at least 50-60 players in those games who honestly want to win. They just are not at the same stage i am.

If league wants to repair their game they need to remove all banning. Get rid of honor PERIOD. They do not understand the word honor at all.

This include your Periscope. who replied to me last time. Instead of banning people why doesnt league formally apolagize for errors in their ranking system and correct it. My real life job and who I am is one of the most Honest Honorable Respectful people you will ever Ever meet. Being frustrated with people ruining the game should not be a bannable offense.

Instead of just shutting everyone up why dont you talk to frustrated players and get your game fixed. "The guy sitting at home laughing as he trolls and says nothing in chat" is your problem. The players whom you seem to place in silver2+ who lack the skills of an iron player is YOUR problem.

I recently have started trying new players in ranked. 0 skill with the player. why am i doing this? cause i am entitled too. I am losing games. I should feel ashamed for doing this but i not longer RESPECT league as a game because of what they have done to me. Gotta wonder if 90% of the people trolling are just people who are sick and tired of league banning and playing god.

Remove the WORD HONOR from your game. Call it Politeness... call it even respect for others ,. that way people do not care.

Anytime you want to chat Periscope instead of just deleting and smothering the problems let me know.

Well, your name is accurate.

That said, the terms of use clearly lay out what is and is not allowed. Even if you could gather up enough gullible people to form a class action suit, all Riot would need to do to slap it down is point to their terms of use and provide the mountain of logs that show a persistent pattern of behavior in clear violation of it.

As for the rest of your hogwash, the vast, vast majority of players never receive so much as a single penalty, and of those that do, the majority never receive a second. It is a tiny, tiny fraction of players that continue to be toxic despite every warning not to be, and that eventually end up banned.

There's nothing wrong with trying new champions in ranked. If you hop into ranked on a new champion you've never played before, all it's going to do is drop your MMR, but you won't get penalized for it. And if you do it, say, 44 times in a row, all that's going to do is tank your MMR to the point where you messing around with new champs is still as good as the other players in the game. Sucks for those people who lose the game with you, but ultimately you're just a blip on their radar, and in the grand scheme of things, they're no worse off for having encountered you.

My experience, and what I surmise is the experience of most people who play this game, is that most people go into the game with the intent to win. However, someone will do poorly every game. League of Legends is a zero sum game. For someone to do well, someone must do poorly. There is no getting around it. League of Legends is a snowball game. If someone does a little poorly, that is very likely to grow into doing very poorly. If any of that is "ruining the game" for you, then League of Legends is not your game. Go play checkers or something.

Of the players I've seen start to troll or do things to intentionally lose, the majority of them went into the game wanting to win, but lacked the mental fortitude to deal with someone telling them off, and decided to just give up or troll instead. I report them anyway. But just as bad as them are the people who decide they can't enjoy the game if they can't point the finger at someone else for a game going sideways, people who have to harass, demean, and diminish their teammates because they can't handle a losing situation. I report them too. I gather you're this sort of person, which is likely why you encounter this sort of troll so often.

And by the way, honor that exists only when things are going your way is not honor at all.

3TWarrior2 votes

actually...by Riot's own "admitted" numbers, about 10% of people receive a penalty of some sort and do not receive another one

this then has no way to account for people who bypass the system. If you want an easy example, people are currently using %%%%% signs to "censor" words and just about any method can be used to accomplish this

H@ck1ng Cl-le@trz

one in ten players has received a penalty and there are no ways to determine those who bypass the system OTHER than a manual review. Let's say this is 10% of the 10% , that's still 1% of players or 1 in 10 games

Add to this that people have had to make cases against BLATANT examples of problematic players (one such case had a person losing something like 500 matches in a row...) and the system is flawed

While it is true that people need to learn that their actions affect others, the MAJORITY of gamers playing league are in their teens and most people do not learn to control their emotions until their twenties if not later due to how the brain is structured

Was data ever provided for the claim that chat-banned players started being toxic by using other methods? Even then, they are more likely to reform when their actions are limited than by banning them and forcing a new account

Subdue2 votes

{quoted}

actually...by Riot's own "admitted" numbers, about 10% of people receive a penalty of some sort and do not receive another one

this then has no way to account for people who bypass the system. If you want an easy example, people are currently using %%%%% signs to "censor" words and just about any method can be used to accomplish this

H@ck1ng Cl-le@trz

one in ten players has received a penalty and there are no ways to determine those who bypass the system OTHER than a manual review. Let's say this is 10% of the 10% , that's still 1% of players or 1 in 10 games

Add to this that people have had to make cases against BLATANT examples of problematic players (one such case had a person losing something like 500 matches in a row...) and the system is flawed

While it is true that people need to learn that their actions affect others, the MAJORITY of gamers playing league are in their teens and most people do not learn to control their emotions until their twenties if not later due to how the brain is structured

Was data ever provided for the claim that chat-banned players started being toxic by using other methods? Even then, they are more likely to reform when their actions are limited than by banning them and forcing a new account

I'm not sure where you got these numbers from, but the last set of statistics I saw released said 95% of players were never punished, and of those that were, less than 1% made it to 14-Day bans, and only .006% reached permanent ban.

The majority of players, millions and millions of people, even those which are teens as you've suggested, can play within the very very lenient rules that Riot has set forth. If they can't they don't deserve to be here.

Finally, if you (and by you, I mean players in general) are part of the tiny population of players that is toxic consistently enough to reach permanent ban, the point is not to reform you, but to show you the door. That you are able to create a new account is an unfortunate limitation of free to play games, in that there is no realistic way to stop you from creating new accounts, not an invitation to come back on a new account.

Oh, and as for your your anecdote about problem players slipping through: If you're a fisherman and you discover that a certain type of fish can slip through your nets, do you just stop fishing and let all the fish go, or do you keep catching the ones you can while working on how to improve your net to catch the ones you can't?

3TWarrior1 votes

first, a fisherman is not going to try and catch every fish there is or even a majority of them, second, in Riot's case, it would be like trying to catch fish that are nearly impossible to catch while also cutting holes in their net and turning backwards while standing on their head and trying to fish with that net

If you want a simple example of it all, a bad mouth may be disruptive, but it is one of the easiest things to forget unless they break the taboo examples like wishing death on someone's family. If you compare that to even the recent outbursts such as the Nubrac case, it ends up far more of a gray area

I may not remember any verbal lashings I got other than that they stood out for arguing in circles, but I certainly know who Nubrac is and I do remember a Talon from YEARS ago who decided that bullying and holding a match hostage for new players was "fun" to them

Again, you are also going by the ADMITTED stats. For players that are not caught, the numbers are much higher. If they provide an estimate for how many players they think might be able to bypass the system, then it would be more of an assistance with such data, but such numbers also weaken the presentation value of the data, so Riot would not give out that information

Subdue1 votes

{quoted}

first, a fisherman is not going to try and catch every fish there is or even a majority of them, second, in Riot's case, it would be like trying to catch fish that are nearly impossible to catch while also cutting holes in their net and turning backwards while standing on their head and trying to fish with that net

If you want a simple example of it all, a bad mouth may be disruptive, but it is one of the easiest things to forget unless they break the taboo examples like wishing death on someone's family. If you compare that to even the recent outbursts such as the Nubrac case, it ends up far more of a gray area

I may not remember any verbal lashings I got other than that they stood out for arguing in circles, but I certainly know who Nubrac is and I do remember a Talon from YEARS ago who decided that bullying and holding a match hostage for new players was "fun" to them

Again, you are also going by the ADMITTED stats. For players that are not caught, the numbers are much higher. If they provide an estimate for how many players they think might be able to bypass the system, then it would be more of an assistance with such data, but such numbers also weaken the presentation value of the data, so Riot would not give out that information

I think you need to re-read your posts and figure out what you're trying to argue for.

KABLUMP3 votes

[{quoted}](name=Lost R,realm=NA,application-id=ZGEFLEUQ,discussion-id=dI1MAjiM,comment-id=,timestamp=2019-09-30T18:10:41.040+0000)

Riot is a privately owned company. It's not part of the government.

I'm not involved in the main argument, but free speech is important as a principal not just as an American Constitutional value/

Walmart Karen3 votes

Second amendment does though [slayer-jinx-wink]

The Highest Noon1 votes

I think that you're misunderstanding what the First Amendment Rights are. As RG is a company based in the US, they HAVE to follow 1st rights. This is an irrefutable, federal fact. That said, the 1st Amendment does not protect what Riot punishes for. It does not protect racism, insults, degradation, etc. Most state laws don't even protect those, because in the only situation possible when playing this game, you're harassing someone.

And that's illegal. Freedom of speech is not the freedom to break the law.

KABLUMP2 votes

[{quoted}](name=The Highest Noon,realm=NA,application-id=ZGEFLEUQ,discussion-id=dI1MAjiM,comment-id=0018,timestamp=2019-10-01T22:19:16.023+0000)

I think that you're misunderstanding what the First Amendment Rights are. As RG is a company based in the US, they HAVE to follow 1st rights. This is an irrefutable, federal fact. That said, the 1st Amendment does not protect what Riot punishes for. It does not protect racism, insults, degradation, etc. Most state laws don't even protect those, because in the only situation possible when playing this game, you're harassing someone.

the only argument against toxicity that I can thoroughly get behind is that you are required to attempt to win the game unless your team agrees to forfeit by a majority vote. and if you just leave or AFK you could be subject to bans. I'm curious about how dicey this could get with a really expensive lawyer and someone willing to die on a hill about one specific video game.. that being said, the contract tells us to stay in the match or face penalties which can, by the rules, lead to a ban (Though will usually just be a slap on the wrist such as being forced to wait like you dodged, or being rolled into low priority que).

Since you are obligated by contract to stay, and to do your best to contribute to a win, then I can see how agregious insults that go past "Bro stop sucking" and go into annoying levels of persistence could constitute harassment.

Though there is a mute button.

I don't see why a basic argument is so bad, but I do see why just sitting there spam pinging someone for every cs they miss in a norms game of silver elo while taking every opportunity to say something negative about them to the rest of their team is a special case. It goes from opinion "You're trash" (Slang for calling someone bad at the game) to libel and slander "Report x for inting" and "Report x for trolling" which could cost financial damages if the account that got reported winds up getting slammed with a ban and was an account with skins purchased on it.

And that's illegal. Freedom of speech is not the freedom to break the law.

law geek response Since you're referencing specificall the American constitution's first amendment, I'd like to argue that it, in fact, gives you special exemptions many circumstances that would be considered illegal but due to being religious, political, or philisophical in nature gets to fly.

Certain religions for example are allowed to use certain controlled substances that would otherwise be felonies. Also standing on a soap box in the middle of a sidewalk and screaming about waffles will get you disturbing the peace, but doing so about some political, religious, or philisophical matter will instead just get you laughed at.

it gets complicated, though I'm not posturing for my opinion even if i mentioned it. The legal and political argument is annoying to me because people just proclaim themselves to be correct with limited knowledge of the subject and assumptions of unilateral truth on it.

I do however like the philosophical discussion :)

The Highest Noon1 votes

the only argument against toxicity that I can thoroughly get behind is that you are required to attempt to win the game unless your team agrees to forfeit by a majority vote.

This is true. According to Riot's own rules, anyone that joins a team and enters a game are required to try to win the game or face punishment. This is probably one of the least enforced rules tbh, mainly because it's difficult to prove that a player wasn't trying.

Since you are obligated by contract to stay, and to do your best to contribute to a win, then I can see how agregious insults that go past "Bro stop sucking" and go into annoying levels of persistence could constitute harassment.

I think this might have to do with some anti-bullying stance, but I still feel it has to do with harassment. Riot has said repeatedly that the occasional "You suck" or "stop being bad" doesn't get someone punished but if it's repeated degradation during a match then it's punishable.

Though there is a mute button.

We also now have the power to remove either ally, all or both chats so at this point if there's toxicity then it's on us.

I don't see why a basic argument is so bad,

An argument is one thing, but if someone is AFK constantly typing sentences of complaining and this or that then it's honestly a problem and not just due to the words. In it's most severe instances, the total time that a player will spend typing arguments is about 10 minutes of in-game time. That's 10-minutes afk.

law geek response Since you're referencing specificall the American constitution's first amendment, I'd like to argue that it, in fact, gives you special exemptions many circumstances that would be considered illegal but due to being religious, political, or philisophical in nature gets to fly.

I'm sure this is possible. I'm not that educated on the specific rights provided by amendments but I'm used to having to deliver the "freedom of speech isn't freedom to hate" talk. A lot of people who say they have free speech are the same people who would try to follow someone around a city constantly yelling slurs at them. Or the typical, "Fire!!" in a crowded theater idea.

Certain religions for example are allowed to use certain controlled substances that would otherwise be felonies. Also standing on a soap box in the middle of a sidewalk and screaming about waffles will get you disturbing the peace, but doing so about some political, religious, or philisophical matter will instead just get you laughed at.

Yeah, it's all a matter of circumstance. Now that you mention it, I do think that in that specific case then the person would be allowed to talk about waffles as long as they're speaking at a reasonable level. "Screaming" anything will get you charged with offending the peace, even if it's religious. Most religious people aren't "screaming" though they're just speaking with their outside voice.

it gets complicated, though I'm not posturing for my opinion even if i mentioned it. The legal and political argument is annoying to me because people just proclaim themselves to be correct with limited knowledge of the subject and assumptions of unilateral truth on it.

Well, I only know what I learn at the time that I learn it. The selective information in this nation is wild at times, and its probably the education system's fault.

I do however like the philosophical discussion :)

Everyone does until politicians are mentioned lol

TrulyBland2 votes

[{quoted}](name=The Highest Noon,realm=NA,application-id=ZGEFLEUQ,discussion-id=dI1MAjiM,comment-id=0018,timestamp=2019-10-01T22:19:16.023+0000)

I think that you're misunderstanding what the First Amendment Rights are. As RG is a company based in the US, they HAVE to follow 1st rights.

Strictly speaking true… Just like it's strictly speaking true that they have to follow your 3rd and 5th amendment rights. The point however, is that they couldn't violate those rights even if they tried.

Okay, I guess they could technically violate your 3rd amendment rights… but that'd require a really interesting turn of events.

The Highest Noon1 votes

I think that it'd be difficult for Riot to violate any right outside of outright breaking the law.

More from Player Behavior

More by Lost R