Skip to content

@Riot The grade system

Kank··38 votes·4,170 views

I just had very pretty slow game, Ashe/Janna vs Caitlyn/Braum ,so we were basically just farming, but our both botlane comps allowed us to follow ganks very well.

As you can see enemy midlaner and jungler ganked us. We didn't notice trundle coming from tribush and our ward other ward just expired, so we could prepare for this gank better. But its not the case. Janna ended up with stats 0/2/3 and got C+ even though she supported me very well. We won this game btw, opponents surrendered at 20. It wasn't really a stomp though.

What I mean is this janna could get a better grade if she just let me die there. At this point I had killing spree so she died for me. Perhaps my death wouldn't be so impactful for the game, but Riot listen: You are rewarding players, with higher grade, for being SELFISH @Riot What is the goal of the grade system. You are splitting one game into 10 minigames where players are fighting, and stealing kills just to get higher grade. What is the grade system supposed to do?

TL;DR - veri sad, grade system iz not cool, I cry.

48 Comments

GhaelWinds11 votes

Riot: "We're implementing masteries to grade people on an individual level. Actual: people play less as a team to get a better score. Riot: "we are bringing in DQ to promote team play and not grading people individually" Me: "make up your minds! Am I playing solo, or as a team! Your confusing me!!"

Kank11 votes

Yea. I believe grade should be one for entire team. This way team would have to cooperate to get S.

GhaelWinds7 votes

Ehhh, there should be two grades. With your proposal it won't be about champion mastery, itll be about getting carried. But with the current one it's about playing selfishly. If there are two grades one for team and one for yourself. I think that would help a lot.

Blue Moon Wolf1 votes

They might have to balance the scales for each champ like that. For supports who rely on being carried more than kills and things like that, the scale would have to lean more towards the team grade, while ADC's who are trying to get as many kills as possible anyway would lean more towards the the solo grade. But if they did that, then it could work a lot better for everyone.

BloodyTompon2 votes

That's exactly why they do not release the way it's calculated

lolchemy1 votes

I like that they don't release exactly how ratings are calculated. I don't like that I can't find a sort-able list of rating history per champ/game mode/role/etc with the ability to see the full match results (At least I could look at some games that did earn S- or higher rankings to compare to my own). Without one or the other....how does anyone know what they can specifically work on to improve their play? Also, how does anyone know what everyone else who plays their champ/role does during a game, without statistics to view? Maybe I play champ X differently than most, my team wins and I do well personally, but because others play style is different I can never get high ratings? There isn't one way to play every champ/role combo!!

Kank1 votes

Maybe I play champ X differently than most, my team wins and I do well personally, but because others play style is different I can never get high ratings? There isn't one way to play every champ/role combo!!

+1

Mhihnj1 votes

*you're

CarameI Frappe6 votes

Preach man. I have to literally KILL STEAL my ADC for the system to grade me higher ... as a SUPPORT. Also the system is flawed- I can place a ward down wherever / whenever without a care and the more wards = better my grade gets. Why not grade me if my ward catches enemies in sight? Why not reward me if my death allowed my team to ace the enemy team or earn an objective? It rewards players for being selfish like you said.

Doesn't help that to obtain mastery 6 & 7, you must do it through the hextech system. Like, seriously ...??

John 13 341 votes

{quoted}

Preach man. I have to literally KILL STEAL my ADC for the system to grade me higher ... as a SUPPORT. Also the system is flawed- I can place a ward down wherever / whenever without a care and the more wards = better my grade gets. Why not grade me if my ward catches enemies in sight? Why not reward me if my death allowed my team to ace the enemy team or earn an objective? It rewards players for being selfish like you said.

Doesn't help that to obtain mastery 6 & 7, you must do it through the hextech system. Like, seriously ...??

Really? I don't find this to be true at all. Getting an S on most supports is surprisingly easy, unlike an ADC who has to go 17/2/10 for the S+

How are your assists in most matches? How many wards do you place/clear? How many pinks are you buying?

Çhåryzård2 votes

[{quoted}](name=Yuck Qi,realm=NA,application-id=3ErqAdtq,discussion-id=xiiM542w,comment-id=00010000,timestamp=2016-06-05T23:50:58.981+0000)

Really? I don't find this to be true at all. Getting an S on most supports is surprisingly easy, unlike an ADC who has to go 17/2/10 for the S+

How are your assists in most matches? How many wards do you place/clear? How many pinks are you buying?

Last time I got an S I had to get 40 assists. I buy sightstone, I use all charges before going back to the shop and I generally buy a couple pinks each game. They last a while too.

The S I got before that last one, I had 30 assists.

That's just my experiences, but generally I have not seen supports getting S's and when they do they have at least 20+ assists and the game has gone on longer than 20 minutes.

CarameI Frappe2 votes

[{quoted}](name=Yuck Qi,realm=NA,application-id=3ErqAdtq,discussion-id=xiiM542w,comment-id=00010000,timestamp=2016-06-05T23:50:58.981+0000)

Really? I don't find this to be true at all. Getting an S on most supports is surprisingly easy, unlike an ADC who has to go 17/2/10 for the S+

How are your assists in most matches? How many wards do you place/clear? How many pinks are you buying?

No disrespect to you sir, but I hardly see Supports ever getting S's or above. It's not rare per say, but like Charyzard said ... it takes a LOT of effort to get an S rank especially if you don't want to ks your carries. Usually top / jungler / ADC are the ones to earn an S often simply because of kills.

Don't forget, people usually assist you in getting those kills. It's not like say Ashe went around 1v4 ing people and getting kill after kill- teams are assisting the carry in taking teams out. Also if I go say Leona and have a 1 / 8 / 30 score, because I died so much the grading system will downgrade me despite each death helped kill off the remaining enemies or helped secure objectives (tanks life am I right??)

I main Support, and I only get S's ever so often because Supports rely heavily on their team. If you aren't willing to sacrifice yourself, your team will suffer. If you end up dying too much for your team, it boils down to feeding and it hurts your team. If your game ends before 20 minutes, the 15 / 2 / 5 Gangplank will still earn his S because of his score and yet the Support won't have enough time to of warded / gained enough assists. Even having a 0 / 0 / 19 score will land you only an A or so, because you need time to get that S rank. Very difficult thing, and I am not saying it's for every Support. Soraka / Janna are the easiest to earn S's with, but take in say Nami or Alistar. They're going to be hurting for that S rank.

Çhåryzård2 votes

{quoted}

No disrespect to you sir, but I hardly see Supports ever getting S's or above. It's not rare per say, but like Charyzard said ... it takes a LOT of effort to get an S rank especially if you don't want to ks your carries. Usually top / jungler / ADC are the ones to earn an S often simply because of kills.

Don't forget, people usually assist you in getting those kills. It's not like say Ashe went around 1v4 ing people and getting kill after kill- teams are assisting the carry in taking teams out. Also if I go say Leona and have a 1 / 8 / 30 score, because I died so much the grading system will downgrade me despite each death helped kill off the remaining enemies or helped secure objectives (tanks life am I right??)

I main Support, and I only get S's ever so often because Supports rely heavily on their team. If you aren't willing to sacrifice yourself, your team will suffer. If you end up dying too much for your team, it boils down to feeding and it hurts your team. If your game ends before 20 minutes, the 15 / 2 / 5 Gangplank will still earn his S because of his score and yet the Support won't have enough time to of warded / gained enough assists. Even having a 0 / 0 / 19 score will land you only an A or so, because you need time to get that S rank. Very difficult thing, and I am not saying it's for every Support. Soraka / Janna are the easiest to earn S's with, but take in say Nami or Alistar. They're going to be hurting for that S rank.

The one I got 40 assists on was Nami too I believe. Still have the screenshot of it....the game went on for an hour...

I went 4/4/40 (I wish I had 44 assists though, then my score would be all 4's rip me)

This was before mastery 6 and 7 too so I didn't get a champ mastery token, so now I still need to get 2 more S's....I've been doing well in all my games and warding whenever I can....My teammates are getting S's and I'm getting A's even though I've played a big part in keeping them alive and securing kills

It sucks

CarameI Frappe1 votes

No worries, you'll get there I promise. It's not a matter of how- but when. A lot has to come into account when receiving your grade but it took me 5-7 games with Nami to get one S+ grade, and only 3 to get another S (well S- but still). If you are determined enough, just keep playing with your favorite Support, you will get there.

Hell hit me up and we can duo if you'd like. Try to get our masteries together. Sure i'm lvl 6 Nami now but I need three S or S+ ranks to get Mastery 7 :'D ... Oh man that's going to be rough lmao. My biggest tip is to not die even thought that's nearly impossible. Less deaths + more assists + a KS of 2 or more kills will earn you a S- trust me. You can go 7 / 5 / 16 and get an S+ because of the kills you have overshadowing most support scores.

Çhåryzård1 votes

{quoted}

No worries, you'll get there I promise. It's not a matter of how- but when. A lot has to come into account when receiving your grade but it took me 5-7 games with Nami to get one S+ grade, and only 3 to get another S (well S- but still). If you are determined enough, just keep playing with your favorite Support, you will get there.

Hell hit me up and we can duo if you'd like. Try to get our masteries together. Sure i'm lvl 6 Nami now but I need three S or S+ ranks to get Mastery 7 :'D ... Oh man that's going to be rough lmao. My biggest tip is to not die even thought that's nearly impossible. Less deaths + more assists + a KS of 2 or more kills will earn you a S- trust me. You can go 7 / 5 / 16 and get an S+ because of the kills you have overshadowing most support scores.

Except I don't think its right that I have to intentionally ks my team in order to get myself an S because I'm getting more kills than others who have played my champ...I SHOULD be graded for how I play my role, and it's frustrating that I'm not really graded for that when I play support...I have to either take stuff from my team or hope the game goes on long enough that the amount of assists and wards I have is adequate for an S-

I've been playing Nami for a long time..I got that last S a while ago and haven't gotten one since on her. None of my games have been long enough for me to get close to enough assists, and I ward whenever I can..

I've been doing a great job at getting my adc's S ranks but I haven't gotten one in a long time myself.... :')

CarameI Frappe1 votes

Just played a game as Nami Support ..... 2 / 1 / 32 and I only ended up getting an A+. http://na.op.gg/summoner/userName=CaramelxFrappe

Riot I really don't like you right now.

Cookimonster3166 votes

Real supports don't care about grades :P

Çhåryzård2 votes

{quoted}

Real supports don't care about grades :P

When I'd like lvl 6 and 7 mastery on my main champion, who is a support, I care

Cookimonster3161 votes

It's easy to get an S rank on supports though

Çhåryzård2 votes

{quoted}

It's easy to get an S rank on supports though

No...It really isn't...

The system looks at your gold, your wards, your kda, hell probably a lot of other stuff but Riot won't tell us but I assume its all in that 'statistics' page when you view the match on the web

Supports

  • Do not get as much gold as everyone else. We have items that do gain us some gold, but for half the game we are the only people NOT cs'ing.

-Do not get cs. Look to the above. Our adc gets the cs, try to cs and your adc tells you to stop, because they need it. We have items that will get us some gold, they do not. We are expected to not cs when they are in lane. I do take cs when they are gone, and later in the game, but during the laning phase the support does not take cs. That is a lot of gold we miss out on, but the adc needs it more.

-Do not get kills. While yes, we can sometimes get kills, we are not expected to take them if a teammate can get it. I will take a kill if I believe my adc will die, or if I am the only one who can reach it. My job is to feed my adc and later my team, not to feed myself. Kills count a lot more than assists but I will not ks my adc in order to benefit myself.

Now if the system is grading you based off gold and kills already, supports have the short end of the stick. Every other lane

  • Cs's, and therefore already has more gold.
  • Gets kills. You want to get fed. Being fed = more gold and more gold = more items and more items = more power.

The support role does neither of this, we have a much different purpose. Now, not saying every role is the same besides support, but your goal is the same. Get gold, get kills, win your lane. Be fed for later in the game when we teamfight.

As a support, my job is to help my teammates stay alive and get kills so that we win these teamfights. I want ASSISTS. When I am not doing this, I am warding. I get sightstone, pinks, and destroy enemy wards. Every role needs to ward but support should be doing it the most.

Now lets see what this all counts for. Here is what each role will be getting points for, assuming everything I've mentioned counts

Kills - adc, top, mid, jg Assists - adc, top, mid, jg, support Warding - adc, top, mid, jg, support Gold- adc, top, mid, jg, supports (<- usually the lowest amount) Cs- adc, top, mid, jg

Every role besides support has all of these incorporated into their role. The adc, jg, mid, and top, get kills, assists, ward, usually have a lot of gold, and cs the entire game. Supports ward and get assists, and generally have the lowest amount of gold.

There is A LOT the role misses out on simply because it is not part of the role, and a large chunk of what is graded is generally low. Meaning, you need to do A LOT MORE in the other things we are graded for, and sometimes there simply isn't enough time.

Take my last S as Nami. I went 4/4/40. My Lucian got an S, I got an S-. Why did I get so many assists? The game went on for 1 hour and 4 minutes before we won. We teamfought a lot in that time, took objectives, I warded the hell out of the map, simply because there was so much time.

Now take one of my recent games. Game went on for 24 minutes before the enemy forfeited. In that time I was able to put down around 15 wards, and I went 2/1/11. My adc died 0 times, as I kept him alive and got some really nice saves. I got him a couple kills at the beginning and then he took it from there. He got an S, I got an A. I assisted my teammates in teamfights for the rest of the game and warded when I wasn't. While I did a nice job in the time given, it was not enough in those 2 categories to even earn me an S-. I have only ever seen supports get S's with around 25 or more-ish assists, and the games last longer than 20 minutes.

You have to work your ass off and rack up as many assists and wards as possible during the game, because supports do not have kills, cs, or gold going for them. This means you need to do a shit ton of work in the other categories, and sometimes there isn't even enough time to get close to that S-.

It is hard getting S's on supports without betraying your role a bit. You can take some cs, you can take some kills, but then you really aren't doing your job like you're supposed to. I'm not about to take from my adc in order to benefit myself when my job is to feed him.

Cookimonster3161 votes

Oh I was only basing this off a friend who has 2 level 6 supports (well only 1 hes waiting for blue essence) by only playing like a support.

Çhåryzård1 votes

{quoted}

Oh I was only basing this off a friend who has 2 level 6 supports (well only 1 hes waiting for blue essence) by only playing like a support.

Depending on the support it might be easier.

Some supports are really good at getting assists, others it is much harder. Like someone mentioned Alistar before, who is hard to get enough assists on, while Soraka can spam Q's and get assists pretty quickly.

The system doesn't feel consistent, and seems to be weighted more on kills and gold/cs. Supports aren't supposed to get any of that and usually don't get as much gold as everyone else.

I try to ward the crap out of the map and assist in everything I can but it still isn't enough most of the time

Cookimonster3161 votes

It's based on averages from what I understand. If you play above the average player of that champion you get a higher rank

Kank1 votes

It is hard getting S's on supports without betraying your role a bit. You can take some cs, you can take some kills, but then you really aren't doing your job like you're supposed to. I'm not about to take from my adc in order to benefit myself when my job is to feed him.

Yup, that's true. Grades are all about selfishness

Looknook3 votes

The grade you get at the end of a game is more than just your Kills/Deaths/Assists. It also has to do with other random things like warding and a few other random stats. I've seen players get amazing KDA's and then wonder why they didn't get an S.

Kank4 votes

Yea, but it's still basing on stats. In every game there are some meaningful factors that can't be described by a program. I believe players should still doing what really makes them win the game, like giveing calls, not mindlessly increasing their stats. I don't think that they should absolutely remove the grade system. Imo riot shouldn't give this thing any serious role, but they did, designing 6th and 7th tier champion mastery.

Avarosa Guide Me1 votes

{quoted}

Yea, but it's still basing on stats. In every game there are some meaningful factors that can't be described by a program. I believe players should still doing what really makes them win the game, like giveing calls, not mindlessly increasing their stats. I don't think that they should absolutely remove the grade system. Imo riot shouldn't give this thing any serious role, but they did, designing 6th and 7th tier champion mastery.

But based on what you said there, grades are an impossibility due to a teamwork grade being indeterminate by a computer system. Even if using a teamwide grade it doesn't show teamwork based on the raw stats of the team.

Sancre3 votes

After some time trying to get jhin to grade 7, i'm seriously starting to see jhin support as viable, as no matter how fed I end, i just get a+. 25/5? a+ has been the worst

Vik4prez3 votes

I had a game of Poro King earlier as Thresh where I went 5/5/36 with kill participation in 41 out of 53 kills my team got, but only received an A+. That's about as good of a game as I could have had as full tank Thresh and it wasn't even deserving of an S-. Getting more hextech chests as a solo player is truly a nightmare.

Wheatloaf2 votes

Mastery grade is based off the champion's stats across all games on the server. Janna being Janna, her stats involve a lot less deaths than most.

ZeeWolfZ2 votes

She needs to get 200 CS to get an S.

Let your support Farm.

Stop being selfish.

escape2 votes

Exactly! I play premade with friends and we do setups to get someone an S grade... everyone else die for the person and give him kills and it's easy to get the grade that way. Basically that person just KS and be as selfish as possible and can sacrifice team to get a perfect and high kda...

Kank1 votes

[{quoted}](name=Rofl NeverGiveUp,realm=NA,application-id=3ErqAdtq,discussion-id=xiiM542w,comment-id=0012,timestamp=2016-06-06T15:57:34.815+0000)

Exactly! I play premade with friends and we do setups to get someone an S grade... everyone else die for the person and give him kills and it's easy to get the grade that way. Basically that person just KS and be as selfish as possible and can sacrifice team to get a perfect and high kda...

Yea, I just had a game against zac who tried to get S really hard. And I think he could carried even harder but he was too afraid to die. he was saving his flash for escapes etc. Sometimes a sacrifice, allows your team to win the game.

Nami Used Bubble1 votes

I stopped playing ranked recently because of this crap. Had a brilliant jungler in the first half of the game, pretty much a guaranteed win but later he decided he wasn't going to participate in any sort of teamfight or objective in case he lost his S-worthy score and we got stomped hard because of it. It doesn't help that I've been in promos four times now and if this guy had played consistently, I could have finally gotten past that hurdle but nah, KDA is more important now than LP.

Kank1 votes

The point of this thread is, that I feel like people often have a choice to save their grade or to save the game. Pretty sure there are some people that prefers to surrender as 12/1/2 when their team is not doing great to keep their S rather than trying to win.

Wamuudes1 votes

Many players arleady play Selfish, already snipe/steal kills, already DO let their allies die in favor of not dying themselves.

The Grade system is meaningless unless you're trying to get Hextech stuff. IF you're playing to win the game itself, don't worry about the grade.

Kank1 votes

There are many ways to implement the grade system without forcing players to be selfish. I will never risk kill stealing our carry, a low hp enemy, even if I won't get an assist. that's the way I play this game.

Wild Geese1 votes
  1. Always buy 2 pinks every back, always place
  2. Steal every kill you can.
  3. Always Place your green trinket wards
  4. Buy Sightstone, always place
  5. Don't upgrade trinket, 2 wards are better than 1!
  6. Buy Ruby Sightstone..
  7. Hopefully you can get Soulstealer and Deathcap and are 20-0.
  8. Lose game.
  9. S RANK!
Kenioshi2 sequel1 votes

The main reason she got a C+ is because the game only lasted 20min and she's 0/2/3 the highest rating she could have gotten would be a B-/+ if she had a bit of cs

kaltenashes1 votes

idk how it works, had a really bad early game with zillean support, i gave enemy adc around 4 or 5 kills ='( (report zillean plz) but when my team grouped the cc was just too much that we won and somehow the system gave me a freaking S-

ok i'll take, meanwhile my mid laner, the true carry of my team, didnt get an S

another system from rito that doesnt works, ohh thats new

lolchemy1 votes

Even worse in the rotating game modes. In general, doing things that actually help teams win doesn't give high mastery ratings in those modes....so I've found people just go for those stats instead. Def Not Dom was the worst...I had whole teams who wouldn't ever stay in lane or take the objectives, just try to get kills in the jungle....all game.

Çhåryzård1 votes

To be honest the grading system isn't very good at grading supports for anything in the first place.

While every other role is supposed to prioritize kills over assists, supports prioritize assists over kills, and assists are worth less than kills. Last time I got an S on a support I had to get 40 assists and the only reason I got that much was because the game went on for a very very long time.

I believe warding does contribute to it, but I'm still warding the most and destroying the most wards on my team. I get sightstone ever game, I always use up my charges before going back to the shop. Warding seems to not contribute much at all, which is detrimental to supports because it makes up a big part of the role.

Gold contributes too, and supports are hurt in this category also. Supports do not earn as much gold usually as the rest of the team in general (although depending on how your teammates did you might have more than one or two). Supports do have ways of getting gold as far as support items go, and I will take cs later in the game or when my adc is not in lane, but it I still don't earn as much as my other teammates especially if they are fed.

I usually do a good job at supporting, after all, it is my main role. I have gotten many of my adc's S roles because I helped get them fed so they could fend for themselves most of the time....yet I never get an S.

One recent game I went 1/0/6, my Jhin adc who I had some REALLY great saves on, went 5/0/5. I believe my adc got an S- and I got an A. We both played our roles perfectly, and the game only lasted 20 minutes since the enemy forfeited, yet the system does not grade supports accurately. The support role is played much differently than the other as far as k/d/a goes, so supports generally do not earn S ranks because the system is looking for kills more than assists.

Another game, I go 2/1/11, my adc goes 9/0/3. He gets an S rank, meanwhile I get an A again even though I was the one who got him kills and kept him alive. He got fed at the beginning because of me, the rest he did himself. The system doesn't recognize that I played my role correctly, because I'm not fed in kills. Game lasted 24 minutes, I had the least gold but the most wards placed out of everyone that game, with a total of 15 wards.

KDA does play a factor in grading, but supports are not played as the other roles are and can not be graded the same. It will not be accurate. I will not have the largest amount of gold since I am the only one in game not cs'ing for half the time, I will not be fed in kills unless I ks my team, and that goes directly against how my role is played. My job is to ward, which I do, to save my teammates and keep them safe, and to secure kills for teammates.

I am working on getting assists, not on feeding myself. My job is to feed others, and because of it I do not earn S ranks.

Sancre1 votes

The system isn't consistent, ill present you some examples I experienced

2nd match as support Jhin (Lost)

4/8/26 135 minion 49 wards

S Rank

3rd match as support Jhin (Won)

12/6/14 ,145 minions, 57 wards

took out 5 turrets and a dragon

Rank a+

Something feels weird here or its just me?

For supports the most graded seems to be asistences, and wards, not just wards set, but removed with the red trinket, as it was another diference between first example and second, in the first one i bough ward stone and red trinket, in the second one kept yellow trinket and ward stone to boost my warding rate for the experiment of ward value on supporting

Communist Toast1 votes

she couldn't have supported you that well if she only got 3 assists

Kank1 votes

{quoted}

she couldn't have supported you that well if she only got 3 assists

It was a very passive game. It's not always all about assists and kills.

Communist Toast1 votes

when it comes to the Grading system, it is very much about assists/kills

Sancre1 votes

For adc's its all about kills/farm

As some user said, there seems to be a proportion kill/dead adecuate for getting s rank, this seems to apply to everyone but supports

Adc Jhin 21/2/7 212 minions 31 minutes in

Rank S+

zlumpy1 votes

What if they add an F grade that forces you to replay the match over again!?

More from Gameplay

More by Kank