@Riot When if ever are you going to rework Aatrox
I'l keep making these until i get an answer and i don't care what the rest of you don't like it.
Passive: Remove the revive part replace it with a stacking mechanic that doesn't stack to infinity but has like mile stones that at x amount you get some kind of bonus and there is a cap on how high you can stack. Minions give X stacks and champion kills give x stacks and assists X amount of stacks. This will be more useful than his revive and gives him late game scaling.
Q: Increase the knock up radius. Make it immune to cc effects not dmg or at least when he is hit by cc the dark flight will go the full distance but you will remain cc'ed at the end of the dark flight. Reduce the wind up.
W: Is good maybe little higher ad scaling.
E: Chane from magic to ad damage for better scaling and it can benefit from armor penetration. Give E passive armor penetration that scales with more levels. This will give him better late game.
R: Give it a short aoe fear i am ok with the dmg reduction if he gains an aoe fear.
If you think this will make him to strong there is always the the thing that can balance it chancing the numbers. If you are silver or bronze you can play basically any champ i any role and win so don't get on you high horse and say that he does not deserve a rework and i don't care if you think there are other champions who need a rework more.
Edit: And i am not saying that i know exactly how to play him 100% perfectly and there is no one who can play a 100% perfect game with any champion
Edit: Chance Q to instant stun around him in a certain radius that gives him reliable form of cc. E chance into a cap closer that does ad damage and slows on contact with the enemy. Maybe give every 3 proc of his w a cd reduction (This could be to strong if done wrong).