Don't you just love how Tyrnd can kill you at level 3 with three RNG crits in a row?

Dude, screw the format. This isn't an english class

Does my education anger you? You seem to be agitated right at the start here.

You calculated the damage lucian could do with crit. And?

I showed how Lucian can bypass what should be a weakness due to the flaw in crit mechanics. Yes I gave information that has been seen before, but I also analyzed it to show how and why this is possible. Everyone knows that DNA exists and takes part in how our bodies are constructed, but until someone analyzes the exact way it takes place that information can not be used productively by the medical community.

What, you just add IE and then add 75% damage.

This sentence makes no sense with the context around it, I mean I get what you are referencing but why is it plopped in the middle of a paragraph with no context?

Your 'calculations' made up about 70% of the post. 70% of the post was basically saying crit deals too much damage and is an inconsistent statistic.

At least a third of it was actually why it warps the balance of lethality and black cleaver, while not actually affecting the adcs themselves. Throw in the other third for the accuracy stat and you have 33% of the post talking about why crit is inconsistent, I never said it dealt to much damage.

Then you went on to say how marks men could build crit and Lethality and how that messed with lethality items. THIS IS WELL KNOWN!! THIS IS THE REASON PEOPLE ARE COMPLAINING MORE ABOUT CRIT!!!!

If this was well know I would expect a lot more threads complaining about crit and less complaining about marksmen abusing lethality. Since as I stated in the thread Marksmen are abusing crit chance to avoid scaling problems that should arise from building lethality/black cleaver/death's dance.

The only and I mean ONLY substancial thing worth reading was your tidbit on 'accuracy' which you gave absolutely 0 information on how it would work! This is what you said:

Its funny how quickly you go from assuming everyone has made a post on crit chance to stating I gave 0 information on how accuracy would work when if the former was true you would've seen this suggestion hundreds of times. I was a little skim, but it is quite simple take the %crit chance on any item and that becomes %auto attack damage amp. Infinity edge would have the passive "increases current accuracy by 50%", the dps of any character would be the exact same without any random chance. Ability based adc's may need tweaks, but overall this change would enhance game health a hundred fold.

Also you claim I give 0 information, yet "And even then the possibility exists that 'accuracy' has been suggested many times already but with different wording used". To imply it may have been suggested before, you would have to have at least a basic idea of what I am talking about right? Unless of course you just want to try to make me sound dumb, in which case you would flip flop like you did.

Sometimes it's next to impossible to pick up sarcasm in written text. I'm here questioning what sarcasm your referinging to.

"(Apparently) everyone loves random chance winning fights." You see that apparently? It gives the text an aloof tone, I didn't care what everyone else thought. I was being sarcastic.

I kinda think that the guy who believes that his written piece is flawless because it was written in an oh-so holy college format is a little bit more self absorbed wouldn't you agree?

xD You went out of your way to right a post to call me out and ended with that fallacy and good day thinking you were the king smart ass of the Gameplay boards. I pointed out my essay format after you wanted to question it, again I didn't care, that is why I have no mention of it being in essay format until you showed up.

I'm mean like, this is kinda 101% self absorbed?

Yes my frustration for trying to hammer through a balance change we have needed for years was me being self absorbed. I know for a fact there are at least 3 people on this board that will absolutely down vote anything I post on sight. Nice cut off on that quote btw to keep out the point I was making, you should work at a news network.

I didn't even down vote it earlier as I mentioned.

I'm sure it just lost a down vote since last night from one of the other random people, note I have FEK and it was at +8 -11 now it is at +8 - 10 as of sometime this morning.

doing the 'you're either with me or against me' thing.

You keep trying to straw man me, I have literally only said no one is giving legitimate reasons (outside of you this post saying I didn't describe accuracy enough) that my post should not at least be realistically considered as a solution to a problem that has lasted years. That does not mean I believe people all like crit as is, in fact if I had to analyze it myself I would argue that I simply do not have the presentation skills to effectively handle such a task. That is why I made this comment "Go make your own damn post with the same suggestion in a better format". I am not looking for glory, I legitimately just want this problem fixed.

I'm just explaining what I found wrong with the post and you seem ready to pass me off as some random hater

I actually passed you off as a random smart ass, doesn't mean I didn't read what you said even if I disagreed. In this response I even did agree I didn't explain accuracy near enough in my post.

Also just because the other people downvoted your post doesn't mean that they don't have a valid reason.

Someone literally said random chance is good for competitive games while down voting every thing I said to prove that wrong for league. Judging by the lack of comments I am willing to bet a large majority of the down votes didn't even finish it thinking I was complaining about Lucian or something.

Dude........... there's no argument to be had. You just posted stats.... that people could google and made calculations with the simpliest statistic in the game, crit.

I honestly don't know how else to explain analysis to you. I took what people say and found the root causes and concerns, no that is not difficult in hindsight, neither is inventing something that exists. Have you ever heard of the saying hindsight is 20/20? I am going above and beyond saying "Lucian can still do a lot of damage late game even with bork bc as his first two items" and instead breaking down why he still does damage comparable to a full crit adc without the need for similar amounts of crit.

Then you presumptuously presented what your opinions on the subject as the divine truth by saying they were long over due?

... They are long overdue, you get nothing of value out of random crit chance in a competitive game. If you can give a reason that it has any value I'd love it.

Well to be honest I doubt anyone really knows who you are and I KNOW that the people who read your post couldn't give less shits about your 'format'.

I've been around the boards for almost 2 years, as I said I know of at least 3 people who down vote anything I say if they see it because of various reasons. As for the format issues, isn't that the exact point you brought up originally? I didn't get to the accuracy section fast enough? I can't imagine you would say you "KNOW" that people didn't care about that when you have it in writing above, are you not familiar with what format is?

ON A VIDEO GAME BOARD?!?!

I just like that you put the ?!?! there, I answered this above.

I've seen longer post that yours get positive feedback and I've seen shorter post that gave more substancial information.

... You thought format meant length...

https://i.gyazo.com/cc1061b99020ad2b117685e62a4c3084.png

It is the order in which the post is arranged... Which is exactly what you complained about "Your accuracy thing could have been stated a lot earlier in the post".

Again this entire post is you trying to sound smart, you don't have a single paragraph without an insult, strawman, or CAPS LUL at me. Don't bother responding if you are just trying to get a gotcha moment, this thread will be gone in a week and nobody (myself included) will care about you. Though I'm sure you will respond because you have to be right, right?

But Pete would have died if he didn't crit, he's even died and said "Damn I didn't get the crit"

This thread isn't about things that you didn't expect because it was fast, it's about the random crits, something most people think is unhealthy because of the RNG, similar to dodge before it was removed for that reason.