NOPE,
i'm not talking about a single thing,
you missed 3 information :
1-Determination can be a secondary tree,
2-Riot is planning on changing stat functionning , if you pick determination, you will not be forced to have hp as secondary stats
3-the adc is not the one willing to create the shield.
meaning, JANNA FULL AP + ADC.
Read it carefully and you'll see : WHEN YOU GAIN A SHIELD
any shield works.
if you don't think i'm right,
imagine this :
janna with NO ap
240*0.085 = 20 damages
+39 = 59 damages just because rune on a shield
now
1000 AP JANNA:
940*0.085+39 = 119 damages BURST.
(for comparison DUSKBLADE is 75+lethality damages burst. and 44 lethality is A LOT)
- the 140 ad damages
that's ..... not acceptable.
with

she has around 250 ap + 250 shield due to unholy grail.
even with that
she gives a
665 shield
which represent a
95.525 damages burst on each SHIELD gain
+64 ad on adc.
i'm sorry , that champion become a living duskblade.
i did not even talk about karma or lulu that also have a shield
or rakan.
If you want to do shield damage , you should not be able to o that on secondary tree, it deserve to be a keyston , so champion who PICK it are not willing to use it with MORE burst on auto attack or something.