So I tried maining Fiddlesticks...
He has to be the single worst jungler I've ever played this season (even worse than Tristana JG) and no matter what I do, I can't impact the game consistently. He's god awful from behind or if you can't secure excellent vision. His dueling is trash and you have no dash to escape safely either (just hope Q is enough). His clearing is slow. His kit is super unreliable besides the Q. He gets half his HP removed by just a Cait. headshot late game. How do people win using him without feeling like you lucked out that they chased into your ult. or some lanes overextended in really silly ways? On equal gold, he seems like such a liability.
Last game for example, an Eve with Banshee's Veil would just roam the map and kill me even within our own base while still getting away. By the time I Ed her so I could use Fear, I'm already dead and she's far tankier too. Eve isn't even a particularly good late game champion. If I put the same effort into a meta jungler, I'd be back in ~Plat. 3.
I feel like I gave Fiddle a more than fair chance and I've done OK with him in other seasons so it's not like I have no clue how he plays. I tried him as support. I tried him mid (some decent matchups) and I've jungled him a lot. He seems to suck at every position except in really niche cases and there are always better options. I'm not claiming to be a good Fiddlesticks but I've first timed random junglers and had a bigger impact on games than when I play Fiddlesticks after 60+ games. Even when I win, it's either a snowball or the enemy team "chose to lose" by making fundamentally bad plays/decisions.
/Rant
, its tho only build that works for me. Pump out that utility and dont die