@Riot Garen 5.16 Feedback thread

King of Hearts11·8/22/2015, 3:34:33 PM·1 votes·594 views

I have been playing the new Garen consistently. Here's a few of my thoughts.

I don't feel he's as solid anymore without building crit or building 3-4 offensive items. That's a good thing. I don't feel semi-tanky Garen is as viable as DPS Crit Garen right now. Some pros like Pants are Dragon said that the only offensive item on Garen should be black cleaver, I disagree very strongly that makes him feel just as weak as he was before with the occasional True Ult damage. Its a good thing you are pushing him towards more DPS oriented roles and I really enjoy that because it actually feels scary getting to a late game Garen. As it is right now, late game DPS Garen is fucking scary, seriously. The only problem with him right now is how hard he gets kited in team fights and which is something I know Riot mentioned it was aiming for but at the same time I do feel he lacks a bit too much of "getting in the fight mechanics" because his only reliable way to kill someone is still Flash -> Q -> E -> Ult. With his Q's duration and Silence nerfed, I feel it does hurt him a lot getting to his intended target. To be fair I don't feel like he can be played as a Tank or even a Tanky Bruiser anymore. He's more of a late game Riven with similar role and less Mobility. The only thing which feels out of place in his kit is W, I don't enjoy the abyssmal 30 Ar/Mr late game tbh.

Some of the changes I would recommend are:

1.) Changing his Courage to have infinite scaling but have a very low rating on it per minion killed, something like Garen gains 0.2 Ar/Mr when he kills a minion or a champion. That means you need to farm 300, 200 and 100 minions to get 60 Ar/Mr, 40 Ar/Mr, 20 Ar/Mr.

I feel it allows him to scale more decently into late game and focus more on DPS.

2.) Reverting his Q's silence Duration back to 3 seconds

Discussion. Thoughts?

8 Comments

Critmaster Garen8/22/2015, 3:52:24 PM3 votes

right now theyre more likely to nerf him instead of buffing him. his winrate kindof skyrocketed.

its fine around diamond, and at around 55% in plat, which is pretty strong. if they touch him, i hope they dont massively overdo it. i just hope they keep his current lategame intact. and increasing the resistance bonus cap to the original 35 would be a worthwile thought.

CppL8/22/2015, 3:52:45 PM2 votes

Infinity scaling? nop 3s silence????? nop thats my 2 cents Also they gonna nerf him ,so you can forget any buffs lol

King of Hearts118/22/2015, 6:22:09 PM1 votes

bump

fasega8/22/2015, 7:19:35 PM1 votes

Garen has never been a tank as he has no cc and requires damage to be effective. The rework simply enabled him to do the damage he needed to not be ignored in teamfights. As far as op I don't think so as he gave up laning power for a better late game and most people seem for forget they removed his tenacity on the W making him very easy to kite and peel. It really just people are use to facetanking his ignoreable damage from before the rework and refusing to kite making him seem godlike when he is just finally in a good spot. Dude if you are getting kited that much it means you aren't building the new items Deadmans plate and Sterak's Gate that literally fixes all the problems of his kit.

brownthunder888/24/2015, 5:55:01 AM1 votes

Honestly, I do not think adjusting the numbers will solve all the problems garen faces. Adjusting the silence duration is hard to get right without being to over-powered or under-powered. The problem with infinite scaling is that it forces Garen to stay in lane away from teamfights just to farm. I can agree with a higher cap, but infinite might be too much.

What I believe Garen needs is a New Passive (Not a buff or nerf to his current passive). Right now, his passive and his abilities (Q, W, E, R) do not really have good synergy with each other. His abilities feel like they are designed to go into a fight, where as his passive rewards me for staying out of a fight. The passive is called “Perseverance”, so this should mean that he will stay alive longer than anyone else, WHILE IN THE MIDDLE of the battle. This passive alone should be enough encompass what Garen is at his core, the sturdiest soldier on all of Demacia. Garen should have his passive activate when he attacks (similar rework style like Ryze's passive).

LilxPaprika8/22/2015, 4:01:09 PM1 votes

death recap died to garen had plenty of armor dmg type was all true damage sell zzrot for warmogs next death recap damage type all ad from lucian. was like good grief. just wanna say don't pick poppy into garen passive nonexistent

King of Hearts118/22/2015, 3:50:59 PM1 votes

bump