@Riot As an Aatrox main I'm just disappointed with this terrible rework.
Like seriously? You guys take I don't even know how long to do this and this is what you come up with? It's like you took Riven and gave her some new abilities and made them big and aeo and gave him some sustain just from any damage that you do, it's not tied to just auto attacks, it's just anything.
Aatrox is auto attack reliant for most of his damage something not a lot of top laners these days do besides stuff like trynd or yasuo, or if you're good at Irelia to weave in autos. Now he is completely ability reliant and that is something that people who play Aatrox don't really want. If we wanted ANOTHER champion who was ability dependent we would play Renekton
or Riven
or Pantheon
or Fiora
even or Jayce
hell even Wu
or Vi
since you gave her buffs to be able to use her E more often. Aatrox fits a small pool of champs that rely a lot on auto attack damage that aren't normally junglers or just straight crit
.
Lets start with all of the abilites Passive is just straight gone really, Aatrox has now turned into Garen and Kat and Riven for having just cool downs to work with until he finally ults then he gets a revive. This cuts out soooo much of how to play Aatrox and it really kills what was different about him from other champions. On top of that the new passive looks like something that has a 25 second cool down for god's sake -.- and it's not even something you're going to think about unless you're in lane and trying to trade.
Next up is the Q. This is just Riven reskinned right here. Yea you get a knock up every hit but just a tiny portion of the actual ability, it's like they said "oh hey right now Aatrox's knock up is really hard to hit, lets take that and make that the entire ability but make it almost all of his damage" like what? why? On top of that it's a 12 second cooldown when maxed still, you're not going to get anywhere near the damage you got with the current Aatrox.
The W Looks interesting to be honest, but I can't think of how this even has much counter play unless you have a dash or don't care if Aatrox is gonna pull you or not, it happens so fast you can't really get away, but I suppose with full boots you probably could very easily, which means you'll need to CC someone already for this to even work. This ability I'm just pretty unsure about in general.
Now for the E
What. The. Fuck.
LOOK AT THAT E DASH..... WHAT THE HELL IS THAT that's like if you took
's E and put both of this new abilities charges together to get just one dash of his e without even hitting minions, like that range is pitiful and not even worth bothering to cast other than to slip over tiny walls like you did in the spotlight.
Lets not forget this does no damage so you're just dashing because it's fun or to gap close, and it just buffs you Attack Damage, which is probably the most boring thing you could do with an ability. Talk about hidden power? Cast E and Ult and anywhere from 45 - 85 (possibly more because they haven't shown if the ult gives you more AD per level) AD for free why not.
For the ult This just looks sad and boring. You get more AD, you can move ALOT faster for 1 second(Movement Speed: 120/180/240, this is more than Mobi boots, that sounds like fun counter play) of the 12 seconds this is on (or if you're not in combat because you accidentally pushed R when nobody was around.), and now you've tied the Revive part of his kit to just pressing R instead of having to have some set up done like with his current passive.
Honestly I think I may never play Aatrox again if this rework goes through, this isn't why people play him and honestly I think you're just making him a more brain dead version of Riven with big aoe CC.