If you were able to order your vote into a list...
How would it look like? Personally:
Fiddlesticks > Nocturne > Volibear > Mundo > Shyvana
(I hesitated for ages between my order for the first three simply because they all deserve it.)
11 Comments
Volibear doesn't
Fiddle, Mundo, Nocturne Shyvana Volibear
Shyv > Fiddle > Noc > Voli > Mundo
Mundo > Shyvana > Fiddlesticks > Volibear > Nocturne
Mundo and Shyv, most dated. Fiddle still works but they need to do more to make him more viable in jungle, he has a game defining ult so they'd have to keep that. Voli is just a non-factor for me, never play him, don't own him. I think Nocturne's gameplay is actually okay. I'd say he needs a Ezreal style visual update only.
For me it would be Shyvana > Nocturne > Volibear > Dr. Mundo > Fiddlesticks I don't play Summoner's Rift however (only ARAM and some event-based gamemodes) so naturally my PoV will differ from players that mainly play SR (be it normal or ranked).
Shyvana right now is like old (AP) Yi. Press button, stuff drops. but even before that she felt out of place due to the limitations of her ultimate in terms of CDR/resource generating. She might be quite tanky when actually building tank but her kit doesn't help her much against any form of CC. Nocturne is great for blowing up squishies by ulting into them but besides that he doesn't really have much impact on the game (basically, he's a "suicidal" type of champion) Volibear has some nice CC/peel but he needs x items first before being able to survive an onslaught of poke/disengage from the enemy team (roots and slows don't really help him get in there even with his Q activated). Dr. Mundo can survive a lot due to his ultimate and his Q and E helps him deal additional damage while fighting squishies. He however has no form of CC besides a slow on a skillshot and is just like Volibear a champion that can be worn down before a fight happens. Needless to say, his survivability and the fact that he has a poke makes him a lower priority for me. Fiddlesticks has a lot of CC and some survivability. His E is annoying for ability-based champions and his Q can help his team's squishies out when they're engaged on. With Mark/Dash and Flash he has a way of getting into a fight with his ultimate (downside being the lengthy cooldown on Mark/Dash if he's the only form of engage on the team).
As I said, this is just my PoV based on my experiences in ARAM over the years. We each play the game in our own way so experience and thoughts can greatly differ. [slayer-jinx-catface]